Microstructure and Mechanical Properties Ultrasonic Assistance Laser Welded Joints of Beta Titanium Alloy with Multiple Vibrators

Shi-Yu Wang, Peng Dong, Fei Chai, Linshan Gao, Shuzhi Zhang, Changjiang ZhangMetals 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multi-vibrator ultrasonic-assisted laser welding (M-ULW) technique to overcome the common issues of porosity and coarse grains in beta titanium alloy welds. By applying controlled ultrasonic vibrations, the researchers achieved significant grain refinement, leading to a remarkable improvement in both the tensile strength and elongation of the welded joints, surpassing even the base material.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Beta titanium alloys are highly valued for their excellent mechanical properties and are crucial in aerospace and deep-sea applications. However, traditional fusion welding processes, including laser beam welding (LBW), often result in undesirable microstructures. Specifically, rapid cooling rates prevent the formation of strengthening alpha phases, leading to a loss of strength. Furthermore, coarse dendritic structures in the weld reduce ductility, and the high reactivity of titanium with atmospheric elements makes porosity a persistent challenge. Existing methods to improve weld quality, such as post-weld heat treatments or ultrasonic impact, are often applied after solidification, limiting their effectiveness and applicability. This paper tackles the problem of improving the microstructure and mechanical properties of beta titanium alloy welds by applying ultrasonic vibrations during the laser welding process.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-vibrator ultrasonic-assisted laser welding (M-ULW) setup. To optimize the application of vibrations, they utilized COMSOL 6.1 for ultrasonic vibration field simulations, exploring different vibrator arrangements (cross and column) and distances to predict optimal amplitude distribution.

The experimental welding was performed using a 2.4 KW laser with a 0.5 mm spot diameter. Four groups of ultrasonic amplitudes (0, 10, 20, and 25 µm) were tested.

Post-welding characterization involved:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Optical Microscopy (OM) for observing microstructure.
  • Electron Back-Scatter Diffraction (EBSD) for analyzing grain morphology and orientation.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD) for phase composition analysis.
  • Universal Testing Machine for tensile strength and elongation measurements.
  • Laser Doppler Vibrometer for measuring vibration intensity on the molten pool surface.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental results obtained from welding beta titanium alloy samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ultrasonic vibration doesn't alter phase composition: While ultrasonic assistance significantly impacts microstructure and mechanical properties, it does not change the fundamental phase composition (beta phase) of the titanium alloy welds.
  • Grain refinement is key: The primary mechanism for property improvement is the transformation of coarse, columnar grains into fine, equiaxed grains. This is directly correlated with the applied ultrasonic amplitude.
  • Optimal amplitude for refinement: An ultrasonic amplitude of 20 µm proved to be the sweet spot, yielding uniformly distributed fine equiaxed grains. Beyond this, increasing amplitude (to 25 µm) didn't offer further refinement and even introduced some grain boundary issues.
  • Weakening of {200} texture: Ultrasonic vibration helps to weaken the preferred orientation (texture) in the {200} direction of the beta grains, reducing structural anisotropy and improving overall mechanical performance.
  • Increased dislocation density: Ultrasonic assistance leads to a higher density of dislocations within the weld, contributing to strengthening.
  • Shift in fracture location: The improved ductility and strength of M-ULW joints cause the fracture to shift from the weld center (in LBW) to the heat-affected zone, indicating a more robust joint.

Key Results

  • Grain Size Reduction: At 20 µm ultrasonic amplitude, the average weld grain size was reduced to 56.15 µm, approximately one-third of that in un-ultrasonicated welds.
  • Tensile Strength Increase: The tensile strength of M-ULW joints exceeded the base material by 907 MPa.
  • Elongation Improvement: Elongation was significantly increased by a factor of 1.8 compared to un-ultrasonicated laser-welded joints.
  • Defect-Free Welds: The M-ULW process, at a laser power of 2.4 KW and spot diameter of 0.5 mm, resulted in defect-free welded joints.
  • Equiaxed Grains: At 20 µm amplitude, all grains in the joint exhibited an equiaxial structure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Amplitude Limit: While 20 µm amplitude showed optimal results, amplitudes beyond this (e.g., 25 µm) did not yield further benefits and potentially introduced new issues like increased small-angle grain boundaries. The paper suggests that exceeding a certain limit might disrupt the molten pool filling process, leading to defects.
  • Future Work: The paper implies that further optimization of vibrator arrangement and frequency could be explored. Investigating the long-term performance and fatigue life of these M-ULW joints would also be valuable. Understanding the precise mechanisms of cavitation-induced grain refinement and dislocation generation under varying ultrasonic parameters could lead to even more tailored welding processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aiming at the problem of deterioration of the properties of beta titanium alloy welded joints due to many porosity defects and coarse grains, multi-vibrator ultrasonic-assisted laser welding (M—ULW) technology was used to improve the structure and properties of beta titanium alloy welded joints. The microstructure evolution, tensile strength, elongation, and fracture behavior of the weld joint were studied through scanning electron microscopy, electron back-scatter diffraction, and a universal testing machine. The results show that ultrasonic vibration has no effect on the phase composition of titanium alloy welds during ultrasonic-assisted laser welding. However, it caused all grains in the weld to be transformed into equiaxed grains, and the higher the amplitude, the finer and more uniformly distributed were the equiaxed grains. When the ultrasonic amplitude reached 20 μm, the fine equiaxed crystals were uniformly distributed throughout the weld, and the average grain size of the weld was 56.15 um, which is only one-third of that of the unultrasonicated laser welded joint. Ultrasonic refinement makes the joint grain size decrease, weakens the beta titanium alloy {200} direction weaving, increases the dislocation density within the weld; and increases the tensile strength of the welded joint. The tensile strength of the welded joints exceeded that of the base material by 907 MPa, and the elongation was significantly increased by a factor of 1.8 compared with that of the un-ultrasonicated laser welded joints, resulting in a shift of the fracture location from the center of the weld to the heat-affected zone.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024microstructure,
  author = {Shi-Yu Wang and Peng Dong and Fei Chai and Linshan Gao and Shuzhi Zhang and Changjiang Zhang},
  title = {{Microstructure and Mechanical Properties Ultrasonic Assistance Laser Welded Joints of Beta Titanium Alloy with Multiple Vibrators}},
  booktitle = {Metals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/met14040422},
}
Figure