Mega-cities dominate China's urban greening

Xiaoxin Zhang, Martin Brandt, Xiaoye Tong, Xiaowei Tong, Wenmin Zhang, Florian Reiner, Sizhuo Li, Tian Feng, Yuemin Yue, Weiqi Zhou, Bin Chen, Xiangming Xiao, Rasmus Fensholt

Abstract: Trees play a crucial role in urban environments, offering various ecosystem services that contribute to public health and human well-being. China has initiated a range of urban greening policies over the past decades; however, monitoring their impact on urban tree dynamics at a national scale has proven challenging. In this study, we deployed nano-satellites to quantify urban tree coverage in all major Chinese cities larger than 50 km² in 2010 and 2019. Our findings indicate that approximately 6000 km² (11%) of urban areas were covered by trees in 2019, and 76% of these cities experienced an increase in tree cover compared to 2010. Notably, the increase in tree cover in mega-cities such as Beijing and Shanghai was approximately twice as large as in most other cities (7.69% vs 3.94%). The study employs a data-driven approach towards assessing urban tree cover changes in relation to greening policies, showing clear signs of tree cover increases but also suggesting an uneven implementation primarily benefiting a few mega-cities.

Introduction

Urban trees are vital for public health, providing shade, filtering air, and sequestering carbon. While China has implemented aggressive "urban greening" policies since the 1990s, tracking their success at a national scale has been notoriously difficult. Most previous studies relied on "greenness" indices like the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) from low-resolution satellites. However, these indices often fail to distinguish between trees, manicured lawns, or weeds. Furthermore, urban environments are "patchy"—trees are often small and interspersed with building shadows, making them invisible to standard 10m- or 30m-resolution sensors. This study provides a precise, tree-specific accounting of China’s urban canopy dynamics from 2010 to 2019.

Methodology

The researchers employed a data-driven approach using a U-Net convolutional neural network for semantic segmentation. To bridge the decade, they combined 3-meter resolution imagery from the PlanetScope constellation (2019) with 5-meter resolution data from RapidEye (2010). The imagery was up-sampled to 1-meter resolution using bilinear interpolation to better capture tree boundaries and small clusters. The model utilized the Tversky loss function, which allows for fine-tuning the balance between false positives and false negatives, a critical factor for detecting small, isolated urban trees.

National Urban Tree Canopy Status

In 2019, approximately 6,000 km² (11%) of major Chinese urban areas were covered by trees. The deep learning model achieved an overall accuracy of 90% for 2019 data, significantly outperforming traditional land-cover products which missed nearly 42% of trees because they were in clusters smaller than 100 m².

Figure 1: Spatial distribution and statistical summary of urban tree cover across China in 2019.

Dynamics of Urban Greening and the Mega-City Advantage

The study reveals that 76% of cities saw an increase in tree cover between 2010 and 2019, with a national average increase of 4.57%. However, there is a clear "wealth gap" in urban greening. Mega-cities like Beijing and Shanghai, along with large cities like Shenzhen and Guangzhou, have significantly higher tree cover and faster growth rates. Mega-cities saw a 7.69% increase in tree cover, while small and medium cities averaged only ~3.9%. This likely reflects larger municipal budgets for both planting and the high maintenance costs, such as irrigation, required to sustain urban forests.

Figure 2: Changes in urban tree cover from 2010 to 2019, illustrating the growth trends and the disparity between mega-cities and smaller urban areas.

Key Insights

  • Greenness vs. Trees: The researchers found only a weak relationship ($r^2=0.10$) between changes in NDVI and actual tree cover. This highlights that "greening" seen in lower-resolution studies might just be increases in grass or shrubs, which do not provide the same level of ecosystem services as trees.
  • The Urbanization Lag: In newly developed areas, tree cover initially drops as land is cleared. While policies eventually catch up, there is a lag; trees planted after 2016 are often still too small to be captured by satellites, leading to a temporary "loss" in data.
  • Climatic Constraints: Geography remains a significant factor. Cities in arid Northwest China struggle to maintain canopies compared to the humid South and Southwest.

Limitations and Future Work

Many cities rely on fast-growing monocultures (like willows and poplars), which are cost-effective but vulnerable to pests and diseases. Future research should focus on the quality and biodiversity of urban forests. Additionally, in dry regions, the high cost of irrigation raises questions about the long-term sustainability of these greening projects. As high-resolution data becomes more accessible, these methods can be applied globally to track progress toward UN Sustainable Development Goals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Trees play a crucial role in urban environments, offering various ecosystem services that contribute to public health and human well-being. China has initiated a range of urban greening policies over the past decades, however, monitoring their impact on urban tree dynamics at a national scale has proven challenging. In this study, we deployed nano-satellites to quantify urban tree coverage in all major Chinese cities larger than 50 km2 in 2010 and 2019. Our findings indicate that approximately 6000 km2 (11%) of urban areas were covered by trees in 2019, and 76% of these cities experienced an increase in tree cover compared to 2010. Notably, the increase in tree cover in mega-cities such as Beijing, and Shanghai was approximately twice as large as in most other cities (7.69% vs 3.94%). The study employs a data-driven approach towards assessing urban tree cover changes in relation to greening policies, showing clear signs of tree cover increases but also suggesting an uneven implementation primarily benefiting a few mega-cities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025mega,
  author = {Xiaoxin Zhang and Martin Brandt and Xiaoye Tong and Xiaowei Tong and Wenmin Zhang and Florian Reiner and Sizhuo Li and Tian Feng and Yuemin Yue and Weiqi Zhou and Bin Chen and Xiangming Xiao and Rasmus Fensholt},
  title = {{Mega-cities dominate China's urban greening}},
  booktitle = {Nature Cities},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s44284-025-00227-9},
}
Figure