Macroeconomic Development and Dramatic Increase in Stroke Burden in Rural China: A 25-Year Population-Based Study

Peng Zhao, Jie Liu, Yuhan Hao, Qiuxing Lin, Ying Gao, Jun Tu, Jinghua Wang, Yaogang Wang, Xianjia Ning

TL;DR

This study reveals a significant positive correlation between rapid economic development in rural China and a dramatic increase in stroke incidence over 25 years. As GDP and per capita income rose, so did the rates of both ischemic and hemorrhagic strokes, with a notable trend towards younger stroke onset in men.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, stroke remains a major cause of death and disability, with developing countries experiencing a disproportionately larger increase in stroke burden compared to developed nations. While socioeconomic status is known to be linked to stroke risk, there's a critical knowledge gap regarding the quantitative relationship between national economic development indicators and the actual burden of stroke, particularly in rapidly industrializing regions. This paper aims to fill that gap by investigating how macroeconomic growth in rural China has influenced stroke incidence and age of onset over a substantial period.

Methods

The researchers conducted a 25-year prospective, population-based study in a rural township in Tianjin, China. They collected data on annual stroke events and deaths from 1992 to 2016. Macroeconomic development was quantified using two key indicators:

  • Purchasing Power Parity Adjusted Gross Domestic Product (PPP-aGDP): This metric, adjusted for inflation and exchange rates, provides a standardized measure of economic output.
  • Per Capita Net Income (PCNI): This represents the individual purchasing power of rural residents.

The study assessed the association between changes in PPP-aGDP and PCNI with first-ever stroke incidence and age at stroke onset. Statistical analysis involved linear regression models to estimate the percentage change in stroke incidence and years of change in age of onset per unit increase in the economic indicators.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a prospective, population-based cohort in Yangjinzhuang, a township in Tianjin, China. This cohort comprised 15,438 residents, with a focus on low-income farmers. The dataset included:

  • Annual registrations of stroke events (first-ever strokes) and all-cause deaths from 1992 to 2016.
  • 362,296 person-years of surveillance data.
  • Demographic information and diagnostic data (ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage) for stroke patients.

The study also incorporated national macroeconomic data for China, specifically PPP-aGDP and PCNI for rural residents, over the same 1992-2016 period.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Economic Growth Fuels Stroke Burden: The most striking finding is the direct, positive correlation between rising economic indicators (GDP and income) and increasing stroke incidence. This challenges the assumption that economic development inherently leads to better health outcomes without targeted interventions.
  • Rural Areas Hit Hardest: The study highlights that this trend is particularly pronounced in rural China, suggesting that the rapid changes associated with industrialization and urbanization may disproportionately affect these populations.
  • Younger Onset for Hemorrhagic Stroke: A concerning insight is the decrease in the age of onset for intracerebral hemorrhage, especially in men, as the economy grew. This indicates that the impact of economic development isn't just about more strokes, but potentially more severe strokes occurring earlier in life.
  • Lifestyle Shifts as a Driver: The paper posits that economic development leads to significant lifestyle changes, including reduced physical labor, increased food availability (often less healthy), and shifts towards diets high in sodium and fat. These factors likely contribute to the rise in stroke risk factors like hypertension and obesity.

Key Results

  • Overall Stroke Incidence: For every $1,000 USD increase in PPP-aGDP, overall first-ever stroke incidence increased by 10.7%. Similarly, for every 1,000 Yuan increase in PCNI, incidence rose by 12.0%.
  • Gender Differences: Women experienced a slightly higher percentage increase in stroke incidence with economic growth (13.0% for PPP-aGDP, 14.4% for PCNI) compared to men (9.6% for PPP-aGDP, 10.8% for PCNI).
  • Stroke Subtypes: Ischemic stroke incidence saw a substantial increase (12.6% for PPP-aGDP, 14.3% for PCNI), while intracerebral hemorrhage also increased (6.2% for both indicators).
  • Age of Onset: In men, the age of intracerebral hemorrhage onset decreased by 0.96 years per $1,000 USD increase in PPP-aGDP and by 1.08 years per 1,000 Yuan increase in PCNI.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in a single township in northern China, which may not be representative of the entire Chinese population or other developing countries.
  • Individual Income: The study used national PCNI rather than individual income, which could lead to under- or overestimation of the relationship.
  • Neuroimaging Application: The increasing application of neuroimaging techniques over the study period might have contributed to the apparent increase in stroke diagnoses. However, the authors note that only symptomatic strokes were included, mitigating some of this bias.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the critical need for enhanced healthcare investments to manage stroke risk factors during periods of rapid economic development. They suggest that their findings can serve as a reference for other developing countries to establish effective stroke prevention strategies during their initial stages of economic growth. Further nationwide studies are recommended to fully understand the impact of economic development on stroke burden.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low socioeconomic status is associated with a high stroke risk. However, few studies have quantitatively assessed the relationship between stroke burden and national economic development indicators. We explored the quantitative association between macroeconomic development and stroke burden in rural China. In this population-based, prospective study (1992-2016), we collected data on annual registrations of stroke events and deaths in Tianjin, China. Economic development over the period was represented by gross domestic product annually adjusted for purchasing power parity (PPP-aGDP) and per capita net income (PCNI) of rural residents in China. We assessed the association of first-ever stroke incidence with PPP-aGDP and PCNI. During the 25-year study period, there were 1,185 stroke events and 362,296 person years of surveillance. First-ever stroke incidence increased by an average of 10.7% per 1,000 USD increase in overall PPP-aGDP and by 12.0% per 1,000 Yuan increase in PCNI; respectively, the mean increases were 9.6 and 10.8% in men and 13.0 and 14.4% in women (all, <i>P</i> < 0.001). These same changes in PPP-aGDP and PCNI also resulted in increases in the incidence of ischemic stroke (12.6 and 14.3%, respectively; <i>P</i> < 0.05), and intracerebral hemorrhage (both, 6.2%; <i>P</i> < 0.05). Similarly, in men, the age of onset of intracerebral hemorrhage decreased by 0.96-years (<i>P</i> = 0.002) for each 1,000 USD increase in PPP-aGDP and by 1.08-years (<i>P</i> = 0.003) for each 1,000 Yuan increase in PCNI. Macroeconomic development was positively associated with stroke incidence in rural China. Thus, enhancing health-care investments is crucial for containing the stroke burden during this remarkable economic development in China. Our findings could guide other developing countries with information regarding the timely control of stroke risk factors and reductions in stroke burden during the initial stages of economic development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020macroeconomic,
  author = {Peng Zhao and Jie Liu and Yuhan Hao and Qiuxing Lin and Ying Gao and Jun Tu and Jinghua Wang and Yaogang Wang and Xianjia Ning},
  title = {{Macroeconomic Development and Dramatic Increase in Stroke Burden in Rural China: A 25-Year Population-Based Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2020.00385},
}
Figure