Minimizing symbol error rate for cognitive relaying with opportunistic access

Ammar Zafar, Mohamed-Slim Alouini, Yunfei Chen, Redha M. Radaydeh

Abstract

Cognitive radio (CR) networks enable secondary users (SUs) to utilize licensed spectrum during primary user (PU) inactivity. To enhance reliability, cooperative relaying can be employed. This paper investigates an Optimal Resource Allocation (ORA) scheme for cognitive relay networks aimed at minimizing the Symbol Error Rate (SER). By optimizing the trade-off between spectrum sensing time and data transmission duration, alongside power allocation across multiple relays, the proposed scheme significantly improves link reliability compared to uniform power allocation and direct transmission methods.

Introduction

In the evolving landscape of wireless communications, spectrum scarcity is a major hurdle. Cognitive Radio (CR) technology addresses this by allowing secondary (unlicensed) users to opportunistically access "spectral holes" left by primary (licensed) users. However, ensuring reliable communication for SUs without interfering with PUs remains a challenge. Cooperative relaying, where multiple SUs assist in signal transmission, offers a promising solution to improve reliability.

Problem Formulation

The core challenge in cognitive relay networks is a two-fold optimization problem involving sensing-transmission trade-offs and power allocation.

System Model

The authors model an "all-participate" (AP) network where a source transmits to a destination with the help of $m$ relays using Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relaying. The destination employs Maximal Ratio Combining (MRC) to integrate signals from the direct source link and all relay links.

Figure 1: System model of the primary and secondary networks, illustrating the source, destination, and multiple relays (R1 to Rm).

Optimization Challenges

  1. The Sensing-Transmission Trade-off: SUs must sense the spectrum to detect PU activity. Insufficient sensing time increases the probability of missed detection, leading to interference and higher error rates. Conversely, excessive sensing time reduces the time available for data transmission, lowering the effective signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and also increasing errors. This creates a characteristic "U-shaped" error curve.
  2. Power Allocation: Given a limited power budget, the system must determine how to distribute power between the source and multiple relays to minimize the SER at the destination.

Proposed ORA Scheme

The Optimal Resource Allocation (ORA) scheme is formulated to minimize the SER under various power constraints:

  • Global Constraint: A total power limit for the entire secondary network.
  • Individual Constraints: Specific power limits for each node.
  • Combined Constraints: Both global and individual limits.

Due to the non-convex nature of the optimization problem, numerical techniques are used to determine the optimal sensing time and power distribution.

Key Results and Discussion

Numerical simulations using BPSK modulation and standard wireless channel models demonstrate the effectiveness of the ORA scheme.

Figure 2: Symbol Error Rate (SER) vs. average SNR for various transmission schemes, demonstrating the performance superiority of ORA over Uniform Power Allocation (UPA).

Performance Comparison

As shown in Figure 2, the ORA scheme consistently outperforms Uniform Power Allocation (UPA) and direct-link methods across a wide range of SNRs. The "Global Power Constraint" scenario typically yields the best results as it allows the system to prioritize the most efficient relay links.

Key Insights

  • The "U-Shaped" Error Curve: There is a distinct "sweet spot" for sensing time. If the number of sensing samples is too low, errors skyrocket due to PU interference. If it is too high, errors rise because the shortened transmission time forces a lower effective SNR.
  • Direct Link Importance: Even with many relays, the presence of a direct link between the source and destination significantly lowers the SER, especially at low system SNRs.
  • Relay Scaling: As the number of relays increases, the SER decreases, but the ORA scheme maintains its lead over simpler allocation methods.

Conclusion

The proposed ORA scheme provides a robust framework for improving the reliability of cognitive relay networks. By jointly optimizing sensing time and power allocation, the system achieves significant reductions in Symbol Error Rate. Future work could explore more complex sensing methods and different relaying protocols like Decode-and-Forward to further enhance performance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zafar2012minimizing,
  author = {Ammar Zafar and Mohamed-Slim Alouini and Yunfei Chen and Redha M. Radaydeh},
  title = {{Minimizing symbol error rate for cognitive relaying with opportunistic access}},
  booktitle = {CrownCom},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.4108/icst.crowncom.2012.248456},
}
Figure