Mangrove reforestation provides greater blue carbon benefit than afforestation for mitigating global climate change

Shanshan Song, Yali Ding, Wei Li, Yuchen Meng, Jian Zhou, Ruikun Gou, Conghe Zhang, Shengbin Ye, Neil Saintilan, Ken W. Krauss, Stephen Crooks, Shuguo Lv, Guanghui Lin

Abstract

Significant efforts have been invested to restore mangrove forests worldwide through reforestation and afforestation. However, blue carbon benefit has not been compared between these two silvicultural pathways at the global scale. Here, we integrated results from direct field measurements of over 370 restoration sites around the world to show that mangrove reforestation (reestablishing mangroves where they previously colonized) had a greater carbon storage potential per hectare than afforestation (establishing mangroves where not previously mangrove). Greater carbon accumulation was mainly attributed to favorable intertidal positioning, higher nitrogen availability, and lower salinity at most reforestation sites. Reforestation of all physically feasible areas in the deforested mangrove regions of the world could promote the uptake of 671.5-688.8 Tg CO<sub>2</sub>-eq globally over a 40-year period, 60% more than afforesting the same global area on tidal flats (more marginal sites). Along with avoiding conflicts of habitat conversion, mangrove reforestation should be given priority when designing nature-based solutions for mitigating global climate change.

Introduction

Mangrove forests are among the most carbon-dense ecosystems on Earth, serving as a cornerstone for nature-based solutions to climate change. Restoration typically follows two distinct pathways: reforestation, which re-establishes forests in recently degraded or deforested areas (e.g., abandoned aquaculture ponds), and afforestation, which plants mangroves in areas they did not previously occupy, such as intertidal mudflats. While both methods increase forest cover, their relative long-term carbon sequestration potential has remained poorly understood at a global scale. This study addresses this gap by comparing the "blue carbon" benefits of these two strategies to provide actionable insights for global climate policy.

Methodology

The study utilized a global meta-analysis of 379 restoration sites across 106 scientific publications. Researchers assessed three primary carbon pools: Aboveground Biomass Carbon (AGC), Belowground Biomass Carbon (BGC), and Sediment Carbon (SCS) to a depth of 1 meter. To overcome the lack of long-term longitudinal data, a chronosequence modeling approach (using "space-for-time" substitution) was employed to build growth trajectories over a 40-year horizon. These models were integrated with environmental covariates, including Mean Annual Precipitation (MAP), salinity, and nitrogen availability, and upscaled using the Global Mangrove Watch dataset to estimate total global mitigation potential.

Results and Global Carbon Potential

The analysis reveals a significant "home field advantage" for reforestation. Over a 40-year period, reforestation provides a 60% greater carbon benefit per hectare than afforestation. Specifically, a 40-year-old reforested site stores approximately 127.7 Mg C/ha in aboveground biomass, compared to 88.7 Mg C/ha for afforested sites.

The most striking difference was found in sediment carbon. Reforestation sites accumulated sediment carbon at a rate of 3.5 Mg C/ha/yr—more than double the 1.6 Mg C/ha/yr observed in afforestation sites. This disparity is driven by favorable environmental conditions at reforestation sites, such as mid-to-upper intertidal positioning and higher nitrogen availability, which facilitate faster growth and better carbon retention.

Global distribution and regional carbon density of mangrove restoration sites across three carbon pools: aboveground biomass (b), belowground biomass (c), and sediment (d). Panel (a) shows regional box plots for these pools.

Globally, reforesting all physically feasible deforested areas could sequester between 671.5 and 688.8 Tg CO₂-eq over 40 years. The highest potential for this mitigation is concentrated in Indonesia, Mexico, and Myanmar.

Discussion and Implications

Beyond superior carbon sequestration, reforestation avoids the ecological conflicts associated with afforestation. Planting mangroves on mudflats often results in the conversion of valuable non-forest habitats that support migratory birds and local fisheries. Reforestation, by contrast, restores land to its natural state.

However, significant hurdles remain. The current data is heavily biased toward the Asia-Pacific region, and socio-economic challenges—such as the high opportunity cost of converting active agricultural or aquaculture land back to mangroves—can make reforestation politically difficult. Despite these limitations, the findings suggest that reforestation should be prioritized in national and international climate strategies to maximize the efficiency of nature-based carbon sinks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Significant efforts have been invested to restore mangrove forests worldwide through reforestation and afforestation. However, blue carbon benefit has not been compared between these two silvicultural pathways at the global scale. Here, we integrated results from direct field measurements of over 370 restoration sites around the world to show that mangrove reforestation (reestablishing mangroves where they previously colonized) had a greater carbon storage potential per hectare than afforestation (establishing mangroves where not previously mangrove). Greater carbon accumulation was mainly attributed to favorable intertidal positioning, higher nitrogen availability, and lower salinity at most reforestation sites. Reforestation of all physically feasible areas in the deforested mangrove regions of the world could promote the uptake of 671.5-688.8 Tg CO<sub>2</sub>-eq globally over a 40-year period, 60% more than afforesting the same global area on tidal flats (more marginal sites). Along with avoiding conflicts of habitat conversion, mangrove reforestation should be given priority when designing nature-based solutions for mitigating global climate change.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2023mangrove,
  author = {Shanshan Song and Yali Ding and Wei Li and Yuchen Meng and Jian Zhou and Ruikun Gou and Conghe Zhang and Shengbin Ye and Neil Saintilan and Ken W. Krauss and Stephen Crooks and Shuguo Lv and Guanghui Lin},
  title = {{Mangrove reforestation provides greater blue carbon benefit than afforestation for mitigating global climate change}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-36477-1},
}
Figure