Mid-career pitfall of consecutive success in science

Noriyuki Higashide, Takahiro Miura, Yuta Tomokiyo, Kimitaka Asatani, Ichiro Sakata

Scientific "hot streaks"—periods of consecutive high-impact discoveries—are not randomly distributed throughout a career as previously thought. Instead, they follow a distinct U-shaped pattern, peaking during early and late career stages while dipping significantly in the middle. This "mid-career pitfall" occurs because researchers at this stage often lose the close-knit mentorship of their youth but haven't yet acquired the massive resources and large teams characteristic of senior success.

The Myth of Random Success

In science, the "miracle year"—like Einstein’s 1905—is a well-known phenomenon where one breakthrough triggers a chain reaction of success. Bibliometricians call these "hot streaks." Previous influential research suggested these streaks occur randomly at any point in a scientist's career. However, this "randomness" assumption contradicts the lived experience of many academics who face the "Muddle of the Middle"—a phase bogged down by administrative duties, teaching, and the struggle to secure tenure or first-time grants.

The U-shaped distribution of hot streaks across a career. Panel (a) shows an example career with a hot streak (orange). Panels (b) and (c) demonstrate the U-shaped probability of success across different thresholds, while (d) compares real data to a random shuffle.

Methodology: Defining Consecutive Success

Researchers moved away from standard "hot-streak models" that use moving averages, which can create artifacts by stretching a single lucky hit into a perceived streak. Instead, they used a data-centric approach based on raw publication sequences from a massive dataset of 100,000 long-life careers (20+ years) derived from Elsevier’s Scopus Custom Data.

Success was defined as "consecutive success" when $X$ out of $N$ papers (e.g., 3 out of 5) fell into the top $k\%$ of citations for that field. They compared three types of sequences: "Hot" (true consecutive success), "Top" (single-hit success), and "Ordinary" (no high-impact papers).

Two Paths to a Streak

The study identified two distinct mechanisms for success that explain the U-shaped reality:

  1. Early Career (Dense Ties): Driven by intense collaboration within small groups. Young researchers often work closely with mentors and lab mates, focusing deeply on a single topic. This is reflected in a high probability of "dense ties" early in the career.
  2. Late Career (Big Projects): Senior researchers leverage their reputation to lead large teams (10+ members) on major experimental efforts. This transition to "big science" infrastructure allows for a second peak in consecutive high-impact work.
Collaboration and topic patterns distinguishing hot streaks from ordinary performance. Panels (d-f) show how team size, big projects, and dense ties evolve, while (h-i) highlight the importance of topic focus.

The Mid-Career Pitfall

Mid-career researchers find themselves in a "no-man's land." They have moved away from the protective, focused environment of their PhD/Postdoc years but haven't yet built the large-team infrastructure of a senior PI. The probability of a hot streak declines significantly starting around year 7 of a career and doesn't begin to recover until roughly 5–10 years before the career's end.

Furthermore, topic focus is critical. Across all stages, "Hot" sequences were characterized by lower topic diversity. Scientists who jump between too many new topics are less likely to hit a hot streak than those who "double down" on familiar territory. Interestingly, while early-career streaks are often less "disruptive" (building on existing work), mid-career work involves more exploration but results in fewer consecutive hits.

Implications for Science Policy

The U-shape is most prominent in experimental fields where large teams are common, such as Health Sciences. In purely theoretical fields, the late-career peak is much smaller. These findings suggest that science policy needs to evolve. Rather than only funding "young stars" or "established giants," there is a clear need for support structures specifically designed for the "Muddle of the Middle" to help researchers bridge the gap between small-team intimacy and large-team resources.

Summary updated

Abstract

The creativity of scientists often manifests as localized hot streaks of significant success. Understanding the underlying mechanisms of these influential phases can enhance the effectiveness of support systems and funding allocation, fostering groundbreaking discoveries worthy of accolades. Historically, analyses have suggested that hot streaks occur randomly over time. However, our research, through meticulous examination, reveals that these phases are not flatly distributed but are more frequent at the early and late stages of scientists' careers. Notably, both early and late hot streaks are marked by dense tie collaborations, with the former typically involving close partnerships with particular authors and the latter being characterized by involvement in large-scale projects compared with single-top or ordinary papers. This pattern indicates that mid-career researchers lack both intimate relations and resources to keep big projects, leading to "mid-career pitfall" of consecutive success. This insight holds profound implications for the development of policies and initiatives aimed at bolstering innovative research and discovery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{higashide2024mid,
  author = {Noriyuki Higashide and Takahiro Miura and Yuta Tomokiyo and Kimitaka Asatani and Ichiro Sakata},
  title = {{Mid-career pitfall of consecutive success in science}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-77206-y},
}
Figure