Measurement of Solar $pp$ Neutrino Flux using Electron Recoil Data from PandaX-4T Commissioning Run

Xiaoying Lü, Abdusalam Abdukerim, Zihao Bo, Wei Chen, Xun Chen, C. H. Cheng, Zhaokan Cheng, Xiangyi Cui, Yingjie 英杰 Fan 樊, Deqing Fang, Changbo Fu, Mengting Fu, Li‐Sheng Geng, Karl Giboni, Linhui Gu, Xuyuan Guo, Chencheng Han, K. Han, Changda He, Jinrong He, Di Huang, Yanlin Huang, J. Huang, Zhou Huang, Ruquan Hou, Yu Hou, Xiangdong Ji, Yonglin Ju, Chenxiang Li, Jiafu Li, Mingchuan Li, Shuaijie Li, Tao Li, Qing Lin, Jianglai Liu, Congcong Lu, Lingyin Luo, Yunyang Luo, Wenbo Ma, Y. G., Yajun Mao, Yue Meng, Xuyang Ning, Binyu Pang, Ningchun Qi, Zhicheng Qian, Xiangxiang Ren, Nasir Shaheed, Xiaofeng Shang, Xiyuan Shao, Guofang Shen, Lin Si, Wenliang Sun, Andi Tan, Yi Tao, Anqing Wang, Meng Wang, Qiuhong Wang, Shaobo Wang, Siguang Wang, Wei Wang, Xiuli Wang, Zhou Wang, Yuehuan Wei, Mengmeng Wu, Weihao Wu, Jingkai Xia, Mengjiao Xiao, Xiang Xiao, Pengwei Xie, Binbin Yan, Xiyu Yan, Jijun Yang, Yong Yang, Yukun Yao, Chunxu Yu, Ying Yuan, Zhe Yuan, Xinning Zeng, Dan Zhang, Minzhen Zhang, Peng Zhang, Shibo Zhang, Shu Zhang, Tao Zhang, R. T. Zhang, Yang Zhang, Yingxin Zhang, Yuanyuan Zhang, Li Zhao, Qibin Zheng, Jifang ZhouarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The proton-proton ($pp$) fusion chain dominates the neutrino production from the Sun. The uncertainty of the predicted $pp$ neutrino flux is at the sub-percent level, whereas that of the best measurement is $\mathcal{O}(10\%)$. In this paper, we present the first result to measure the solar $pp$ neutrinos in the electron recoil energy range from 24 to 144 keV, using the PandaX-4T commissioning data with 0.63 tonne$\times$year exposure. The $pp$ neutrino flux is determined to be $(8.0 \pm 3.9 \,{\rm{(stat)}} \pm 10.0 \,{\rm{(syst)}} )\times 10^{10}\, LATEX0\rm{s}^{-1} \rm{cm}^{-2}$ at 90% C.L..

Introduction

The Sun is powered by nuclear fusion, specifically the proton-proton ($pp$) chain, which produces roughly 91% of the total solar neutrino flux. While the Standard Solar Model (SSM) predicts this flux with sub-percent precision, experimental measurements have historically carried uncertainties around 10%. Furthermore, a "solar metallicity puzzle" persists—a discrepancy between solar models based on spectroscopy versus those based on helioseismology. Precise measurements of different neutrino flavors are essential to resolve this. While the Borexino experiment previously measured $pp$ neutrinos in real-time, it was limited to energies above 165 keV. This study targets the lower energy range (24–144 keV) to provide a more complete picture of the solar interior.

Experimental Methods and Atomic Modeling

The PandaX-4T detector, located in the China Jinping Underground Laboratory, is a dual-phase liquid xenon (LXe) Time Projection Chamber (TPC) containing 3.69 tonnes of sensitive LXe. Neutrinos scattering off electrons produce prompt scintillation ($S1$) and delayed electroluminescence ($S2$) signals, allowing for precise energy and position reconstruction.

A critical technical advancement in this analysis is the treatment of atomic effects. Unlike simpler models that treat electrons as "free," this study accounts for xenon atomic binding energies using the Relativistic Random Phase Approximation (RRPA). At low energies, the fact that electrons are bound to atoms significantly suppresses the expected scattering rate compared to the free-electron (FE) approximation.

Comparison of solar neutrino scattering models: Free Electron (FE) vs. Relativistic Random Phase Approximation (RRPA).

The analysis utilized 86.5 days of commissioning data (0.63 tonne$\times$year exposure). To minimize external backgrounds, a central 2.66-tonne fiducial volume was selected. Background mitigation involved a binned likelihood fit accounting for internal contaminants like $^{222}\text{Rn}$ progeny ($^{214}\text{Pb}$), $^{85}\text{Kr}$, and activated xenon isotopes.

Key Results

The study demonstrates that multi-tonne dark matter detectors have reached the sensitivity required to function as high-precision solar neutrino observatories. By refining noise-rejection algorithms, the researchers recovered approximately 9.5% of exposure previously discarded in dark matter searches.

The solar $pp$ neutrino flux was determined to be $(8.0 \pm 3.9 \text{ (stat)} \pm 10.0 \text{ (syst)}) \times 10^{10} \text{ s}^{-1} \text{cm}^{-2}$. This result is consistent with SSM predictions and previous measurements from Borexino and radiochemical experiments (GALLEX/SAGE). An upper limit of $23.3 \times 10^{10} \text{ s}^{-1} \text{cm}^{-2}$ was established at a 90% confidence level. The fit identified approximately $231 \pm 257$ combined $pp$ and $^7\text{Be}$ neutrino events within the region of interest.

Energy spectrum fit of the PandaX-4T commissioning data showing the contributions of solar neutrinos and various backgrounds.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The current measurement is primarily limited by systematic uncertainties, specifically the reconstructed energy scale and the spectral shape of the $^{214}\text{Pb}$ background. Future runs with PandaX-4T aim to reduce these uncertainties through:

  1. Background Reduction: Implementing optimized online cryogenic distillation to reduce $^{222}\text{Rn}$ and $^{85}\text{Kr}$ concentrations.
  2. Increased Exposure: A projected 6 tonne$\times$year exposure is expected to reduce flux uncertainty to approximately 30%.
  3. Hardware Upgrades: Improvements to TPC materials and PMT readout electronics will further suppress systematic errors, potentially allowing dark matter detectors to resolve the solar metallicity puzzle.

Summary updated

Abstract

The proton-proton ($pp$) fusion chain dominates the neutrino production from the Sun. The uncertainty of the predicted $pp$ neutrino flux is at the sub-percent level, whereas that of the best measurement is $\mathcal{O}(10\%)$. In this paper, we present the first result to measure the solar $pp$ neutrinos in the electron recoil energy range from 24 to 144 keV, using the PandaX-4T commissioning data with 0.63 tonne$\times$year exposure. The $pp$ neutrino flux is determined to be $(8.0 \pm 3.9 \,{\rm{(stat)}} \pm 10.0 \,{\rm{(syst)}} )\times 10^{10}\, $$\rm{s}^{-1} \rm{cm}^{-2}$, consistent with Standard Solar Model and existing measurements, corresponding to a flux upper limit of $23.3\times 10^{10}\, $$\rm{s}^{-1} \rm{cm}^{-2}$ at 90\% C.L..
BibTeX
@misc{lu2024measurement,
  author = {Xiaoying Lü and Abdusalam Abdukerim and Zihao Bo and Wei Chen and Xun Chen and C. H. Cheng and Zhaokan Cheng and Xiangyi Cui and Yingjie 英杰 Fan 樊 and Deqing Fang and Changbo Fu and Mengting Fu and Li‐Sheng Geng and Karl Giboni and Linhui Gu and Xuyuan Guo and Chencheng Han and K. Han and Changda He and Jinrong He and Di Huang and Yanlin Huang and J. Huang and Zhou Huang and Ruquan Hou and Yu Hou and Xiangdong Ji and Yonglin Ju and Chenxiang Li and Jiafu Li and Mingchuan Li and Shuaijie Li and Tao Li and Qing Lin and Jianglai Liu and Congcong Lu and Lingyin Luo and Yunyang Luo and Wenbo Ma and Y. G. and Yajun Mao and Yue Meng and Xuyang Ning and Binyu Pang and Ningchun Qi and Zhicheng Qian and Xiangxiang Ren and Nasir Shaheed and Xiaofeng Shang and Xiyuan Shao and Guofang Shen and Lin Si and Wenliang Sun and Andi Tan and Yi Tao and Anqing Wang and Meng Wang and Qiuhong Wang and Shaobo Wang and Siguang Wang and Wei Wang and Xiuli Wang and Zhou Wang and Yuehuan Wei and Mengmeng Wu and Weihao Wu and Jingkai Xia and Mengjiao Xiao and Xiang Xiao and Pengwei Xie and Binbin Yan and Xiyu Yan and Jijun Yang and Yong Yang and Yukun Yao and Chunxu Yu and Ying Yuan and Zhe Yuan and Xinning Zeng and Dan Zhang and Minzhen Zhang and Peng Zhang and Shibo Zhang and Shu Zhang and Tao Zhang and R. T. Zhang and Yang Zhang and Yingxin Zhang and Yuanyuan Zhang and Li Zhao and Qibin Zheng and Jifang Zhou},
  title = {{Measurement of Solar $pp$ Neutrino Flux using Electron Recoil Data from PandaX-4T Commissioning Run}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2401.07045},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07045},
}
Figure