Method Validation and Measurement Uncertainty (MU) Evaluation on Enrofloxacin and Ciprofloxacin in the Aquatic Products

Li Heng Liu, Nanbiao Long, Juan Zhou, Manxue Liu, Shaobo He, Wuying ChuInternational Journal of Analytical Chemistry 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a validated, simple, and efficient method for detecting enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin in aquatic products using HPLC-FLD. Crucially, it quantifies the measurement uncertainty (MU) associated with the method, identifying calibration curves and experimental analysis as the primary contributors to uncertainty, ensuring reliable quality control for these important veterinary drugs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The widespread use of antibiotics like enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin in aquaculture to combat bacterial diseases is a double-edged sword. While essential for fish health and production, their overuse leads to antibiotic resistance and environmental pollution, posing a significant public health concern. Furthermore, residues of these drugs in aquatic products can impact human health. Therefore, there's a critical need for accurate, reliable, and validated analytical methods to monitor and control these residues in fish and other aquatic organisms to ensure food safety and quality. Existing methods often require complex sample preparation and may not fully account for all sources of error in the analytical process.

Methods

The researchers developed and optimized a method for detecting enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography with a Fluorescence Detector (HPLC-FLD). The core of their work involved:

  • Optimized Sample Pretreatment: This was a key focus, involving a systematic evaluation of various parameters to achieve the best extraction efficiency. This included:
  • Dehydration: Using anhydrous sodium sulfate (Na₂SO₄), with 15g found to be optimal.
  • Deproteinization: Employing an acidic acetonitrile solution, with an 8% acetonitrile and 50% hydrochloric acid mixture proving most effective.
  • Degreasing: Using n-hexane, with 2 mL identified as the optimal dosage.
  • Extraction Time: Optimizing both ultrasonic time (10 minutes) and standing extraction time (20 minutes).
  • Method Validation: Standard analytical parameters were assessed, including specificity, linearity, Limit of Detection (LOD), Limit of Quantitation (LOQ), accuracy (recovery rates), and precision (RSD).
  • Measurement Uncertainty (MU) Evaluation: This was a significant aspect of the study. The researchers meticulously identified and quantified various sources of uncertainty, including those arising from:
  • Calibration curves (standard purity, mass, dilution, and the curve itself).
  • Sample weighing.
  • Volumetric measurements.
  • Experimental analysis (instrument repeatability, resolution, and sample recovery). They then calculated the combined standard uncertainty and the expanded uncertainty, providing a comprehensive assessment of the method's reliability.

Datasets

The study utilized real-world aquatic product samples, specifically:

  • Shrimp
  • Grass carp
  • Tilapia

These samples were obtained from a local wholesale market. Blank samples (free from enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin) were also prepared for spiking experiments to assess recovery and precision.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of MU: The paper strongly emphasizes that simply validating a method with parameters like recovery and precision isn't enough. Measurement Uncertainty (MU) is crucial for truly understanding the reliability of results, as it accounts for a broader range of potential errors.
  • Pretreatment is Paramount: The optimization of sample pretreatment steps (dehydration, deproteinization, degreasing) significantly impacts the method's performance, leading to improved recovery rates.
  • Calibration and Experimentation Dominate Uncertainty: The study found that the calibration curves and the overall experimental analysis were the largest contributors to the measurement uncertainty, highlighting areas where further refinement could yield the most significant improvements in accuracy.
  • A Practical, Reliable Method: The developed HPLC-FLD method is presented as simple, sensitive, and reliable, making it suitable for routine quality control in the food industry.

Key Results

  • Optimal Extraction Conditions: The study identified specific conditions for optimal extraction: 15g Na₂SO₄, 8% acetonitrile/50% HCl, 2 mL n-hexane, 10 min ultrasonic time, and 20 min extraction time.
  • Performance Metrics: The method demonstrated good performance with LOD and LOQ values of 0.8 µg/kg and 2.5 µg/kg, respectively. Recovery rates were generally high (e.g., 70-113% depending on the analyte and matrix), and precision (RSD) was low (typically below 15%).
  • Measurement Uncertainty: The expanded uncertainties for enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin were determined to be 2.8601 and 0.8613, respectively.
  • Major Uncertainty Contributors: Calibration curves (Urel(C)) and experimental analysis (Urel(E)) accounted for over 40% of the total measurement uncertainty for both analytes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Specific Matrices: While the study tested shrimp, grass carp, and tilapia, the findings might not be directly generalizable to all aquatic product matrices without further validation.
  • MU as a Continuous Improvement Tool: The paper implicitly suggests that understanding MU is not just for reporting but also for guiding future method development and refinement to further reduce uncertainty.
  • Potential for Further Optimization: While the method is presented as optimized, there's always room for exploring alternative extraction techniques or instrumental parameters to potentially further enhance sensitivity or reduce analysis time.

The authors conclude that their developed method is well-suited for the determination of enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin residues in aquatic products and will contribute to strengthening the supervision and inspection of their quality and safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aimed to investigate a detection method of enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin to be avail for strictly supervising the quality and safety of aquatic products. The results displayed that the optimal extraction conditions for enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin were the following five aspects: 15 g dosages of Na<sub>2</sub>SO<sub>4</sub> to dehydrate, 8‰ of acetonitrile and 50% hydrochloric acid to deproteinization, 2 mL dosages of n-hexane to degrease, 10 min of ultrasonic time, and 20 min of extraction (stand) time. Meanwhile, it was also obtained for the optimal detection performance indexes of the recovery, precision, and accuracy from the tests of <i>shrimp</i>, <i>grass carp</i>, and <i>tilapia</i>. In particular, the expanded uncertainties were 2.8601 and 0.8613, and the factors of both the calibration curves (<i>U</i><sub>rel(C)</sub>) and the analysis of the experiment (<i>U</i><sub>rel(E)</sub>) were the two MU main contributors for enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin together with the results above 40%. Consequently, the developed novel method was suited for the determination of the enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin residues in aquatic products and would contribute to reinforce in supervision and inspection of the quality and safety of aquatic products.
BibTeX
@article{liu2023method,
  author = {Li Heng Liu and Nanbiao Long and Juan Zhou and Manxue Liu and Shaobo He and Wuying Chu},
  title = {{Method Validation and Measurement Uncertainty (MU) Evaluation on Enrofloxacin and Ciprofloxacin in the Aquatic Products}},
  journal = {International Journal of Analytical Chemistry},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1155/2023/5554877},
}
Figure