Low‐Mass X‐Ray Binaries in Six Elliptical Galaxies: Connection to Globular Clusters

Eunhyeuk Kim, Dongwoo Kim, G. Fabbiano, Myung Gyoon Lee, Hong Soo Park, D. Geisler, B. DirschThe Astrophysical Journal 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents the largest sample to date of low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) associated with globular clusters (GCs) in six elliptical galaxies. The findings confirm that metallicity and GC luminosity are key factors in LMXB formation, and reveal a surprising dependence on galacto-centric distance, suggesting a second, as-yet-unknown, formation parameter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Astronomers have long observed a connection between globular clusters (GCs) and low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs), systems where a compact object (like a neutron star or black hole) accretes matter from a low-mass companion star, producing intense X-ray emission. Specifically, LMXBs appear to be more common in metal-rich GCs (red GCs) than in metal-poor GCs (blue GCs), and brighter GCs tend to host more LMXBs. However, the exact physical mechanisms driving this association and the role of other factors remain unclear. This paper aims to systematically investigate this GC-LMXB connection by analyzing a large sample of galaxies and their GCs and LMXBs, seeking to identify additional parameters that influence LMXB formation within GCs.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-wavelength approach, combining X-ray data from the Chandra telescope with optical data from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and ground-based observatories. They used sophisticated X-ray and optical photometry techniques to identify and characterize both X-ray point sources (potential LMXBs) and globular cluster candidates. Rigorous matching criteria were applied to associate X-ray sources with GCs, and statistical methods were used to assess the significance of these associations and to compare the properties of different LMXB populations (GC-associated vs. field LMXBs, and red vs. blue GC-associated LMXBs). They also analyzed the radial distributions of these populations to understand spatial dependencies.

Datasets

  • Chandra Archival Data: Used to identify 665 X-ray point sources in six elliptical galaxies.
  • HST Archival Data (WFPC2): Used for high-resolution optical imaging to identify globular cluster candidates.
  • Ground-based Optical Observations: Supplemented HST data to increase the sample size and coverage of globular clusters.
  • USNO-B1 Catalog: Used for astrometric calibration of optical source positions.
  • Hubble Deep Fields (HDF) Catalogs: Used as an independent test for contamination in the GC sample.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Metallicity is King (Still): The strong preference for LMXBs to reside in metal-rich GCs is confirmed, reinforcing metallicity as a primary driver of LMXB formation in GCs.
  • Brighter GCs, More LMXBs (with a Twist): While brighter (more massive) GCs are indeed more likely to host LMXBs, this trend is significantly stronger in red GCs than in blue GCs, suggesting a complex interplay between mass and metallicity.
  • The Central Advantage: GCs located closer to the galaxy's center are more likely to host LMXBs than those in the outskirts. This radial dependence is a novel finding and hints at a crucial, yet unidentified, factor influencing LMXB formation.
  • Beyond Metallicity: The steeper radial profile of GC-LMXBs compared to the overall GC population, and its similarity to the galaxy's halo light profile, strongly suggests that galacto-centric distance plays a significant role, possibly through a distance-dependent encounter rate.
  • No X-ray Spectral Differences: Surprisingly, the X-ray spectral properties of LMXBs in red GCs, blue GCs, and field LMXBs are statistically indistinguishable, which challenges some theoretical models.
  • BHs in GCs? Maybe: The similarity in X-ray luminosity functions between GC-LMXBs and field-LMXBs suggests that black hole binaries might not be as rare in GCs as previously thought, contrary to findings in the Milky Way.

Key Results

  • Identified 6173 globular cluster candidates and 665 X-ray point sources in six elliptical galaxies.
  • Associated 209 LMXBs with red GCs (RGCs) and 76 with blue GCs (BGCs), with 258 LMXBs having no optical GC counterpart (field LMXBs).
  • Confirmed that RGCs are approximately 3 times more likely to host LMXBs than BGCs.
  • Found that the luminosity-mass dependency for LMXB hosting is stronger in RGCs than in BGCs.
  • Demonstrated that GCs closer to the galaxy center have a higher probability of hosting LMXBs.
  • Showed that GC-LMXBs have a steeper radial distribution than the overall GC population, similar to the galaxy's halo light profile.
  • Found no statistically significant differences in X-ray properties (luminosity function, Lx/Lv, spectra) among RGC-LMXBs, BGC-LMXBs, and field-LMXBs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Contamination: While efforts were made to minimize contamination from background galaxies and foreground stars, some level of misclassification is inherent in such studies. The authors estimate a systematic error of 5-10% due to contamination and false matches.
  • Sample Size: While this is the largest GC-LMXB sample to date, the number of LMXBs in some specific categories (e.g., faint GCs, or in certain radial bins) can still be small, limiting the statistical power for some analyses.
  • Theoretical Models: The lack of significant differences in X-ray spectra between RGC-LMXBs and BGC-LMXBs challenges some existing theoretical models for LMXB formation, particularly the irradiation-induced stellar wind model.
  • Unidentified Parameter: The most significant future direction highlighted is the need to identify the "second parameter" that, in addition to metallicity, governs LMXB formation in GCs and depends on galacto-centric distance. Further theoretical modeling and observational studies are needed to elucidate this factor, which could be related to encounter rates, GC core densities, or other dynamical processes. The question of whether GCs can host BH X-ray binaries also warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a systematic study of the low mass X-ray binary (LMXB) populations of 6 elliptical galaxies. We utilize Chandra archival data to identify 665 X-ray point sources and HST archival data supplemented by ground observations to identify 6173 GCs. We associate 209 LMXBs with red GC (RGC) and 76 LMXBs with blue GCs (BGC), while we find no optical GC counterpart for 258 LMXBs. This is the largest GC-LMXB sample studied so far. We confirm previous reports suggesting that the fraction of GCs associated with LMXBs is 3 times larger in RGCs than in BGCs, indicating that metallicity is a primary factor in the GC-LMXB formation. While as already known, the brighter (and bigger) GCs have a higher probability to host LMXBs, we find that this optical luminosity (or mass) dependency is stronger in RGCs than in BGCs. We also find that GCs located near the galaxy center have a higher probability to harbor LMXBs compared to those in the outskirts. The radial distributions of GC-LMXBs (for both RGC and BGC) are steeper than those of the whole optical GC sample, but consistent with those of the optical halo light, suggesting that there must be another parameter (in addition to metallicity) governing LMXB formation in GCs. This second parameter must depend on the galacto-centric distance. We find no statistically significant difference in the X-ray properties among RGC-LMXBs, BGC-LMXBs and field-LMXBs. The similarity of the X-ray spectra of BGC-LMXBs and RGC-LMXBs is inconsistent with the irradiation-induced stellar wind model prediction. The similarity of the X-ray luminosity functions (XLFs) of GC-LMXBs and field-LMXBs indicates that there is no significant difference in the fraction of BH binaries present in these two populations, in contrast to Galactic LMXBs where BH binaries are not found in GCs.
BibTeX
@article{kim2006lowmass,
  author = {Eunhyeuk Kim and Dongwoo Kim and G. Fabbiano and Myung Gyoon Lee and Hong Soo Park and D. Geisler and B. Dirsch},
  title = {{Low‐Mass X‐Ray Binaries in Six Elliptical Galaxies: Connection to Globular Clusters}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1086/505261},
}
Figure