Mammalian PIWI-piRNA-target complexes reveal features for broad and efficient target-silencing

Zhiqing Li, Zhenzhen Li, Lili Li, Lin Zeng, Junchao Xue, Huilin Niu, Jing Zhong, Qilu Yu, Dengfeng Li, Shikui Tu, Zz Zhao Zhang, Chun‐Qing Song, Jianping Wu, En-Zhi ShenbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Mammalian PIWI-piRNA complexes (MILI and HILI) are more efficient at silencing targets than their invertebrate counterparts, thanks to structural adaptations like a wider binding channel and a more flexible "seed gate." These features allow them to tolerate mismatches, enabling broader target recognition and more robust defense against mobile genetic elements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The PIWI-interacting RNA (piRNA) pathway is crucial for maintaining genome integrity by silencing "selfish genetic elements" like transposons. While this pathway is well-studied in invertebrates, how it specifically functions and adapts in mammals has remained unclear. Mammalian genomes are heavily populated by transposons, and understanding how the piRNA machinery effectively silences them is key to understanding genome defense and fertility. This paper aims to elucidate the molecular mechanisms behind mammalian piRNA targeting and silencing, focusing on the structural and functional differences compared to invertebrates.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Biochemical Assays: Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) was used to measure binding kinetics (affinity, dissociation rates) of piRNA-protein complexes to target RNAs. In vitro cleavage assays were performed to assess the catalytic activity of these complexes.
  • Cryo-Electron Microscopy (Cryo-EM): High-resolution structures of mammalian PIWI-piRNA complexes (MILI and HILI) in both the absence and presence of target RNA were determined. This allowed for detailed visualization of structural features related to target binding and cleavage.
  • Mutagenesis: Specific amino acid residues, particularly a vertebrate-specific lysine, were mutated to understand their role in target binding and cleavage.
  • Sequence Analysis: Phylogenetic analysis was used to place MILI and HILI within the PIWI protein family and to identify conserved and unique features.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mammalian PIWIs are "super-silencers": MILI and HILI show significantly higher target binding affinity and cleavage efficiency compared to their invertebrate counterparts (e.g., Ephydatia fluviatilis Piwi, EfPiwi).
  • A Wider Gate for Broader Access: Mammalian piRISCs possess a wider nucleic-acid-binding channel and a more relaxed "seed gate" mechanism. This structural difference is key to their ability to tolerate mismatches in the piRNA-target duplex.
  • The Vertebrate Lysine Advantage: A specific lysine residue, conserved in vertebrate PIWI proteins but absent in invertebrates, plays a critical role. It interacts with the piRNA backbone, shifting the piRNA-target duplex trajectory and lowering the activation threshold for target binding and cleavage.
  • Mismatch Tolerance = Broader Defense: The ability to tolerate mismatches, especially in the "seed" region, allows mammalian piRISCs to recognize a wider range of targets, making them more effective against the constantly evolving landscape of mobile genetic elements.

Key Results

  • MILI and HILI piRISCs bind targets with 6-fold higher affinity than EfPiwi piRISC.
  • MILI and HILI piRISCs cleave targets 25-fold more efficiently than EfPiwi piRISC.
  • The "seed gate" in mammalian piRISCs is displaced by ~11° compared to EfPiwi, allowing for greater mismatch tolerance.
  • A single lysine mutation in EfPiwi (N959K) increased its target binding and cleavage activity, while mutating the corresponding lysine in MILI/HILI to asparagine (K943N/K945N) reduced their activity, highlighting the lysine's crucial role.
  • Mammalian piRISCs can cleave targets with as little as 14-nt guide-target complementarity, compared to the 19-nt required by EfPiwi.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In vitro vs. In vivo: While the study provides a strong molecular basis, further investigation is needed to fully understand how these conformational differences and auxiliary factors influence MILI/HILI and invertebrate piRISC function in vivo.
  • Other Factors: The authors suggest that other conformational differences or auxiliary factors might contribute to the functional differences observed.
  • Broader Implications: The study opens avenues for understanding how this enhanced silencing machinery contributes to genome defense, fertility, and disease in mammals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The PIWI-interacting RNA (piRNA) pathway is an adaptive defense system wherein piRNAs guide PIWI-family Argonaute proteins to recognize and silence ever-evolving selfish genetic elements and ensure genome integrity. Driven by this intensive host-pathogen arms race, piRNA pathway and its targeted transposons have co-evolved rapidly in a species-specific manner, but how the piRNA pathway specifically adapts to target silencing in mammals remains elusive. Here, we show that mouse MILI and human HILI piRISCs bind and cleave targets more efficiently than their invertebrate counterpart from sponge Ephydatia fluviatilis . The inherent functional differences comport with structural features identified by cryo-EM studies of piRISCs. In the absence of target, MILI and HILI piRISCs adopt a wider nucleic-acid-binding channel and display an extended prearranged piRNA seed as compared to Ef Piwi piRISC, consistent with their ability to capture targets more efficiently than Ef Piwi piRISC. In the presence of target, the seed gate—which enforces seed-target fidelity in microRNA RISC—adopts a relaxed state in mammalian piRISC, revealing how MILI and HILI tolerate seed-target mismatches to broaden the target spectrum. A vertebrate-specific lysine distorts the piRNA seed, shifting the trajectory of the piRNA-target duplex out of the central cleft and toward the PAZ lobe. Functional analyses reveal that this lysine promotes target binding and cleavage. Our study therefore provides a molecular basis for the piRNA targeting mechanism in mouse and human, and suggests that mammalian piRNA machinery can achieve broad target silencing using a limited supply of piRNA species.
BibTeX
@misc{li2023mammalian,
  author = {Zhiqing Li and Zhenzhen Li and Lili Li and Lin Zeng and Junchao Xue and Huilin Niu and Jing Zhong and Qilu Yu and Dengfeng Li and Shikui Tu and ZZ Zhao Zhang and Chun‐Qing Song and Jianping Wu and En-Zhi Shen},
  title = {{Mammalian PIWI-piRNA-target complexes reveal features for broad and efficient target-silencing}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.06.23.546240},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure