Materials for hydrogen-based energy storage – past, recent progress and future outlook

Michael Hirscher, V.a. Yartys, Marcello Baricco, José M. Bellosta von Colbe, Didier Blanchard, R. C. Bowman, Darren P. Broom, Craig E. Buckley, Fei Chang, Ping Chen, Young Whan Cho, Jean‐Claude Crivello, Fermín Cuevas, William I. F. David, Petra E. de Jongh, R.v. Denys, Martin Dornheim, Michael Felderhoff, Yaroslav Filinchuk, George E. Froudakis, David M. Grant, Evan Gray, Bjørn C. Hauback, Teng He, Terry D. Humphries, Torben R. Jensen, Sangryun Kim, Yoshitsugu Kojima, M. Latroche, Haiwen Li, Mykhaylo Lototskyy, Joshua W. Makepeace, Kasper T. Møller, Lubna Naheed, Peter Ngene, Dag Noréus, Magnus Moe Nygård, Shin‐ichi Orimo, Mark Paskevicius, Luca Pasquini, Dorthe Bomholdt Ravnsbæk, M. Veronica Sofianos, Terrence J. Udovic, Tejs Vegge, Gavin S. Walker, C. J. Webb, Claudia Weidenthaler, Claudia ZloteaJournal of Alloys and Compounds 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This review paper provides a comprehensive overview of magnesium-based materials for hydrogen storage, covering their historical development, recent advancements, and future prospects. It highlights the challenges and opportunities in utilizing magnesium for efficient and safe hydrogen energy storage, crucial for the transition to a hydrogen economy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical challenge of developing effective and economical hydrogen storage solutions to support the growing hydrogen economy. While hydrogen is a promising clean energy carrier, its safe and efficient storage remains a significant hurdle. Magnesium-based materials are particularly attractive due to their abundance, low cost, and high hydrogen storage capacity. However, their practical application is hindered by issues such as slow kinetics, high operating temperatures for hydrogen release, and long-term stability concerns. This review aims to consolidate the vast research in this area, identify key challenges, and outline future research directions.

Methods

The paper discusses a wide range of experimental and theoretical methods employed in the study of magnesium-based hydrogen storage materials. These include:

  • Synthesis techniques: Mechanical alloying (MA), reactive ball milling (RBM), high-energy reactive ball milling (HRBM), chemical synthesis, gas-phase growth, and scaffold infiltration.
  • Characterization techniques: X-ray diffraction (XRD), neutron diffraction, scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), Raman spectroscopy, visible spectroscopy, thermal gravimetry, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), mass spectrometry, and Sieverts systems.
  • Theoretical methods: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations, quasi-harmonic approximation (QHA), and CALPHAD method for thermodynamic modeling.
  • In situ and operando techniques: Synchrotron radiation X-ray diffraction (SR-XRD) and environmental TEM for real-time monitoring of hydrogenation/dehydrogenation processes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nanostructuring is key: Reducing the particle size of magnesium and its hydrides to the nanoscale significantly enhances hydrogenation and dehydrogenation kinetics.
  • Catalysis is crucial: Various additives, particularly transition metals, oxides, and carbon-based materials, act as effective catalysts, lowering activation energies and improving reaction rates.
  • Thermodynamics remain a challenge: While kinetics can be significantly improved, fundamentally altering the thermodynamic stability of MgH2 to achieve lower operating temperatures remains a major hurdle.
  • Composite materials offer promise: Combining magnesium with other materials (e.g., carbon nanostructures, other metal hydrides) can lead to synergistic effects, improving storage capacity, kinetics, and stability.
  • High-pressure studies reveal new phases: Research into the Mg-H system at high pressures has identified new polymorphic phases of MgH2 with potentially different properties.
  • Thermal energy storage is a viable application: Magnesium-based materials show significant potential for thermal energy storage due to their high reaction enthalpy and operating temperature range.

Key Results

  • Improved kinetics: Nanostructuring and catalytic additives have led to orders-of-magnitude improvements in hydrogen absorption and desorption rates.
  • Enhanced stability: Certain composite materials and nanoconfinement strategies have shown improved cycling stability, mitigating degradation issues.
  • New phase identification: High-pressure studies have revealed new phases of MgH2, expanding our understanding of the Mg-H phase diagram.
  • Promising thermal storage materials: Mg-based compounds like Mg2FeH6 and NaMgH3 have demonstrated potential for high-temperature thermal energy storage applications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Thermodynamic limitations: Decoupling enthalpy and entropy to reduce desorption temperatures remains a significant challenge.
  • Scalability and cost: While many promising materials have been developed, scaling up their production for industrial applications and ensuring cost-effectiveness are critical.
  • Mechanism understanding: The precise mechanisms by which catalysts and nanostructuring influence hydrogen sorption are not fully understood and require further investigation.
  • Long-term stability: While improvements have been made, ensuring long-term cycling stability under real-world operating conditions is essential for practical applications.
  • Future research directions: The authors emphasize the need for continued fundamental studies on thermodynamics, kinetics, and properties under extreme conditions, as well as the development of novel synthesis techniques and characterization methods. Further exploration of multicomponent alloys, composite materials, and applications in thermal energy storage and batteries is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

Globally, the accelerating use of renewable energy sources, enabled by increased efficiencies and reduced costs, and driven by the need to mitigate the effects of climate change, has significantly increased research in the areas of renewable energy production, storage, distribution and end-use. Central to this discussion is the use of hydrogen, as a clean, efficient energy vector for energy storage. This review, by experts of Task 32, “Hydrogen-based Energy Storage” of the International Energy Agency, Hydrogen TCP, reports on the development over the last 6 years of hydrogen storage materials, methods and techniques, including electrochemical and thermal storage systems. An overview is given on the background to the various methods, the current state of development and the future prospects. The following areas are covered; porous materials, liquid hydrogen carriers, complex hydrides, intermetallic hydrides, electrochemical storage of energy, thermal energy storage, hydrogen energy systems and an outlook is presented for future prospects and research on hydrogen-based energy storage.
BibTeX
@article{hirscher2019materials,
  author = {Michael Hirscher and V.A. Yartys and Marcello Baricco and José M. Bellosta von Colbe and Didier Blanchard and R. C. Bowman and Darren P. Broom and Craig E. Buckley and Fei Chang and Ping Chen and Young Whan Cho and Jean‐Claude Crivello and Fermín Cuevas and William I. F. David and Petra E. de Jongh and R.V. Denys and Martin Dornheim and Michael Felderhoff and Yaroslav Filinchuk and George E. Froudakis and David M. Grant and Evan Gray and Bjørn C. Hauback and Teng He and Terry D. Humphries and Torben R. Jensen and Sangryun Kim and Yoshitsugu Kojima and M. Latroche and Haiwen Li and Mykhaylo Lototskyy and Joshua W. Makepeace and Kasper T. Møller and Lubna Naheed and Peter Ngene and Dag Noréus and Magnus Moe Nygård and Shin‐ichi Orimo and Mark Paskevicius and Luca Pasquini and Dorthe Bomholdt Ravnsbæk and M. Veronica Sofianos and Terrence J. Udovic and Tejs Vegge and Gavin S. Walker and C. J. Webb and Claudia Weidenthaler and Claudia Zlotea},
  title = {{Materials for hydrogen-based energy storage – past, recent progress and future outlook}},
  journal = {Journal of Alloys and Compounds},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jallcom.2019.153548},
}
Figure