Abstract
Achieving ubiquitous ultra-reliable low latency consensus in centralized wireless communication systems can be costly and hard to scale up. The consensus mechanism, which has been widely utilized in distributed systems, can provide fault tolerance to the critical consensus, even though the individual communication link reliability is relatively low. In this article, a widely used consensus mechanism, Raft, is introduced to the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) to achieve ultra-reliable and low latency consensus, where the consensus reliability performance in terms of nodes number and link transmission reliability is investigated. We propose a new concept, Reliability Gain, to show the linear relationship between consensus reliability and communication link transmission reliability. We also find that the time latency of consensus is contradictory to consensus reliability. These conclusions can provide guides to deploy Raft protocol in distributed IIoT systems.
Introduction
Mission-critical Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) applications—such as autonomous vehicle platooning and factory robotics—demand Ultra-Reliable Low Latency Communications (URLLC). Traditionally, these systems rely on centralized architectures where a single controller makes decisions. However, centralized systems are expensive to scale, suffer from "single point of failure" risks, and struggle with the inherent instability of wireless channels.
The challenge lies in guaranteeing extreme reliability (the "nine nines" standard) using wireless links prone to interference. This research proposes moving away from centralized control toward distributed consensus using the Raft protocol. In this model, nodes work together to agree on a state, allowing the system to remain functional even if several individual communication links fail.
Methods
The study focuses on the Raft consensus algorithm, modeled for IIoT environments. Key methodological steps included:
- Mathematical Modeling: Deriving the probability of consensus success ($P_C$) based on individual link success rates ($P_l$) using binomial distribution summations.
- Reliability Gain ($k$): Proposing a new metric to quantify how much the consensus mechanism amplifies the reliability of a single link.
- Latency-Reliability Analysis: Using a wireless short-packet transmission model to map how total consensus latency ($T$) affects individual packet error rates.
- Simulation: Validating analytical formulas using MATLAB simulations with standard 18 kHz bandwidth and 10 dB SINR parameters.
Key Insights and Results
One of the most significant findings is the log-linear relationship between consensus failure and link failure. The Reliability Gain ($k$) is approximately $(N+1)/2$, where $N$ is the number of nodes. This implies that adding nodes increases the "amplification" of reliability linearly.
However, there is a fundamental trade-off. While adding nodes increases redundancy, it also consumes more time because the leader must communicate with more followers. Since the total time budget ($T$) for a mission-critical task is fixed, more nodes mean less time allocated per individual transmission. This creates a "Goldilocks" problem where an optimal number of nodes exists; beyond this point, reliability actually decreases as individual link quality drops due to insufficient transmission time.
Simulation results perfectly overlap with analytical curves, proving the model's accuracy. The paper demonstrates that even with a poor link success rate of 90%, a distributed system can achieve $1-10^{-9}$ reliability with 69 nodes. If link reliability improves to 99.9%, only 5 nodes are required to reach the same goal.
Conclusion
This research mathematically proves that consensus reliability and time latency are contradictory in distributed IIoT. While increasing allowed latency consistently improves reliability, IIoT systems often face hard constraints. Future work will focus on optimizing resource allocation to balance the trade-off between node count and latency, and extending the model to protect against Byzantine (malicious) failures.
Summary updated