Mismatch between Augmented Reality Navigation Images and Actual Location of a Cauda Equina Tumor:A Case Report

S Fujimoto, Fumitake Tezuka, Takahiro Ogawa, Shunsuke Tamaki, Kosuke Sugiura, Makoto Takeuchi, Masatoshi Morimoto, Kazuta Yamashita, Koichi SairyoThe Journal of Medical Investigation 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Combined use of intraoperative ultrasound and augmented reality navigation seems advisable in cases involving mobile spinal tumors. J. Med. Invest. 71 : 174-176, February, 2024.

Introduction

Augmented Reality (AR) navigation is a transformative tool in spinal surgery, allowing surgeons to visualize 3D digital models of tumors and anatomical structures overlaid directly onto the surgical field. While highly effective for static structures like vertebrae, its reliability for intradural tumors—those located inside the protective membrane of the spinal cord—remains a challenge. This paper documents a significant "navigation mismatch" where a mobile cauda equina tumor shifted 3 cm from its predicted location, highlighting the necessity of intraoperative verification.

Case Presentation and Methods

The authors treated a 63-year-old woman with a tumor at the L2–L3 level of the spine. The surgical workflow integrated several advanced technologies:

  • Preoperative Modeling: The tumor and dura mater were manually segmented using MRI and CT myelogram data via Brainlab’s Smartbrush software.
  • Navigation Setup: A Brainlab Curve navigation platform was used, with registration performed via point-matching on the L3 lamina.
  • AR Visualization: Digital models were projected into the surgeon's view through a Kinevo 900 microscope.
  • Verification: Before incising the dura mater, the team used intraoperative ultrasound (IOUS) to confirm the tumor's actual location.

The Navigation Mismatch

Despite achieving a technically excellent registration error of less than 1 mm, the surgical team encountered a major clinical discrepancy. The AR projection indicated the tumor was in one position, but the physical tumor was found 3 cm caudal (lower) than the digital overlay suggested.

Intraoperative view showing the AR overlay (blue lines) and the actual tumor location (dotted circle/white arrows).

The tumor, identified as a schwannoma, was located in the cauda equina—a bundle of nerve roots at the lower end of the spinal cord. Because these tumors are often attached to flexible nerve roots and bathed in cerebrospinal fluid, they can slide within the spinal canal due to changes in patient positioning or surgical maneuvers. This phenomenon is known as "spinal shift."

Intraoperative ultrasound (IOUS) image confirming the actual tumor location.

Discussion and Conclusion

This case proves that high technical registration accuracy does not guarantee clinical target accuracy if the anatomy is mobile. The primary limitation of current AR navigation is its static nature; it relies on a "snapshot" taken before surgery and cannot account for real-time internal movements.

To ensure patient safety and surgical success, the authors suggest that AR should not be used in isolation for mobile spinal tumors. Intraoperative ultrasound serves as an essential "truth source" to correct navigation mismatches. Future developments in the field should focus on dynamic AR, which would update 3D models in real-time using intraoperative imaging to ensure digital maps remain synchronized with physical targets. By identifying the mismatch via ultrasound, the surgeons in this case were able to perform an additional laminectomy and achieve a successful gross total resection of the tumor.

Summary updated

Abstract

Combined use of intraoperative ultrasound and augmented reality navigation seems advisable in such cases. J. Med. Invest. 71 : 174-176, February, 2024.
BibTeX
@article{fujimoto2024mismatch,
  author = {S Fujimoto and Fumitake Tezuka and Takahiro Ogawa and Shunsuke Tamaki and Kosuke Sugiura and Makoto Takeuchi and Masatoshi Morimoto and Kazuta Yamashita and Koichi Sairyo},
  title = {{Mismatch between Augmented Reality Navigation Images and Actual Location of a Cauda Equina Tumor:A Case Report}},
  journal = {The Journal of Medical Investigation},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2152/jmi.71.174},
}
Figure