Machine learning in the prediction of cardiac epicardial and mediastinal fat volumes

Érick O. Rodrigues, V. H. A. Pinheiro, Panos Liatsis, Aura Conci

TL;DR

This paper introduces a computational shortcut for cardiac risk assessment by demonstrating that epicardial and mediastinal fat volumes are highly correlated. By using machine learning to predict one fat volume from the other, researchers can cut the time-intensive process of medical image segmentation in half—from 1.8 hours down to roughly 0.9 hours—without sacrificing significant accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cardiac epicardial fat (located inside the pericardium) and mediastinal fat (located outside it) are critical biomarkers for cardiovascular risks, including coronary artery calcification and atherosclerosis. However, quantifying these fats in Computed Tomography (CT) scans is a bottleneck.

Manual segmentation by experts is tedious and prone to observer bias, while even state-of-the-art automated methods can take nearly two hours to process a single patient scan. The authors set out to determine if they could leverage the inherent relationship between these two fat depots to simplify the workflow. If you segment one, can a machine learning model accurately "guess" the other?

![Fig.

  1. A cross-section of the heart (top) and the associated cardiac layers (bottom).](/figures/art_7448b0b6fa3e44d2afc9f8c00418447b)

Methods

The researchers treated the volume estimation as a regression problem. They extracted seven key features from 878 CT image slices, including pixel counts for different fat types (manually labeled as red, green, or grey), the pericardium (blue), and background (black), alongside metadata like the slice index and total scan length.

They benchmarked a diverse array of algorithms, ranging from simple Linear Regression to complex ensembles like Rotation Forest combined with Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) Regressors.

A unique aspect of this study was the exploration of "interpretability vs. performance." While complex models often yield the best numbers, the authors also derived explicit linear equations (e.g., predicting mediastinal fat based on epicardial fat and slice index) that clinicians could theoretically use without specialized software.

Datasets

The study utilized a ground-truth dataset consisting of axial-plane CT scans from 20 patients, totaling 878 images.

  • Expert Labeling: Two experts manually segmented the fats to provide the "gold standard."
  • Hardware Diversity: The data came from two different manufacturers (Siemens and Philips), which is crucial for ensuring the models aren't overfitted to a specific scanner's characteristics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Predictive Asymmetry: The models were significantly better at predicting mediastinal fat based on epicardial fat than vice versa. This suggests that epicardial fat—the fat closest to the heart—contains more information about the overall cardiac environment.
  • The Power of Ensembles: The Rotation Forest + MLP combination consistently outperformed individual models, achieving near-perfect correlation coefficients.
  • Interpretability Matters: Even though Linear Regression was less accurate, it achieved a correlation of 0.95 for mediastinal fat prediction. This provides a "good enough" solution that is transparent and easy to implement in a clinical setting.
  • Segmentation is Still Necessary: Attempting to predict fat volumes from raw, unprocessed greyscale images (without segmenting at least one fat type first) led to a massive drop in accuracy, with errors nearly doubling.

![Fig.

  1. Example of input images for the prediction of epicardial and mediastinal fat. (a) Input images when predicting epicardial (red) pixels (b) Input images when predicting mediastinal (green) pixels.](/figures/art_9cb9b050000b4ce5bdff34568542a146)

Key Results

  • Top Performance: The Rotation Forest + MLP Regressor achieved a correlation coefficient ($\rho$) of 0.9876 for predicting mediastinal fat from epicardial fat, with a Relative Absolute Error (RAE) of only 14.4%.
  • Reverse Prediction: Predicting epicardial fat from mediastinal fat was slightly less accurate but still strong, with a $\rho$ of 0.9683 and an RAE of 19.6%.
  • Efficiency: By only requiring the segmentation of one fat type, the total processing time per patient scan is reduced by approximately 50% (from 1.8h to 0.9h).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their ground truth relies on automated registration, which can introduce subtle errors. Furthermore, some models (like Linear Regression) occasionally predicted negative fat volumes—a physical impossibility that could be corrected in the future through normalization or rectification layers.

Future research will focus on testing these models on larger datasets from a wider variety of CT scanner manufacturers to further validate their generalization properties and refining the linear functions for easier clinical adoption.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a methodology to predict the cardiac epicardial and mediastinal fat volumes in computed tomography images using regression algorithms. The obtained results indicate that it is feasible to predict these fats with a high degree of correlation, thus alleviating the requirement for manual or automatic segmentation of both fat volumes. Instead, segmenting just one of them suffices, while the volume of the other may be predicted fairly precisely. The correlation coefficient obtained by the Rotation Forest algorithm using MLP Regressor for predicting the mediastinal fat based on the epicardial fat was 0.9876, with a relative absolute error of 14.4% and a root relative squared error of 15.7%. The best correlation coefficient obtained in the prediction of the epicardial fat based on the mediastinal was 0.9683 with a relative absolute error of 19.6% and a relative squared error of 24.9%. Moreover, we analysed the feasibility of using linear regressors, which provide an intuitive interpretation of the underlying approximations. In this case, the obtained correlation coefficient was 0.9534 for predicting the mediastinal fat based on the epicardial, with a relative absolute error of 31.6% and a root relative squared error of 30.1%. On the prediction of the epicardial fat based on the mediastinal fat, the correlation coefficient was 0.8531, with a relative absolute error of 50.43% and a root relative squared error of 52.06%. In summary, it is possible to speed up general medical analyses and some segmentation and quantification methods that are currently employed in the state-of-the-art by using this prediction approach, which consequently reduces costs and therefore enables preventive treatments that may lead to a reduction of health problems.
BibTeX
@misc{rodrigues2022machine,
  author = {Érick O. Rodrigues and V. H. A. Pinheiro and Panos Liatsis and Aura Conci},
  title = {{Machine learning in the prediction of cardiac epicardial and mediastinal fat volumes}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.14374},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.14374},
}
Figure