Manipulation of topological phase transitions and the mechanism of magnetic interactions in Eu-based Zintl-phase materials

Boxuan Li, Ziyin Song, Fang Zhong, Zhijun Wang, Hongming Weng

Abstract

Various topological phases, including topological insulators, topological semimetals, and topological superconductors, along with the controllable topological phase transitions, have attracted considerable attention due to their promising applications in spintronics and quantum computing. In this work, we propose two distinct methods for manipulating topological phase transitions in magnetic materials. First, by varying the strength of electron correlation effects, we induce a series of topological state transitions within the EuM$_2$X$_2$ (M = Zn, Cd; X = P, As, Sb) family of Zintl materials, including magnetic topological crystalline insulators (TCIs) and magnetic Dirac semimetals. Our findings indicate that strong electron correlation effects tend to influence the emergence of topological phases. Second, by reducing the electronegativity of the pnictogen X (from P to As and Sb), we observe a similar transition from trivial insulator to magnetic Dirac semimetal or magnetic TCI. This suggests that weaker electronegativity favors the emergence of topological phases. Furthermore, we establish a Heisenberg model to describe the magnetic interactions of the EuM$_2$X$_2$ system, based on which we perform Monte Carlo simulations of specific heat and magnetic susceptibility, yielding Néel temperatures that perfectly match experimental data. This suggests that the local magnetic moment framework provides an accurate description of the magnetization behavior in this family of materials.

Introduction

Topological materials, such as topological insulators and Dirac semimetals, are central to modern condensed matter physics due to their potential for dissipationless transport. For practical applications in spintronics and quantum computing, the ability to switch or transition between these topological states is critical. The $EuM_2X_2$ (M = Zn, Cd; X = P, As, Sb) family of Zintl-phase materials offers a unique platform for such manipulation, characterized by a complex interplay of metallic and covalent bonding alongside magnetic order.

Methodology

This study utilizes a multi-layered theoretical framework to investigate the electronic and magnetic properties of the $EuM_2X_2$ family:

  • First-Principles Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was performed using the VASP package with the GGA+U method to account for the strong correlation of Europium’s $4f$ electrons.
  • Topological Analysis: Symmetry indicators and irreducible representations were used to classify topological phases. Tight-binding models based on maximally localized Wannier functions (MLWFs) were constructed to simulate surface states.
  • Magnetic Modeling: A two-parameter Heisenberg model was established to describe exchange interactions ($J_{||}$ and $J_{\perp}$). Monte Carlo simulations using the Espins package provided temperature-dependent properties like specific heat and magnetic susceptibility to determine Néel temperatures ($T_N$).

Tuning Topological States via Electron Correlation

A primary "tuning knob" identified in this research is the strength of electron correlation, represented by the Hubbard-$U$ parameter. Increasing $U$ effectively acts as a proxy for physical pressure, driving the material through a sequence of phase transitions.

Evolution of band structures for the AFM-Aa configuration with increasing Hubbard-U, showing the transition from a trivial insulator to a topological state.

As shown in the band structure evolution, varying $U$ from 1 eV to 6 eV induces transitions between trivial insulators, topological crystalline insulators (TCIs), and Dirac semimetals. For instance, in the AFM-Aa configuration, the material transitions from a trivial state to a TCI and eventually back to a trivial insulator as the correlation strength increases. This demonstrates that electron correlation is a critical factor in the emergence and stability of topological phases in these Zintl systems.

The Role of Electronegativity in Band Inversion

The second manipulation method involves chemical substitution of the pnictogen element (X). By moving down the periodic table from Phosphorus (P) to Arsenic (As) and Antimony (Sb), the electronegativity of the X site decreases.

Comparison of band structures across the EuM2X2 family, illustrating how decreasing pnictogen electronegativity promotes band inversion.

This reduction in electronegativity leads to a decrease in the band gap and promotes band inversion at high-symmetry points like $\Gamma$. As illustrated in the comparative band structures, heavier pnictogens with lower electronegativity favor the formation of topological phases, such as magnetic Dirac semimetals or TCIs. This chemical tuning provides a robust experimental route for designing materials with specific topological properties.

Magnetic Interactions and Thermal Properties

Beyond electronic topology, the study successfully describes the magnetic behavior of the $EuM_2X_2$ family using a local magnetic moment framework. The Heisenberg model accurately captured the exchange interactions, and subsequent Monte Carlo simulations yielded Néel temperatures that align closely with experimental values. For $EuCd_2As_2$, the predicted $T_N$ of $\sim$7.58–9.5 K matches the experimental value of 9.5 K, validating the theoretical approach.

Conclusion

This work identifies electron correlation and elemental electronegativity as two powerful mechanisms for manipulating topological phase transitions in magnetic Zintl materials. By providing a comprehensive mapping of topological states and a reliable magnetic model, this research offers a theoretical foundation for the experimental development of tunable topological devices for future quantum technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Various topological phases, including topological insulators, topological semimetals, and topological superconductors, along with the controllable topological phase transitions, have attracted considerable attention due to their promising applications in spintronics and quantum computing. In this work, we propose two distinct methods for manipulating topological phase transitions in magnetic materials. First, by varying the strength of electron correlation effects, we induce a series of topological state transitions within the $\mathrm{Eu}{M}_{2}{X}_{2}$ ($M$ = Zn, Cd; $X$ = P, As, Sb) family of Zintl materials, including magnetic topological crystalline insulators (TCIs) and magnetic Dirac semimetals. Our findings indicate that strong electron correlation effects tend to influence the emergence of topological phases. Second, by reducing the electronegativity of the pnictogen $X$ (from P to As and Sb), we observe a similar transition from trivial insulator to magnetic Dirac semimetal or magnetic TCI. This suggests that weaker electronegativity favors the emergence of topological phases. Furthermore, we establish a Heisenberg model to describe the magnetic interactions of the $\mathrm{Eu}{M}_{2}{X}_{2}$ system, based on which we perform Monte Carlo simulations of specific heat and magnetic susceptibility, yielding N\'eel temperatures that perfectly match the experimental data. This suggests that the local magnetic moment framework provides an accurate description of the magnetization behavior in this family of materials. This work provides the potential for the experimental manipulation of topological phase transitions and their possible applications, while also enhancing the understanding of the magnetic interactions within the $\mathrm{Eu}{M}_{2}{X}_{2}$ system and offering a theoretical foundation for future applications in magnetism.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025manipulation,
  author = {Boxuan Li and Ziyin Song and Fang Zhong and Zhijun Wang and Hongming Weng},
  title = {{Manipulation of topological phase transitions and the mechanism of magnetic interactions in Eu-based Zintl-phase materials}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.111.205127},
}
Figure