Measuring Modular Matrices by Shearing Lattices

Yi‐Zhuang You, Meng ChengarXiv 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: A topologically ordered phase on a torus possesses degenerate ground states that transform nontrivially under the modular transformations of the torus, generated by Dehn twists. Representation of modular transformations on the ground states (modular matrices) characterizes the topological order. We show that the modular matrices can be numerically measured as the non-Abelian Berry phase of adiabatic deformations of the lattice model placed on a torus. We apply this method to the example of a gauged $p_x+i p_y$ superconductor, and show that the result is consistent with the topological quantum field theory descriptions.

Introduction

Topological order is a fundamental concept in modern condensed matter physics, yet it remains notoriously difficult to detect because it cannot be characterized by local order parameters. Instead, it is defined by long-range entanglement and the way ground states transform under global changes to the manifold's topology. This paper presents a robust numerical method for identifying topological order by simulating a "shear" deformation on a lattice to directly measure the modular $S$ and $T$ matrices via the non-Abelian Berry phase.

The Problem: Detecting Global Topology

On a torus, a topologically ordered system has degenerate ground states. When a "Dehn twist" is performed—essentially cutting the torus, twisting it by $360^\circ$, and gluing it back together—the ground states transform into one another. These transformations are described by modular matrices ($S$ and $T$), which act as the "DNA" of the phase, containing information about quasiparticle statistics, fusion rules, and the chiral central charge.

While theoretical tools exist to calculate these for field theories, extracting them from a microscopic lattice Hamiltonian is numerically challenging. Previous methods often relied on indirect measures like entanglement entropy, which can be limited by specific geometries.

The Method: Adiabatic Shearing

The authors introduce a direct approach: Adiabatic Shearing. On a square lattice, a Dehn twist is implemented by smoothly "shearing" the bonds. This involves weakening horizontal bonds while strengthening diagonal bonds until the lattice is effectively shifted by one unit.

Lattice shearing on a torus representing different twist sectors.

As the Hamiltonian is slowly (adiabatically) deformed through this shearing cycle, the system accumulates a non-Abelian Berry phase. Because there are multiple degenerate ground states, this phase is a matrix—the modular $T$ matrix. The measured Berry phase $\Theta$ contains both a non-universal "area law" part (proportional to the system size $L^2$) and a universal topological part $\alpha$: $$\Theta = \alpha + \beta L^2 + O(L^{-2})$$ By simulating different lattice sizes, the authors extract the universal $\alpha$.

Key Results

The method was validated using numerical simulations of a lattice $p_x + ip_y$ superconductor Hamiltonian. The authors successfully extracted the $S$ and $T$ matrices, finding universal phases $\alpha_{00} = \pi/12$ and $\alpha_{01} = -\pi/24$. These results are perfectly consistent with the Ising anyon model predicted by topological quantum field theory (TQFT).

Extraction of the universal phase $\alpha$ and detection of the topological phase transition.

Furthermore, the method effectively detects phase transitions. As shown in the figure above, the universal phase $\alpha$ drops abruptly to zero when the chemical potential $\mu$ moves the system from a topological phase ($|\mu| < 4$) to a trivial phase ($|\mu| > 4$). The non-universal coefficient $\beta$ was also found to relate to the Hall viscosity of the quantum fluid, bridging topological data and hydrodynamics.

Conclusion

This shearing method provides a powerful new tool for the numerical classification of exotic quantum matter. While the current study focuses on free-fermion systems, the approach is general and could be applied to more complex, interacting systems like fractional Chern insulators. Future work may explore "G-crossed" modular data to classify symmetry-protected topological (SPT) orders, further expanding our ability to map the landscape of topological phases.

Summary updated

Abstract

A topologically ordered phase on a torus possesses degenerate ground states that transform nontrivially under the modular transformations of the torus, generated by Dehn twists. Representation of modular transformations on the ground states (modular matrices) characterizes the topological order. We show that the modular matrices can be numerically measured as the non-Abelian Berry phase of adiabatic deformations of the lattice model placed on a torus. We apply this method to the example of a gauged $p_x+i p_y$ superconductor, and show that the result is consistent with the topological quantum field theory descriptions.
BibTeX
@misc{you2015measuring,
  author = {Yi‐Zhuang You and Meng Cheng},
  title = {{Measuring Modular Matrices by Shearing Lattices}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1502.03192},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.03192},
}
Figure