Memory-dependent abstractions of stochastic systems through the lens of transfer operators

Adrien Banse, Giannis Delimpaltadakis, Luca Laurenti, Manuel Mazo, Raphaël M. Jungers

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for creating "memory-dependent abstractions" of stochastic systems. By extending traditional Markov chain approximations to incorporate memory, the authors provide a more accurate way to analyze and verify complex, safety-critical autonomous systems operating in uncertain environments. This approach offers tighter bounds on approximation errors, crucial for ensuring system reliability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autonomous systems, from self-driving cars to robots, are increasingly prevalent and operate in complex, uncertain environments. Ensuring their safety and reliability requires rigorous formal verification methods. A common approach is to create simplified models, or "abstractions," of these stochastic systems. However, traditional abstractions often simplify the system into a Markov chain, which assumes that the future state depends only on the current state. This "memoryless" assumption can lead to significant approximation errors, especially when the underlying system exhibits inherent memory effects or when the abstraction process itself introduces non-Markovian behavior. This paper addresses the challenge of creating abstractions that can effectively capture these memory effects, leading to more accurate analysis and verification.

Methods

The core contribution of this work is a formalism for memory-dependent abstractions based on transfer operators. Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Lifted System: They first define a "lifted system" where each state represents a sequence of past states (of length l, the memory depth). This explicitly captures the system's history.
  • Transfer Operator: They leverage the theory of transfer operators, which are mathematical tools for analyzing the evolution of probability distributions in dynamical systems.
  • Galerkin Approximation: A Galerkin method is used to approximate the transfer operator of the lifted system. This involves projecting the operator onto a finite-dimensional subspace, resulting in a finite-dimensional matrix representation (the l-memory Markov transition matrix, Pe).
  • Memory-Dependent Abstraction: Algorithm 1 outlines how to construct the l-memory Markov model. It involves computing transition probabilities based on the lifted system's dynamics, initializing the model with the appropriate joint probabilities, and then propagating these probabilities through the l-memory Markov chain.
  • Error Bounds: A key theoretical contribution is the derivation of upper bounds on the total variation distance between the true system's state distribution and the approximated distribution. These bounds have two components: one that increases with time (due to accumulated projection errors) and one that decreases (due to convergence to the invariant measure), providing a comprehensive error estimate.

What's new here is the explicit incorporation of memory into the abstraction process using transfer operators, moving beyond traditional memoryless Markov abstractions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical experiments on a synthetic 2D linear system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Memory is Crucial for Accuracy: The paper strongly suggests that incorporating memory into abstractions significantly improves approximation quality, especially for systems with inherent memory or when dealing with the non-Markovian nature introduced by discretization.
  • Transfer Operators as a Unifying Framework: Transfer operators provide a powerful mathematical tool to bridge the gap between continuous stochastic systems and discrete, memory-dependent abstractions.
  • Two-Regime Error Bounds: The derived error bounds, composed of an increasing and a decreasing component, offer a more nuanced understanding of approximation error over time. This is a significant theoretical advancement.
  • Generalization of Markov State Models: The work extends the concepts of Markov state models to handle memory effects, offering a more sophisticated approach for analyzing complex systems.
  • Memory vs. Partition Granularity: Numerical results indicate that increasing memory can compensate for a coarser initial partition, suggesting that memory-dependent abstractions can be "smarter" than simply refining the state space partition in traditional methods.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Framework: The paper provides a formal framework for constructing l-memory Markov abstractions of stochastic systems using Galerkin approximations of lifted transfer operators.
  • Error Guarantees: Upper bounds on the total variation distance between the true and approximated state distributions are derived, offering formal guarantees on the quality of the abstraction.
  • Numerical Validation: Experiments on a 2D linear system demonstrate that increasing memory (l) generally leads to reduced approximation error (lower total variation distance) for both partially observable and finite abstraction settings. For instance, in Figure 4, increasing memory from l=1 to l=3 for a fixed partition size leads to a noticeable decrease in TV error. Figure 5 further illustrates that even with a coarser partition, increasing memory can achieve better approximation quality than a finer-grained memoryless abstraction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conservatism of Bounds: The authors acknowledge that their derived bounds can be conservative and sometimes exceed the theoretical maximum value of 1 for total variation distance.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Systematic Memory Selection: Investigating how to systematically determine the optimal memory length (l) for a given system and desired accuracy.
  • Data-Driven Abstractions: Extending the framework to data-driven settings, including analyzing sample complexity.
  • Alternative Error Metrics: Exploring alternative approaches to derive bounds that might be less conservative, potentially by directly using 1-norm results instead of 2-norm results.
  • Extension to Non-Unique Invariant Measures: Generalizing the results to systems that do not satisfy the assumption of a unique invariant measure.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the increasing ubiquity of safety-critical autonomous systems operating in uncertain environments, there is a need for mathematical methods for formal verification of stochastic models. Towards formally verifying properties of stochastic systems, methods based on discrete, finite Markov approximations -- abstractions -- thereof have surged in recent years. These are found in contexts where: either a) one only has partial, discrete observations of the underlying continuous stochastic process, or b) the original system is too complex to analyze, so one partitions the continuous state-space of the original system to construct a handleable, finite-state model thereof. In both cases, the abstraction is an approximation of the discrete stochastic process that arises precisely from the discretization of the underlying continuous process. The fact that the abstraction is Markov and the discrete process is not (even though the original one is) leads to approximation errors. Towards accounting for non-Markovianity, we introduce memory-dependent abstractions for stochastic systems, capturing dynamics with memory effects. Our contribution is twofold. First, we provide a formalism for memory-dependent abstractions based on transfer operators. Second, we quantify the approximation error by upper bounding the total variation distance between the true continuous state distribution and its discrete approximation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{banse2025memory,
  author = {Adrien Banse and Giannis Delimpaltadakis and Luca Laurenti and Manuel Mazo and Raphaël M. Jungers},
  title = {{Memory-dependent abstractions of stochastic systems through the lens of transfer operators}},
  booktitle = {Hscc},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1145/3716863.3718039},
}
Figure