Magnetostriction effect of amorphous CoFeB thin films and application in spin-dependent tunnel junctions

Dexin Wang, Cathy Nordman, Zhenghong Qian, J.m. Daughton, John Myers

TL;DR

This paper investigates the magnetostriction effect in amorphous CoFeB thin films and their application in spin-dependent tunnel junctions (SDTs) for strain gauge applications. The researchers found that CoFeB exhibits a significant magnetostriction constant, enabling SDTs to achieve a gauge factor at least 7 times higher than the best existing piezoresistive strain gauges, offering a promising new avenue for high-sensitivity strain sensing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Strain gauges are crucial components in a wide array of sensors, from pressure and acceleration sensors to applications in automotive and aerospace industries. Current strain sensing technologies primarily rely on piezoresistive and capacitive devices. While silicon-based piezoresistive devices offer high sensitivity (gauge factors of 100-200), they suffer from a high temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR), limiting their operation to lower temperatures and requiring complex compensation schemes. Metal piezoresistive devices have a lower TCR, allowing for high-temperature operation, but their sensitivity is significantly lower (gauge factors of 2-6). The paper addresses the need for strain sensors that combine high sensitivity with robust performance across a wider temperature range. The authors explore the potential of amorphous CoFeB thin films, known for their high tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) in SDTs, to also exhibit useful magnetostrictive properties for strain gauge applications.

Methods

The researchers fabricated amorphous CoFeB thin films and spin-dependent tunnel junctions (SDTs) using DC magnetron sputtering. They characterized the magnetic properties of single CoFeB layers using a B-H Loop Tracer and measured magnetostrictive properties using a custom-built fixture that allowed for the application of controlled strains while simultaneously measuring magnetoresistance and magnetic hysteresis loops. For the SDT devices, they investigated the effect of strain on TMR by applying tensile and compressive strains and observing the changes in TMR traces. They also derived equations to relate the magnetostriction constant, magnetic anisotropy, and strain to the gauge factor of the SDT devices.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental fabrication and characterization of CoFeB films and MTJs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CoFeB's Dual Nature: CoFeB is not only excellent for high TMR in SDTs but also possesses significant magnetostrictive properties, making it a versatile material for advanced sensor applications.
  • Strain-Induced Anisotropy Modulation: Applying strain to CoFeB films can dramatically alter their magnetic anisotropy. Tensile strain can effectively "soften" the hard axis, while compressive strain can significantly enhance it, demonstrating a direct link between mechanical stress and magnetic behavior.
  • SDTs as High-Performance Strain Gauges: The magnetostrictive effect in CoFeB within SDT junctions translates into exceptionally high strain sensitivity. The modulation of magnetic anisotropy by strain directly impacts the TMR, leading to a gauge factor far exceeding conventional piezoresistive devices.
  • Reverse Magnetostriction is Key: The study leverages the "reverse effect of magnetostriction" (applying stress to change magnetic properties) to quantify the material's behavior and design strain sensors.

Key Results

  • Amorphous CoFeB films exhibited excellent soft magnetic properties: saturation magnetization of 1.5 T, near-zero hard axis coercivity, low easy axis coercivity of 2.0 Oe, and an induced magnetic anisotropy field of 32 Oe.
  • The saturation magnetostriction constant (λ) for CoFeB was measured to be +31 ppm, significantly higher than non-magnetostrictive materials like Permalloy (λ < 0.1 ppm).
  • When subjected to strain, the magnetic hard axis loops of CoFeB films showed substantial changes. Compressive strain doubled the effective anisotropy from 32 Oe to 64 Oe.
  • SDT junctions using CoFeB as free layers demonstrated a dramatic change in TMR behavior under strain. A tensile strain perpendicular to the easy axis transformed the easy axis TMR loop into a hard axis TMR loop.
  • The calculated gauge factor (Se) for these magnetostrictive SDT devices was approximately 1490, and a measured value of 1416 was obtained. This is at least 7 times higher than the best Si-based piezoresistive devices (max ~200) and more than two orders of magnitude higher than metallic piezoresistive devices (2-6).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temperature Dependence: While the paper highlights the potential for high-temperature operation due to the nature of the materials, the explicit temperature dependence of the magnetostrictive effect and the resulting gauge factor is not extensively studied or presented.
  • Long-Term Stability: The long-term stability and reliability of these magnetostrictive SDT strain gauges under various environmental conditions (temperature cycling, humidity, mechanical fatigue) are not addressed.
  • Further Optimization: The authors suggest that the gauge factor can be further increased by enhancing TMR and λ, and decreasing Hk and Ms. Future work could focus on optimizing the CoFeB composition, layer structure, and junction fabrication to achieve even higher sensitivities. Exploring different buffer and overcoat layers for improved performance and integration is also a potential avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

CoFeB thin films and magnetic tunnel junctions using them are studied for magnetostriction effect. The single-layer films were sputter deposited with excellent soft magnetic properties including a high saturation magnetization of 1.5T, a near-zero hard axis coercivity, a low easy axis coercivity of 2.0Oe, and an induced magnetic anisotropy field of 32Oe. The saturation magnetostriction constant is measured to be 31ppm. Magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) were fabricated and tested for potential strain gauge applications. The gauge factor for the magnetostrictive MTJs, a measure of strain sensitivity, is many times of the best piezoresistive devices.
BibTeX
@article{wang2005magnetostriction,
  author = {Dexin Wang and Cathy Nordman and Zhenghong Qian and J.M. Daughton and John Myers},
  title = {{Magnetostriction effect of amorphous CoFeB thin films and application in spin-dependent tunnel junctions}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physics},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1063/1.1848355},
}

Loading related content...

Figure