Mapping the Accessibility of Medical Facilities of Wuhan during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Zhenqi Zhou, Zhen Xu, Anqi Liu, Shuang Zhou, Lan Mu, Xuan ZhangISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper maps the accessibility of medical facilities in Wuhan during the COVID-19 lockdown, revealing significant spatial inequalities in resource distribution. By using Baidu Map API to estimate travel times, the study highlights underserved areas and potential facility overloads, offering a framework for emergency response planning and resource allocation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented unprecedented challenges to urban healthcare systems, particularly in densely populated cities like Wuhan. During the strict lockdown, residents faced severe restrictions on movement, and a hierarchical diagnosis and treatment system was implemented, emphasizing local access to care. This created a critical need to understand how residents could access necessary medical facilities under these conditions. The problem this paper addresses is the spatial disparity in access to medical resources and the potential strain on these facilities, which could significantly impact the effectiveness of diagnosis, treatment, and overall public health response during an emergency. Traditional accessibility metrics might not fully capture the dynamic and restricted conditions of a pandemic lockdown, necessitating a more nuanced approach.

Methods

The study employed a geospatial analysis approach using the Baidu Map API to estimate travel distances and times from communities to various medical facilities. This allowed for the identification of service areas for different types of facilities (community healthcare centers, fever clinics, designated hospitals, mobile cabin hospitals, and pharmacies). The core methodology involved:

  • Data Integration: Combining official information on medical facilities with online map data.
  • Geospatial Database Construction: Mapping the locations of medical facilities and compiling community boundaries.
  • Travel Mode Analysis: Scraping travel distance and time data for various travel modes (walking, biking, electric scooter, car) from communities to facilities, prioritizing the shortest-time travel for each mode. For community healthcare centers and pharmacies, walking was prioritized, while for others, driving was considered using the Baidu Map API.
  • Service Area and Capacity Estimation: Identifying the number of communities and the population served by each medical facility. This was then overlaid with community population data to estimate potential capacities.
  • Index Calculation: Utilizing Population-to-Provider Ratio (PPR)-related indices to assess potential facility loading, acknowledging that the "no cross-district treatment" policy simplified the analysis by removing the complexity of cross-border healthcare-seeking behavior.

Datasets

  • Community Data: Boundaries of 4076 communities in the study area of Wuhan.
  • Population Data: Community population data from 2010 (noted as a limitation).
  • Medical Facility Data: Geographical locations and bed information for various pandemic-related medical facilities in Wuhan, including community healthcare centers, fever clinics, designated hospitals, mobile cabin hospitals, community pharmacies, and designated pharmacies.
  • Geospatial Data: Road network and travel time data obtained via the Baidu Map API.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Inequality is Pervasive: The study strongly highlights that medical resources are not evenly distributed. Peripheral areas of Wuhan are significantly less accessible than central areas, exacerbating existing inequalities.
  • Walking Accessibility is Crucial but Often Lacking: Despite the emphasis on walking for local access during lockdown, a substantial portion of communities were found to be underserved by walking distance to community healthcare centers, particularly impacting vulnerable populations.
  • Hierarchical System's Impact: The implemented hierarchical diagnosis and treatment system, combined with motor vehicle restrictions, created a unique scenario for accessibility analysis. This system, while aiming to manage patient flow, also concentrated demand on specific facility types.
  • Potential for Overload: The analysis identified specific medical facilities (e.g., Liuqier Designated Hospital, Wuti Mobile Cabin Hospital) that could be potentially overloaded based on their service population and bed capacity, underscoring the need for proactive resource management.
  • Open-Source Data Power: The study demonstrates the efficacy of using readily available open-source data (like Baidu Map API) for rapid and relevant accessibility mapping, even in complex emergency situations.

Key Results

  • Community Healthcare Centers: 31.9% of communities were beyond a 15-minute walking distance to the nearest community healthcare center. Caidian District had the highest percentage of underserved communities (62.7%).
  • Fever Clinics: Peripheral areas showed inadequate service population coverage compared to central areas.
  • Designated Hospitals: Significant spatial inequality in population-hospital bed ratios was observed, with Liuqier Designated Hospital and Hankou Designated Hospital identified as potentially heavily burdened.
  • Mobile Cabin Hospitals: Similar spatial inequalities were noted, with the Wuti Mobile Cabin Hospital being the most heavily burdened.
  • Pharmacies: Community pharmacies generally showed good accessibility via walking (97.1% of residents within 15 minutes), with designated pharmacies also exhibiting reasonable coverage, though some challenges were noted in specific districts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations:
    • Reliance on Baidu Map data for all geospatial information, which might not be exhaustive or perfectly accurate.
  • Use of 2010 population data, which may not reflect current population distribution, potentially biasing capacity estimations.
  • Limited access to official demographic data, medical facility resources, and real-time waiting times.
  • Scope Limitations:
    • The study focused on an "ideal state" of lockdown and did not fully account for the dynamic adaptations that occurred in real-time.
  • Inability to correlate accessibility with health outcomes (e.g., infection rates, diagnosis efficacy) due to a lack of publicly available community-level data.
  • Future Work Suggestions:
    • Deploying more community healthcare centers to improve accessibility, especially for vulnerable populations.
  • Developing a more flexible healthcare system that can adapt to vertical resource and personnel flows during emergencies.
  • Utilizing accessibility analysis for proactive identification of underserved areas and potential hotspots to guide emergency response and resource allocation.
  • Exploring the transferability of this methodology to other cities facing similar public health crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

In December 2019, the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic attacked Wuhan, China. The city government soon strictly locked down the city, implemented a hierarchical diagnosis and treatment system, and took a series of unprecedented pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical measures. The residents’ access to the medical resources and the consequently potential demand–supply tension may determine effective diagnosis and treatment, for which travel distance and time are key indicators. Using the Application Programming Interface (API) of Baidu Map, we estimated the travel distance and time from communities to the medical facilities capable of treating COVID-19 patients, and we identified the service areas of those facilities as well. The results showed significant differences in service areas and potential loading across medical facilities. The accessibility of medical facilities in the peripheral areas was inferior to those in the central areas; there was spatial inequality of medical resources within and across districts; the amount of community healthcare centers was insufficient; some communities were underserved regarding walking distance; some medical facilities could be potentially overloaded. This study provides reference, in the context of Wuhan, for understanding the spatial aspect of medical resources and residents’ relevant mobility under the emergency regulation, and re-examining the coordination of emergency to improve future planning and utilization of medical facilities at various levels. The approach can facilitate policymakers to assess potential loading of medical facilities, identify low-accessibility areas, and deploy new medical facilities. It also implies that the accessibility analysis can be rapid and relevant even only with open-source data.
BibTeX
@article{zhou2021mapping,
  author = {Zhenqi Zhou and Zhen Xu and Anqi Liu and Shuang Zhou and Lan Mu and Xuan Zhang},
  title = {{Mapping the Accessibility of Medical Facilities of Wuhan during the COVID-19 Pandemic}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uDECv3T2nK},
}
Figure