Metagenomic Methods for Addressing NASA's Planetary Protection Policy Requirements on Future Missions: A Workshop Report

Stefan J. Green, Tamás Török, Jonathan Allen, Emiley A. Eloe‐Fadrosh, Scott A. Jackson, Sunny C. Jiang, Stuart S. Levine, Shawn Levy, Lynn M. Schriml, W. Kelley Thomas, Jason M. Wood, Scott TigheAstrobiology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

NASA is looking to upgrade its planetary protection (PP) protocols for future space missions by incorporating advanced molecular techniques like metagenomics. A recent workshop concluded that a hybrid approach combining metagenomics and digital PCR offers a revolutionary way to assess spacecraft bioburden, providing more comprehensive and rapid results than current methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Planetary protection (PP) is crucial for preventing the biological contamination of other celestial bodies by Earth microbes (forward contamination) and the potential contamination of Earth by extraterrestrial life (backward contamination). NASA's current standard assay (NSA) relies on culturing bacterial endospores, a method that is time-consuming and fails to detect many relevant microorganisms, including non-spore-forming bacteria, fungi, viruses, or dead organisms and their DNA (eDNA). This limitation poses a significant risk, especially for missions involving sample return or life detection, where a complete understanding of microbial bioburden is essential for accurate risk assessment and to distinguish between terrestrial contamination and potential extraterrestrial biosignatures. The need for more sensitive, comprehensive, and rapid methods to assess the full spectrum of microbial life on spacecraft surfaces is paramount.

Methods

This paper reports on a NASA-organized technology workshop that explored the feasibility of integrating advanced molecular techniques into PP protocols. The core of the proposed solution is a hybrid molecular biology workflow. This workflow combines:

  • Metagenomic Sequencing: This technique allows for the simultaneous sequencing of all DNA present in a sample, providing a comprehensive picture of the microbial community's taxonomic composition and functional potential. It's a "discovery tool" that can identify a wide range of microorganisms, including those not previously known or culturable.
  • Quantitative Digital PCR (dPCR): This method offers rapid, highly sensitive, and absolute quantification of specific DNA targets. It's proposed to be used for targeted enumeration of known PP-relevant microorganisms or functional genes, providing quick results for immediate risk assessment.

The paper also discusses the need for improvements in:

  • Sample Collection: Developing flight-certified, low-biomass sampling devices and standardized protocols.
  • Sample Processing: Ensuring efficient lysis of all microbial cells, nucleic acid isolation from low-biomass samples, and robust controls to mitigate reagent contamination.
  • Bioinformatics Analysis: Creating user-friendly, standardized pipelines for rapid analysis, accurate taxonomic and functional gene identification, and robust risk assessment.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a workshop and recommendations for future methodology rather than presenting results from specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Endospores: The current NSA is insufficient because it only targets bacterial endospores, missing a vast majority of potentially relevant microbes and their genetic material.
  • Metagenomics as a Game Changer: Metagenomics offers an unprecedented ability to characterize the entire microbial community on a spacecraft, including functional genes, which is crucial for accurate risk modeling.
  • Digital PCR for Speed: Combining metagenomics with targeted digital PCR provides a powerful one-two punch: metagenomics for broad discovery and dPCR for rapid, quantitative confirmation of specific threats.
  • The "Kitome" Problem: Reagent contamination ("kitome") is a major hurdle, especially with ultra-low biomass samples, and requires stringent controls and ultra-clean reagents.
  • Viability Matters: Differentiating between live and dead organisms is critical for assessing forward contamination risk, and new methods (like RNA sequencing or PMA treatment) are being explored for this.
  • Standardization is Key: Consistent bioinformatics pipelines and curated reference databases are essential for reliable and comparable results across different missions and labs.

Key Results

The workshop participants unanimously recommended metagenomics and digital PCR as a revolutionary advance over current methods. While specific quantitative results are not presented as this is a workshop report, the key qualitative findings include:

  • Revolutionary Advance: The proposed hybrid workflow is considered a "revolutionary advance" for assessing microbial bioburden on spacecraft surfaces.
  • Tailored Risk Assessment: Metagenomic data can feed directly into quantitative microbial risk assessment models, allowing for tailored and cost-effective microbial reduction plans for each hardware item.
  • Improved Confidence: This approach will increase confidence in reducing forward contamination threats and benefit future missions.
  • Key Development Areas: Low biomass sampling, reagent contamination, and inconsistent bioinformatics data analysis were identified as critical areas for technology development.
  • Validation Goal: The aim is to have these new molecular techniques validated and incorporated into standard PP assays by 2026.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges several limitations and outlines future work:

  • Low Biomass Sampling: Recovering sufficient nucleic acids from ultra-low biomass spacecraft surfaces remains a significant challenge.
  • Reagent Contamination: The "kitome" (reagent-derived DNA) can overwhelm true sample signals, necessitating the development of ultra-clean reagents and rigorous control strategies.
  • Bioinformatics Inconsistency: Current bioinformatics pipelines lack standardization, leading to variable results and hindering reliable comparisons.
  • Viability Assessment: Accurately determining the viability of detected microorganisms, especially at low biomass levels, requires further research.
  • RNA vs. DNA: The viability of using RNA sequencing to assess active organisms versus DNA sequencing for total genetic material needs further investigation.
  • Database Development: Fortifying public reference databases with genomes of microbial species relevant to cleanroom environments and extraterrestrial analogs is crucial.
  • Method Validation: Extensive validation of new assays and workflows, including multi-institutional testing, is required.
  • Funding and Standardization: NASA needs to adequately fund research and establish clear requirements and standardized protocols for these new molecular assays, similar to existing PP policies.
  • Future Work: The paper calls for the development of standardized sampling devices, processing protocols, bioinformatics pipelines, and risk assessment models, with a target for adoption by 2026.

Summary updated

Abstract

Molecular biology methods and technologies have advanced substantially over the past decade. These new molecular methods should be incorporated among the standard tools of planetary protection (PP) and could be validated for incorporation by 2026. To address the feasibility of applying modern molecular techniques to such an application, NASA conducted a technology workshop with private industry partners, academics, and government agency stakeholders, along with NASA staff and contractors. The technical discussions and presentations of the Multi-Mission Metagenomics Technology Development Workshop focused on modernizing and supplementing the current PP assays. The goals of the workshop were to assess the state of metagenomics and other advanced molecular techniques in the context of providing a validated framework to supplement the bacterial endospore-based NASA Standard Assay and to identify knowledge and technology gaps. In particular, workshop participants were tasked with discussing metagenomics as a stand-alone technology to provide rapid and comprehensive analysis of total nucleic acids and viable microorganisms on spacecraft surfaces, thereby allowing for the development of tailored and cost-effective microbial reduction plans for each hardware item on a spacecraft. Workshop participants recommended metagenomics approaches as the only data source that can adequately feed into quantitative microbial risk assessment models for evaluating the risk of forward (exploring extraterrestrial planet) and back (Earth harmful biological) contamination. Participants were unanimous that a metagenomics workflow, in tandem with rapid targeted quantitative (digital) PCR, represents a revolutionary advance over existing methods for the assessment of microbial bioburden on spacecraft surfaces. The workshop highlighted low biomass sampling, reagent contamination, and inconsistent bioinformatics data analysis as key areas for technology development. Finally, it was concluded that implementing metagenomics as an additional workflow for addressing concerns of NASA's robotic mission will represent a dramatic improvement in technology advancement for PP and will benefit future missions where mission success is affected by backward and forward contamination.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{green2023metagenomic,
  author = {Stefan J. Green and Tamás Török and Jonathan Allen and Emiley A. Eloe‐Fadrosh and Scott A. Jackson and Sunny C. Jiang and Stuart S. Levine and Shawn Levy and Lynn M. Schriml and W. Kelley Thomas and Jason M. Wood and Scott Tighe},
  title = {{Metagenomic Methods for Addressing NASA's Planetary Protection Policy Requirements on Future Missions: A Workshop Report}},
  booktitle = {Astrobiology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1089/ast.2022.0044},
}
Figure