Metabolic interactions between dynamic bacterial subpopulations

Adam Rosenthal, Yutao Qi, Sahand Hormoz, Jin Park, Hsin‐Jung Li, Michael B. Elowitz

TL;DR

This study reveals that even genetically identical bacterial populations can spontaneously divide into specialized subpopulations with distinct metabolic roles. These subpopulations dynamically switch between producing toxic acetate and detoxifying it by producing acetoin, demonstrating a sophisticated form of environmental control within a clonal population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While it's well-established that different microbial species occupy distinct metabolic niches within a community, the question of whether a single, genetically identical bacterial population can exhibit such metabolic specialization has been less clear. Specifically, researchers wanted to understand if and how a clonal population could dynamically coordinate different metabolic functions, like producing and then detoxifying a toxic byproduct. This is crucial for understanding microbial behavior in diverse environments and for optimizing industrial fermentation processes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Fluorescent Reporter Strains: They engineered Bacillus subtilis strains with fluorescent protein reporters (YFP, CFP) linked to promoters of key metabolic genes. This allowed them to visualize and quantify gene expression at the single-cell level in real-time.
  • Single-Cell Microscopy: Time-lapse microscopy, including the "Mother Machine" microfluidic device, was used to track individual cells over many generations. This enabled the observation of dynamic gene expression changes, growth rates, and cell division patterns.
  • Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting (FACS) & RNA-Seq: Cells with distinct reporter expression levels were sorted using FACS, and their transcriptomes were analyzed via RNA-Seq. This helped identify the broader gene expression profiles associated with specific metabolic states.
  • Biochemical Assays: Extracellular acetate and acetoin concentrations were measured in the culture media to correlate metabolic activity with population dynamics.
  • Genetic Manipulations: Strains with deletions of key genes (e.g., comk, alsS/D) were used to probe the necessity of specific pathways for observed behaviors.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study generated and analyzed:

  • Fluorescence microscopy time-lapse data: From individual cells and microcolonies over extended periods.
  • RNA-Seq data: From sorted subpopulations of cells.
  • Extracellular metabolite concentration data: Acetate and acetoin levels measured over time.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intra-clonal Metabolic Specialization: The most striking finding is that even genetically identical cells within a Bacillus subtilis population spontaneously differentiate into distinct metabolic subpopulations. This challenges the assumption of homogeneity in clonal cultures.
  • Dynamic State Switching: Cells aren't permanently specialized; they dynamically switch between states. This includes a "sucC+" state linked to acetate production and a "alsS+" state linked to acetoin production.
  • Environmental Feedback Loop: The accumulation of toxic acetate produced by one subpopulation directly influences the behavior of another subpopulation, prompting the production of the non-toxic acetoin. This creates a self-regulating system.
  • Acetate as a Switch: Extracellular acetate concentration acts as a critical signal, driving the transition to the acetoin-producing state.
  • Competence and Metabolism Link: The study uncovers a surprising link between the genetic competence regulon (controlled by ComK) and acetate production, suggesting that competence might be a prerequisite for high acetate output.
  • Growth Rate Heterogeneity: These metabolic states are associated with different growth rates, with acetate producers (sucC+) generally growing slower than non-producers.

Key Results

  • Bacillus subtilis cultures spontaneously divided into subpopulations expressing genes for acetate production (sucC) and acetoin production (alsS).
  • The sucC+ subpopulation was transient, appearing during mid- to late-exponential growth, coinciding with acetate production.
  • The alsS+ subpopulation emerged later, as acetate levels rose, and was associated with acetoin production.
  • sucC+ cells exhibited slower growth rates compared to sucC- cells.
  • Acetate concentration directly influenced the proportion of cells in the alsS+ state, with higher acetate levels leading to more alsS+ cells.
  • Deletion of the competence master regulator comk significantly reduced acetate production, highlighting the role of competence in this process.
  • alsS+ cells showed slower elongation rates than alsS- cells, but their activity improved the growth environment for neighboring alsS- cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of sucC in Acetate Production: The precise role of sucC in acetate metabolism remains unclear. The authors suggest possibilities related to TCA cycle overload or coenzyme-A regulation, but further investigation is needed.
  • Metabolite Profiling: While acetate and acetoin were measured, a more comprehensive single-cell metabolomics approach would be valuable to fully map the metabolic states of each subpopulation.
  • Environmental Context: The study primarily uses controlled batch and microfluidic conditions. Understanding how these dynamics play out in more complex, natural environments (like soil or fermented foods) is a key future direction.
  • Broader Implications: The authors suggest that this dynamic specialization could be a general strategy for bacteria to manage metabolic challenges, compete, and adapt to fluctuating environments, warranting further exploration in other species and contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Individual microbial species are known to occupy distinct metabolic niches within multi-species communities. However, it has remained largely unclear whether metabolic specialization can similarly occur within a clonal bacterial population. More specifically, it is not clear what functions such specialization could provide and how specialization could be coordinated dynamically. Here, we show that exponentially growing <i>Bacillus subtilis</i> cultures divide into distinct interacting metabolic subpopulations, including one population that produces acetate, and another population that differentially expresses metabolic genes for the production of acetoin, a pH-neutral storage molecule. These subpopulations exhibit distinct growth rates and dynamic interconversion between states. Furthermore, acetate concentration influences the relative sizes of the different subpopulations. These results show that clonal populations can use metabolic specialization to control the environment through a process of dynamic, environmentally-sensitive state-switching.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rosenthal2018metabolic,
  author = {Adam Rosenthal and Yutao Qi and Sahand Hormoz and Jin Park and Hsin‐Jung Li and Michael B. Elowitz},
  title = {{Metabolic interactions between dynamic bacterial subpopulations}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.33099},
}
Figure