The PandaX-4T liquid xenon detector at the China Jinping Underground Laboratory is used to measure the solar $^8$B neutrino flux by detecting neutrinos through coherent scattering with xenon nuclei. Data samples requiring the coincidence of scintillation and ionization signals (paired), as well as unpaired ionization-only signals (US2), are selected with energy thresholds of approximately 1.1 keV and 0.33 keV nuclear recoil energy, respectively. Combining the commissioning run and the first science run of PandaX-4T, a total exposure of 1.20 and 1.04 tonne·year are collected for the paired and US2 samples. After unblinding, 3 and 332 events are observed with an expectation of 2.8±0.5 and 251±32 background events. A combined analysis yields a best-fit $^8$B neutrino signal with ~37% uncertainty, and the background-only hypothesis is disfavored at 2.64$σ$ significance. This gives a solar $^8$B neutrino flux of ($8.4\pm3.1$)$×$10$^6$ cm$^{-2}$s$^{-1}$, consistent with the standard solar model prediction. It is also the first indication of solar $^8$B neutrino "fog" in a dark matter direct detection experiment.
Introduction: The Neutrino Fog
For decades, the search for Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs) has driven the development of increasingly sensitive dark matter detectors. However, these experiments have reached a threshold known as the "neutrino fog." At this level of sensitivity, neutrinos from the sun—specifically those from $^8$B decay—interact with the detector material through Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering (CEvNS). This process produces nuclear recoils that are virtually indistinguishable from the expected signals of dark matter particles. Characterizing this neutrino background is essential for the future of dark matter discovery.
Methodology: Paired and S2-only Signals
The PandaX-4T experiment, located 2,400 meters underground at the China Jinping Underground Laboratory, utilizes a 3.7-tonne dual-phase xenon Time Projection Chamber (TPC). To maximize sensitivity to the low-energy recoils characteristic of CEvNS, the collaboration analyzed two distinct data channels:
Paired Signals: These require a coincidence between a scintillation flash (S1) and an ionization signal (S2). This "gold standard" allows for excellent background rejection and 3D position reconstruction but is limited by a higher energy threshold (~1.1 keV).
US2 (Unpaired S2-only) Signals: By ignoring the S1 requirement, the team lowered the energy threshold significantly to ~0.33 keV. This is critical because the CEvNS rate increases dramatically at lower energies. To manage the higher noise in this channel, Boosted Decision Trees (BDT) were employed to distinguish neutrino signals from detector-specific backgrounds like micro-discharges and electron afterglow.
Signal efficiency for paired and US2 data samples as a function of nuclear recoil (NR) truth energy, illustrating the lower threshold achieved by the US2 analysis.
The analysis combined data from the commissioning run (Run0) and the first science run (Run1). After unblinding the data, the team observed 3 events in the paired sample (against 2.8 expected from background) and 332 events in the US2 sample (against 251 expected).
The combined statistical analysis disfavors the background-only hypothesis at a significance of 2.64$σ$. The resulting solar $^8$B neutrino flux was measured to be ($8.4\pm3.1$)$×$10$^6$ cm$^{-2}$s$^{-1}$. This measurement is remarkably consistent with the B16-GS98 Standard Solar Model (SSM) prediction, validating the detector's low-energy calibration and the theoretical models of solar neutrino production.
Comparison of the measured solar $^8$B neutrino flux with the B16-GS98 standard solar model prediction and previous experimental constraints from XENON1T.
This result represents the first indication of the solar neutrino background in a dark matter direct detection experiment. While the current significance is 2.64$σ$, continued data taking with PandaX-4T is expected to push this toward a definitive 5$σ$ discovery. Beyond characterizing backgrounds for dark matter, these results open a new window for using liquid xenon detectors as low-energy neutrino observatories, potentially allowing for searches for non-standard neutrino interactions and other physics beyond the Standard Model.
Summary updated
Abstract
The PandaX-4T liquid xenon detector at the China Jinping Underground Laboratory is used to measure the solar $^8$B neutrino flux by detecting neutrinos through coherent scattering with xenon nuclei. Data samples requiring the coincidence of scintillation and ionization signals (paired), as well as unpaired ionization-only signals (US2), are selected with energy threshold of approximately 1.1 keV (0.33 keV) nuclear recoil energy. Combining the commissioning run and the first science run of PandaX-4T, a total exposure of 1.20 and 1.04 tonne$\cdot$year are collected for the paired and US2, respectively. After unblinding, 3 and 332 events are observed with an expectation of 2.8$\pm$0.5 and 251$\pm$32 background events, for the paired and US2 data, respectively. A combined analysis yields a best-fit $^8$B neutrino signal of 3.5 (75) events from the paired (US2) data sample, with $\sim$37\% uncertainty, and the background-only hypothesis is disfavored at 2.64$σ$ significance. This gives a solar $^8$B neutrino flux of ($8.4\pm3.1$)$\times$10$^6$ cm$^{-2}$s$^{-1}$, consistent with the standard solar model prediction. It is also the first indication of solar $^8$B neutrino ``fog'' in a dark matter direct detection experiment.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2024first,
author = {PandaX Collaboration and Zihao Bo and Wei Chen and Xun Chen and Yunhua Chen and Zhaokan Cheng and Xiangyi Cui and Yingjie 英杰 Fan 樊 and Deqing Fang and Zhixing Gao and Li‐Sheng Geng and Karl Giboni and Xunan Guo and Xuyuan Guo and Zichao Guo and Chencheng Han and K. Han and Changda He and Jinrong He and Di Huang and Houqi Huang and J. Huang and Ruquan Hou and Yu Hou and Xiangdong Ji and Xiangpan Ji and Yonglin Ju and Chenxiang Li and Jiafu Li and Mingchuan Li and Shuaijie Li and Tao Li and Zhiyuan Li and Qing Lin and Jianglai Liu and Congcong Lu and Xiaoying Lü and Lingyin Luo and Yunyang Luo and Wenbo Ma and Y. G. and Yajun Mao and Yue Meng and Xuyang Ning and Binyu Pang and Ningchun Qi and Zhicheng Qian and Xiangxiang Ren and Dong Shan and Xiaofeng Shang and Xiyuan Shao and Guofang Shen and Manbin Shen and Wenliang Sun and Yi Tao and Anqing Wang and Guanbo Wang and Hao Wang and Jiamin Wang and Lei Wang and Meng Wang and Qiuhong Wang and Shaobo Wang and Siguang Wang and Wei Wang and Xiuli Wang and Xuming Wang and Zhou Wang and Yuehuan Wei and Weihao Wu and Yuan Wu and Mengjiao Xiao and Xiang Xiao and Kaizhi Xiong and Yifan Xu and Shunyu Yao and Binbin Yan and Xiyu Yan and Yong Yang and Peihua Ye and Chunxu Yu and Ying Yuan and Zhe Yuan and Youhui Yun and Xinning Zeng and Minzhen Zhang and Peng Zhang and Shibo Zhang and Shu Zhang and Tao Zhang and Wei Zhang and Yang Zhang and Yingxin Zhang and Yuanyuan Zhang and Li Zhao and Jifang Zhou and Jiaxu Zhou and Jiayi Zhou and N. Zhou and Xiaopeng Zhou},
title = {{First Indication of Solar $^8$B Neutrino Flux through Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering in PandaX-4T}},
year = {2024},
eprint = {2407.10892},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10892},
}