Minimum guesswork discrimination between quantum states

Weien Chen, Yongzhi Cao, Hanpin Wang, Yuan Feng

Abstract

In the field of quantum state discrimination, the standard optimization criterion has long been the minimization of error probability. This approach effectively addresses scenarios where an adversary has only a single opportunity to identify a state. However, in contexts where an adversary can employ a brute-force strategy—repeatedly querying the system until the correct state is identified—minimizing the error probability does not necessarily minimize the expected number of attempts. This paper introduces Minimum Guesswork Discrimination (MGD), utilizing Massey's guesswork as the primary optimization metric. We demonstrate that the MGD problem can be reduced to a semidefinite programming (SDP) problem and provide necessary and sufficient conditions for optimal measurements. Our analysis reveals that MGD and minimum error probability generally diverge for systems with more than two states. Furthermore, we establish information-theoretic bounds and identify conditions under which performing no measurement is the optimal strategy.

Introduction

Quantum state discrimination is a fundamental task in quantum information science, involving the identification of a state prepared from a known set of non-orthogonal quantum states. Traditionally, researchers have focused on Minimum Error Discrimination (MED), which seeks to maximize the probability of a correct identification in a single trial.

While MED is robust for one-shot scenarios, it fails to account for adversaries capable of "brute-force" attacks. In such cases, the relevant metric is the guesswork—the expected number of queries required to correctly identify the state. While guesswork has been a staple of classical Quantitative Information Flow (QIF) and cryptography, its application to quantum systems remained largely unexplored until now. This research bridges that gap, formalizing MGD and contrasting it with traditional error-minimization techniques.

Methodology and Mathematical Framework

The authors formalize MGD by integrating quantum measurement theory (Positive Operator-Valued Measures, or POVMs) with classical guesswork. The study introduces several key methodological breakthroughs:

1. Semidefinite Programming (SDP) Reduction

One of the most significant contributions is the proof that finding the optimal measurement for MGD can be framed as an SDP problem. Because SDPs are numerically tractable and can be solved efficiently, this reduction provides a practical pathway for computing optimal strategies for any arbitrary set of quantum states.

2. Optimality Conditions

The paper derives the necessary and sufficient conditions that a POVM must satisfy to achieve minimum guesswork. These conditions allow researchers to verify whether a specific measurement strategy is truly optimal for a given ensemble.

3. Information-Theoretic Bounds

To provide a broader theoretical context, the authors establish limits on guesswork using the Holevo bound and the subentropy bound. They prove a mathematical bridge between the optimal guesswork ($G^{opt}$) and the optimal error probability ($P_{err}^{opt}$):

$$\frac{1}{2(1 - P_{err}^{opt})} + rac{1}{2} \leq G^{opt} \leq \frac{n}{2}P_{err}^{opt} + 1$$

Key Insights: The Divergence of MED and MGD

The central finding of the research is that the optimal strategy for minimizing error is rarely the optimal strategy for minimizing guesswork.

  • The Binary Exception: For a set of only two states, the measurement that minimizes error also minimizes guesswork.
  • The Trine Ensemble: For three or more states, the strategies diverge. In the case of the Trine ensemble (three equiprobable pure qubit states separated by 120 degrees), the standard "square-root measurement"—which is optimal for MED—results in a guesswork of 1.5. However, the authors identify an alternative measurement that reduces the guesswork to approximately 1.423.
  • The "No-Measurement" Paradox: The study identifies specific conditions where the most efficient strategy for an adversary is to ignore the quantum system entirely and guess based solely on prior probabilities. In these instances, any quantum measurement actually increases the expected number of guesses.

Applications and Symmetry

The framework was applied to geometrically uniform states, which possess high degrees of symmetry. The authors provided sufficient conditions for optimal measurements in these symmetric systems, further simplifying the task of state identification in structured quantum protocols.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite the progress made, several challenges remain:

  • Computational Complexity: The paper notes that an optimal measurement might require up to $n!$ (n-factorial) measurement operators. For large ensembles, this upper bound suggests significant complexity in physical implementation.
  • Analytical Solutions: While numerical solutions are available via SDP, finding closed-form analytical solutions for complex systems beyond the Trine ensemble remains an open problem.
  • Practicality of Bounds: Some of the derived information-theoretic bounds require verifying preconditions that depend on the measurement itself, making them difficult to apply in certain practical scenarios.

Conclusion

By shifting the focus from one-shot error probability to expected guesswork, this research provides a more nuanced understanding of quantum security and information leakage. The reduction of MGD to an SDP problem and the discovery of the divergence between MED and MGD offer essential tools for the design of more secure quantum communication protocols and a deeper understanding of how information flows through quantum channels.

Summary updated

Abstract

Error probability is a popular and well-studied optimization criterion in discriminating non-orthogonal quantum states. It captures the threat from an adversary who can only query the actual state once. However, when the adversary is able to use a brute-force strategy to query the state, discrimination measurement with minimum error probability does not necessarily minimize the number of queries to get the actual state. In light of this, we take Massey's guesswork as the underlying optimization criterion and study the problem of minimum guesswork discrimination. We show that this problem can be reduced to a semidefinite programming problem. Necessary and sufficient conditions when a measurement achieves minimum guesswork are presented. We also reveal the relation between minimum guesswork and minimum error probability. We show that the two criteria generally disagree with each other, except for the special case with two states. Both upper and lower information-theoretic bounds on minimum guesswork are given. For geometrically uniform quantum states, we provide sufficient conditions when a measurement achieves minimum guesswork. Moreover, we give the necessary and sufficient condition under which making no measurement at all would be the optimal strategy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2015minimum,
  author = {Weien Chen and Yongzhi Cao and Hanpin Wang and Yuan Feng},
  title = {{Minimum guesswork discrimination between quantum states}},
  booktitle = {Quantum Inf. Comput},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=IbsgUC08Js},
}
Figure