Measurement and Characteristic Analysis of Turbulent Flow near Permeable Spur Dike

Jielong Hu, Pingyi Wang, Jie Zhang, Meili Wang, Yafei Chen, Congcong ZhaoInstrumentation 2020 · DOI

Abstract

To disclose the turbulence features near a permeable spur dike, this paper measures the three-dimensional (3D) instantaneous velocity at different vertical lines and depths around the permeable spur dike through acoustic Doppler velocimetry (ADV). The relative turbulence intensity and Reynolds stress were calculated for each measuring point, and the distribution features of different turbulence structures were analyzed along the water depth. Experimental results show that: within the length of the dike, the turbulence intensity and Reynolds stress in the downstream of the dike are much greater than those in the upstream. In the downstream of the dike, the turbulence intensity in the root and body regions peaks in the dike crest layer, but that at other positions minimizes in that layer. In the upstream, ejection and sweeping are the dominant turbulence structures; outward and inward interactions dominate near the dike crest layer in the downstream.

Introduction

Spur dikes are hydraulic structures extending from a riverbank into the channel to divert flow, prevent erosion, and maintain ecological health. While traditional solid dikes are effective, permeable spur dikes—which allow a portion of the water to pass through—are increasingly favored for their ability to create diverse aquatic habitats. However, the turbulence around these permeable structures is highly complex and 3D in nature. Previous research has often lacked the spatial resolution to capture how turbulence changes from the riverbed to the surface, particularly near the "crest layer" where overflow and through-flow interact.

Experimental Methodology

The study was conducted in a 30-meter-long straight flume under controlled conditions (flow rate of $0.142 m^3/s$, depth of $20 cm$). The researchers utilized a model permeable spur dike with a 17.6% permeability rate, characterized by a series of arch-shaped openings.

3D model of the permeable spur dike featuring arch-shaped holes used in the flume experiments.

To map the flow field, a Nortek Vectrino Plus Acoustic Doppler Velocimeter (ADV) was used to measure 3D water velocity at a frequency of 100Hz. Measurements were taken across five cross-sections with seven vertical profiles each, covering both upstream and downstream regions.

Top-down schematic of the measurement grid, showing the flow direction and the arrangement of vertical measurement lines (V1-V5).

Turbulence Analysis and Quadrant Decomposition

The core of the analysis involved calculating relative turbulence intensity and Reynolds stress. To understand the physical mechanisms of sediment transport, the researchers employed Quadrant Decomposition. This technique categorizes instantaneous velocity fluctuations into four distinct events:

  • Q1 (Outward Interaction): High-speed fluid moving away from the bed.
  • Q2 (Ejection): Low-speed fluid moving away from the bed.
  • Q3 (Inward Interaction): Low-speed fluid moving toward the bed.
  • Q4 (Sweeping): High-speed fluid moving toward the bed.

Key Insights and Results

The experimental data revealed several critical characteristics of the flow field:

  • Downstream Intensity Surge: Within the vicinity of the dike, turbulence intensity downstream is approximately twice as high as upstream. This surge is attributed to the chaotic mixing of water passing through the dike's arches and spilling over its crest.
  • The Crest Layer Effect: In the root and body regions of the dike, turbulence intensity peaks at the dike crest layer ($z/h \approx 0.8$ to $1.0$). This identifies the crest as a zone of intense energy dissipation where overflow and through-flow collide.
  • Dominant Flow Structures:
    • Upstream: Ejection (Q2) and sweeping (Q4) are the primary drivers of turbulence.
  • Downstream: While Q2 and Q4 dominate near the bed, outward (Q1) and inward (Q3) interactions become dominant near the crest layer, indicating a complex hydraulic jump.
  • Predictive Correlation: A strong mathematical correlation ($R^2 = 0.91$) was found between Reynolds stress and Turbulent Kinetic Energy (TKE), suggesting that TKE can serve as a reliable proxy for shear forces in these environments.

Conclusion

This high-resolution 3D mapping provides a clearer understanding of the "invisible" forces around permeable river structures. The dominance of ejection and sweeping downstream explains the significant scour observed in these areas. These findings are essential for calibrating 3D numerical models and improving the design of riverbank protection works. Future research should explore varying permeability levels and different hole geometries to generalize these results for diverse engineering applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

To disclose the turbulence features near a permeable spur dike, this paper measures the three-dimensional (3D) instantaneous velocity at different vertical lines and depths around the permeable spur dike through acoustic Doppler velocimetry (ADV). The relative turbulence intensity and Reynolds stress were calculated for each measuring point, and the distribution features of different turbulence structures were analyzed along the water depth. Experimental results show that: within the length of the dike, the turbulence intensity and Reynolds stress in the downstream of the dike are much greater than those in the upstream. In the downstream of the dike, the turbulence intensity in the root and body regions peaks in the dike crest layer, but that at other positions minimizes in that layer (but peaks on the water surface or river bottom). In the upstream, ejection and sweeping are the dominant turbulence structures; the two structures also dominate near the free layer at the bottom in the downstream; outward and inward interactions dominate near the dike crest layer in the downstream.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2020measurement,
  author = {Jielong Hu and Pingyi Wang and Jie Zhang and Meili Wang and Yafei Chen and Congcong Zhao},
  title = {{Measurement and Characteristic Analysis of Turbulent Flow near Permeable Spur Dike}},
  booktitle = {Instrumentation},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.18280/i2m.190503},
}
Figure