Measurement report: Surface exchange fluxes of HONO during the growth process of paddy fields in the Huaihe River Basin, China

Fanhao Meng, Baobin Han, Min Qin, Fang Wu, Ke Tang, Dou Shao, Zhitang Liao, Jun Duan, Yan Feng, Yong Huang, Ting Ni, Pinhua Xie

TL;DR

This study quantifies nitrous acid (HONO) fluxes from paddy fields in China, revealing that agricultural activities like tilling significantly boost HONO emissions. The research highlights a dual source for HONO: soil biological processes and light-driven conversion of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) on surfaces, both crucial for understanding atmospheric chemistry and the reactive nitrogen cycle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nitrous acid (HONO) is a key player in atmospheric chemistry, acting as a significant precursor to hydroxyl radicals (OH), which drive the atmosphere's self-cleaning capacity. Despite its importance, the mechanisms behind HONO formation, especially during the daytime, remain poorly understood. This knowledge gap is particularly pronounced for agricultural environments, where soil emissions are suspected to be a major source. Existing studies on HONO fluxes are scarce, especially in unique agricultural settings like paddy fields, hindering our ability to accurately model reactive nitrogen budgets and atmospheric oxidation. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing in-situ measurements of HONO fluxes across various agricultural management stages in a typical Chinese paddy field ecosystem.

Methods

The researchers employed the aerodynamic gradient (AG) method to measure HONO, NO, and NO2 fluxes. This technique relies on measuring concentration differences at two different heights above the surface and using atmospheric turbulence parameters to calculate the vertical flux. They coupled this with broadband cavity-enhanced absorption spectroscopy (BBCEAS) for high-resolution HONO and NO2 measurements and a chemiluminescence instrument for NO. The experiment was conducted over a period of several weeks, capturing different agricultural management activities. They also performed source analysis and sensitivity tests to disentangle the contributions of various HONO production pathways.

Datasets

The study utilized meteorological data (wind speed, direction, temperature, humidity, precipitation, solar radiation) and soil parameters (soil temperature, water-filled pore space) collected concurrently with the gas flux measurements. The primary dataset generated and analyzed in this paper is the time series of HONO, NO, and NO2 concentrations and their corresponding fluxes measured over the paddy field.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tillage is a HONO powerhouse: Rotary tillage, a common agricultural practice, dramatically increased both HONO and NO fluxes, suggesting soil disturbance is a major driver of emissions.
  • Dual HONO sources: The research strongly indicates that HONO production in paddy fields is a combination of biological emissions from the soil and chemical reactions involving NO2 on ground surfaces, especially under sunlight.
  • Sunlight matters: A significant correlation between HONO flux and the product of NO2 photolysis frequency (J(NO2)) and NO2 concentration points to light-driven conversion as a key daytime HONO source.
  • Soil moisture's complex role: While high soil moisture (like in flooded fields) generally suppressed emissions, the study noted that fertilization could still enhance HONO release even under wet conditions, though less dramatically than tillage.
  • Paddy fields are significant contributors: The observed HONO fluxes were comparable to or higher than those reported for other agricultural settings, highlighting the importance of these ecosystems in regional HONO budgets.

Key Results

  • Upward HONO and NO fluxes: Average hourly fluxes were 0.07 ± 0.22 nmol m⁻² s⁻¹ for HONO and 0.19 ± 0.53 nmol m⁻² s⁻¹ for NO.
  • NO2 deposition: NO2 showed a deposition flux to the ground, with an average of -0.42 ± 0.44 nmol m⁻² s⁻¹.
  • Tillage peaks: Continuous peaks in HONO and NO fluxes were observed during rotary tillage, with a significant correlation (R = 0.77) between them.
  • Daytime HONO correlation: A significant correlation (R = 0.60) was found between HONO flux and the product of J(NO2) × NO2 during the day.
  • Unknown HONO source: An "unknown" HONO source (Punknown) showed higher daytime and lower nighttime values, with sensitivity tests suggesting photo-enhanced NO2 conversion on the ground could explain daytime Punknown, while soil emissions explained nighttime values.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study was conducted at a single site, representing a typical rice-wheat rotation ecosystem. They suggest that future work should include measurements across a wider range of agricultural settings and seasons to better understand the variability of HONO fluxes. Additionally, while they identified key HONO sources, further research is needed to fully characterize the contribution of pathways like HNO3 photolysis, especially under varying atmospheric conditions. The study also points out discrepancies between laboratory and field observations under high soil water content, indicating a need for more integrated research to resolve these differences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Significant amounts of nitrous acid (HONO) released from soil affect the chemistry of the troposphere, thereby serving as a major precursor to hydroxyl radicals. However, the scarcity of in situ data on soil–atmosphere HONO exchange flux has constrained the understanding of emission mechanisms and the budget of reactive nitrogen. Herein, we performed measurements of HONO and NOx fluxes over paddy fields in the Huaihe River Basin. The entire experiment involved various agricultural-management activities, including rotary tillage, flood irrigation, fertilization, paddy cultivation and growth, and top dressing. HONO and NO exhibited more upward fluxes, whereas NO2 was deposited on the ground, with average hourly fluxes of 0.07±0.22, 0.19±0.53, and -0.42±0.44 nmol m−2 s−1, respectively. Continuous peaks in HONO and NO fluxes were observed during the rotary tillage period, and they exhibited a significant correlation (R=0.77). Moreover, a significant correlation (R=0.60) between HONO flux and the product of J(NO2) × NO2 was observed during the daytime. The results indicate that both biological emissions from soil and light-driven NO2 conversion are likely active, collectively influencing the diurnal pattern of HONO flux. A source analysis revealed that the unknown HONO source (Punknown) exhibited a diurnal pattern with higher daytime and lower nighttime values. Sensitivity tests demonstrated that photo-enhanced NO2 conversion on the ground could adequately explain Punknown, while nocturnal HONO production derived from soil emission fluxes (ranging from 0.32 to 0.79 ppbv h−1) could sufficiently elucidate nighttime Punknown values. Our study emphasized the variability in HONO fluxes across various agricultural-management activities, as well as the importance of heterogeneous NO2 conversion on ground surfaces and soil emissions in HONO production.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{meng2024measurement,
  author = {Fanhao Meng and Baobin Han and Min Qin and Fang Wu and Ke Tang and Dou Shao and Zhitang Liao and Jun Duan and Yan Feng and Yong Huang and Ting Ni and Pinhua Xie},
  title = {{Measurement report: Surface exchange fluxes of HONO during the growth process of paddy fields in the Huaihe River Basin, China}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-24-14191-2024},
}
Figure