Low-threshold nanolasers based on miniaturized bound states in the continuum

Yuhao Ren, Peishen Li, Zhuojun Liu, Zihao Chen, You-Ling Chen, Chao Peng, Jin LiuarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully shrunk "Bound States in the Continuum" (BIC) lasers down to the wavelength scale by combining them with photonic band gaps. This hybrid approach achieved a record-high quality factor of 32,500 and a record-low lasing threshold, proving that high-performance, ultra-compact lasers are viable for next-generation on-chip photonics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

To build faster computers and more sensitive biosensors, we need lasers that are incredibly small and consume very little power. However, as you shrink a laser, it becomes harder to keep the light trapped; it tends to "leak" out, leading to high energy losses.

Recently, physicists have used Bound States in the Continuum (BICs)—a phenomenon where light waves are trapped even though they technically have enough energy to escape—to create efficient lasers. The catch? Most BIC lasers are "bulky" (relatively speaking) because they require large, periodic arrays to maintain their properties. They lack "in-plane" confinement, meaning light is trapped vertically but can leak out sideways. This paper tackles the challenge of achieving true three-dimensional (3D) light confinement at the nanoscale without sacrificing the high efficiency (Quality factor) that BICs provide.

Methods

The authors developed a "mini-BIC" structure using a suspended gallium arsenide (GaAs) membrane. Their approach relies on two clever spatial engineering tricks:

  1. Vertical Confinement (The BIC): The central region of the device (Region A) is designed to support BIC modes, which prevents light from escaping out of the plane of the chip.
  2. In-Plane Confinement (The PBG): They surrounded the central region with a different lattice of holes (Region B) that acts as a Photonic Band Gap (PBG). This acts like a mirror for light trying to escape sideways, reflecting it back into the center.
  3. Gain Material: To provide the light-amplifying "juice," they embedded three layers of high-density Indium Arsenide (InAs) Quantum Dots (QDs). These dots provide 3D carrier confinement, ensuring the electrons stay where the light is.

The team used electron-beam lithography and dry etching to create these patterns with nanometer precision, then used a selective wet etch to "suspend" the membrane in the air, further isolating the light.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, this work does not use traditional computational datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of:

  • Micro-photoluminescence (µ-PL) spectra: Measuring the light output across different wavelengths.
  • Photon Statistics ($g^{(2)}(\tau)$): Using superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors to measure the timing between emitted photons. This is the "gold standard" for proving a device is actually lasing rather than just acting as a bright LED.
  • Simulated Q-factors: Theoretical benchmarks created using finite-element modeling to compare against experimental results.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Hybrid Advantage: By combining BICs (for vertical trapping) with PBGs (for horizontal trapping), the researchers created a "mini-BIC" that maintains an incredibly high Quality (Q) factor despite its tiny footprint.
  • Lasing vs. "Nano-LED": A major insight of the paper is a warning to the field: simply seeing a "kink" in a power curve or a narrowing of the spectral line is not enough to claim a device is a nanolaser. By comparing a "good" device with a "less optimal" one, they showed that both can look like lasers on the surface, but only the high-Q device showed the true quantum phase transition to coherent light (demonstrated via photon statistics).
  • Topological Engineering: The Q-factor can be "tuned" by slightly adjusting the lattice constant of the holes, allowing them to merge multiple BICs in momentum space to create a "super-BIC" with even lower losses.

Key Results

  • Record-High Q-Factor: The active BIC resonators achieved a Q-factor of 32,500, the highest reported for this type of miniaturized structure.
  • Ultra-Low Threshold: The device achieved single-mode continuous wave (CW) lasing with a threshold of only 80 W/cm². This is nearly two orders of magnitude lower than previously reported BIC lasers.
  • Telecom Ready: The lasers operate in the O-band (~1300 nm), which is a standard wavelength for fiber-optic communications.
  • Proven Coherence: Through second-order coherence measurements ($g^{(2)}(0)$), they confirmed the transition from spontaneous emission (thermal light) to stimulated emission (coherent laser light).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optical Pumping: Currently, the laser must be "pumped" by another external laser. For practical use in a computer chip, the researchers need to develop a version that can be triggered by electrical injection (plugging it into a circuit).
  • Thermal Management: While the threshold is low, suspended membranes are fragile and poor at dissipating heat. Future designs might explore ways to bond these nanolasers to more robust substrates like silicon.
  • Structured Light: The authors suggest that the "vectorial nature" of BICs could be used to create lasers that emit "vortex beams" (light that twists like a corkscrew), which could be used for high-capacity data encoding.

Summary updated

Abstract

The pursuit of compact lasers with low-thresholds has imposed strict requirements on tight light confinements with minimized radiation losses. Bound states in the continuum (BICs) have been recently demonstrated as an effective mechanism to trap light along the out-of-plane direction, paving the way to low-threshold lasers. To date, most reported BIC lasers are still bulky due to the absence of in-plane light confinement. In this work, we combine BICs and photonic band gaps to realize three-dimensional (3D) light confinements, as referred to miniaturized (mini-) BICs. Together with 3D carrier confinements provided by quantum dots (QDs) as optical gain materials, we have realized highly-compact active BIC resonators with a record-high quality ($Q$) factor up to 32500, which enables single-mode continuous wave (CW) lasing with the lowest threshold of 80 W/cm$^{2}$ among the reported BIC lasers. In addidtion, our photon statistics measurements under both CW and pulsed excitations confirm the occurence of the phase transition from spontaneous emission to stimulated emission, further suggesting that conventional criteria of input-output and linewidth are not sufficient for claiming nanoscale lasing. Our work reveal a via path towards compact BIC lasers with ultra-low power consumption and potentially boost the applications in cavity quantum electrodynamics (QEDs), nonlinear optics and integrated photonics.
BibTeX
@misc{ren2022low,
  author = {Yuhao Ren and Peishen Li and Zhuojun Liu and Zihao Chen and You-Ling Chen and Chao Peng and Jin Liu},
  title = {{Low-threshold nanolasers based on miniaturized bound states in the continuum}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.08950},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.08950},
}

Loading related content...

Figure