TL;DR
This study directly measured methane (CH4) emissions from eight North Sea oil and gas platforms during normal operations, revealing that all platforms leak CH4. The findings suggest that current UK emission inventories significantly underestimate these "normal operation" leaks, highlighting a critical gap in understanding and mitigating greenhouse gas emissions from the offshore energy sector.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Atmospheric methane (CH4) is a potent greenhouse gas, and its concentration has more than doubled since 1850. While emission inventories aim to track CH4 sources, recent studies suggest they may be missing significant contributors or underestimating emissions. Specifically, the contribution of "normal operation" leaks from offshore oil and gas platforms (i.e., not during flaring or offloading events) to the overall CH4 budget is poorly understood. Existing inventories often rely on emission factors and may not account for fugitive emissions that are not readily apparent to operators. This paper addresses the critical question of whether offshore oil and gas platforms leak CH4 during routine operations and, if so, by how much, and how these emissions compare to current inventory estimates.
Methods
The researchers employed a boat-based measurement campaign to collect CH4 mole fractions in the air downwind of eight selected oil and gas production platforms in the North Sea. These measurements were taken during summer 2017, specifically when the platforms were not actively flaring gas or offloading oil.
The core methodology involved:
- Direct CH4 Mole Fraction Measurement: A Los Gatos Research Ultra-portable Greenhouse Gas Analyzer (UGGA) was used to measure CH4 concentrations at sea level, typically within 2 km of the platforms. Background CH4 levels were measured upwind of each platform.
- Meteorological Data Collection: A wireless weather station provided crucial data on wind speed, direction, temperature, and other parameters necessary for atmospheric dispersion modeling.
- Gaussian Plume Modeling: The collected CH4 mole fraction data, along with meteorological information, were fed into a Gaussian plume model. This model allows for the estimation of the CH4 emission flux (source strength, Q) from each platform based on the observed downwind concentration enhancements. The model accounts for factors like wind speed, dispersion rates, and emission height.
- Emission Rate Calculation: The model was used to calculate the CH4 emission rate (in grams per second) for each platform.
- Loss Percentage Calculation: These emission rates were then compared to the platforms' natural gas production data to determine the percentage of gas lost as CH4.
Datasets
- CH4 Mole Fraction Data: Collected by the research team using the UGGA during the summer 2017 campaign.
- Meteorological Data: Collected by the research team using a wireless weather station.
- Platform Production Data: Obtained from the Petroleum Production Reporting System published by the UK Oil and Gas Authority (OGA) for 2015 and 2017.
- National Atmospheric Emission Inventory (NAEI) Data: Used for comparison, specifically data from the UK Government's Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy (BEIS) for 2015.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ubiquitous Leakage: The study provides strong evidence that all observed offshore oil and gas platforms leak CH4 during normal operations, even when not actively flaring or offloading. This challenges the assumption that such leaks are negligible or absent.
- Underestimation by Inventories: The measured emission rates are substantially higher than those reported in the UK's National Atmospheric Emission Inventory (NAEI) for similar platforms, indicating a significant gap in current reporting.
- Importance of "Normal Operation" Emissions: The NAEI primarily accounts for emissions from flaring and oil loading. This research highlights that fugitive emissions during routine operations, which are not typically captured by emission factors, represent a crucial, overlooked source.
- Platform Type Matters: Platforms with floating production storage and offloading (FPSO) vessels showed higher CH4 loss rates compared to fixed platforms, suggesting that certain operational configurations may be more prone to leakage.
- Conservative Estimate: By assuming emissions originated from the working deck (a lower height), the study's median emission estimate is considered conservative, implying actual leakage could be even higher if emissions originate from higher points like flare stacks.
Key Results
- CH4 Enhancements: Downwind CH4 mole fractions ranged from 11 to 370 ppb above background concentrations.
- Median Emission Rate: A median CH4 emission rate of 6.8 g CH4 s⁻¹ per platform was estimated, with a range of 2.9 to 22.3 g CH4 s⁻¹.
- CH4 Loss Percentage: Individual platforms lost between 0.04% and 1.4% of their produced gas as CH4, with a median loss of 0.23%.
- Production-Weighted Loss: When considering all measured platforms collectively and weighted by production, the estimated CH4 loss was 0.19% of total gas production.
- Comparison to NAEI: The NAEI reported a CH4 loss of 0.13% for UK platforms in the North Sea, with most attributed to flaring and oil loading, activities not occurring during this study's measurements.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Size: The study acknowledges that the sample size of eight platforms is small, and these platforms may not be fully representative of all North Sea operations.
- Emission Height Uncertainty: The exact height of CH4 emission (e.g., working deck vs. flare stack) is a significant source of uncertainty. The study used a conservative assumption of the working deck, but higher emission points could lead to higher estimates.
- Vertical Mixing Uncertainty: The Gaussian plume model assumes uniform vertical mixing, which may not always hold true in real atmospheric conditions.
- Intermittent Emissions: The measurements only capture "normal operation" leaks and do not account for intermittent emissions from venting, flaring, or oil loading, which can occur at other times.
The authors suggest that further research is crucial, including:
- Broader Measurement Campaigns: Expanding measurements to more platforms across different regions (e.g., Saudi Arabia, Brazil, Mexico, Norway, USA) and over longer time periods.
- Improved Measurement Techniques: Utilizing aircraft to better resolve vertical and horizontal plume mixing, and employing sonic anemometers for more accurate thermodynamic profiles.
- Industry Collaboration: Working with the oil and gas industry to facilitate measurements and share findings, potentially leading to improved emission reduction strategies and consumer confidence.
- Inventory Refinement: Incorporating these direct measurement findings into national and international CH4 emission inventories to provide a more accurate picture of the sector's climate impact.
Summary updated