Low cost underwater acoustic localization

Eduardo Alexander Iscar Ruland, Atulya Shree, Nicholas Goumas, Matthew Johnson‐RobersonProceedings of Meetings on Acoustics 2017

TL;DR

This paper introduces a low-cost, one-way travel time (OWTT) acoustic ranging system to enable accurate localization of deep-sea micro-AUVs. By fusing this acoustic data with existing odometry sensors, the system significantly improves localization accuracy, paving the way for more affordable deep-ocean exploration and mapping.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Exploring and monitoring the vast deep ocean is crucial, but the high cost of marine robotic platforms, particularly for deep-sea operations, has been a major barrier. A significant contributor to this cost is the challenge of accurately localizing underwater vehicles. Unlike surface vessels that can use GPS, underwater vehicles rely on acoustic sensing, which can be complex and expensive. Existing solutions often require precise time synchronization between multiple nodes or are too bulky and power-hungry for small, cost-sensitive micro-AUVs. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a low-cost, simplified acoustic localization system suitable for these smaller platforms.

Methods

The core of the proposed system is a low-cost, one-way travel time (OWTT) acoustic ranging system. This approach simplifies the traditional two-way travel time (TWTT) method by only measuring the time it takes for an acoustic signal to travel from a transmitter (e.g., a surface buoy) to a receiver (the AUV). This reduces the need for complex synchronization between the AUV and the buoys, as only the transmitter needs to know its precise time.

Key components and techniques include:

  • Custom Acoustic Transducers: The paper details the design and fabrication of low-cost piezoelectric transducers, exploring different configurations (e.g., single ring, double stack, air-gapped) to optimize performance and sensitivity.
  • OWTT Range Estimation: The system uses the time-of-flight of acoustic pings to estimate the distance between the AUV and surface buoys.
  • Signal Processing: A Short-Time Fourier Transform (SDFT) is used for efficient real-time signal detection and a matched filter is employed to estimate the precise time delay between the transmitted and received signals. This delay, combined with the speed of sound in water, yields the range measurement.
  • Sensor Fusion (Pose Graph): The acoustic range measurements are integrated into a pose graph framework. This framework combines various sensor inputs (visual odometry, IMU, pressure sensor, GPS) to create a global optimization problem for estimating the AUV's state (position and orientation). This approach is favored over traditional filtering methods for its ability to incorporate all measurements and past poses for smoother trajectories and improved accuracy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on hardware development and simulation-based evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OWTT as a Cost-Effective Solution: By simplifying the acoustic ranging to one-way travel time, the system significantly reduces the complexity and cost associated with time synchronization, making it more accessible for low-cost AUVs.
  • Custom Transducer Design Matters: The paper demonstrates that careful design and configuration of piezoelectric transducers can lead to improved sensitivity and performance, even with low-cost materials and fabrication methods.
  • Pose Graphs for Robust Localization: Integrating acoustic range data into a pose graph framework proves highly effective, allowing for global optimization and smoother trajectory estimation compared to traditional filtering methods.
  • Synergy of Acoustic and Odometry Data: The fusion of acoustic range measurements with existing dead-reckoning (odometry) sensors provides a substantial improvement in localization accuracy, especially in environments where visual odometry is unreliable (e.g., deep water).
  • Single Buoy Improvement: Even a single acoustic beacon can provide significant localization improvements, particularly along the radial direction from the buoy.

Key Results

  • Hardware Experiments: The OWTT system demonstrated high precision in range measurements in a freshwater pool, achieving an average standard deviation of 3.6cm. A constant offset of approximately 15cm was observed, which the authors suggest can be compensated for.
  • Simulation Results:
    • Dive Sequence: The addition of acoustic range information reduced the RMS position error from 10.04m (odometry only) to 2.85m.
  • Lawn Survey (Single Buoy): RMS position error was reduced from 3.76m to 1.30m.
  • Lawn Survey (Two Buoys): RMS position error was further reduced to 1.04m, demonstrating the benefit of multiple beacons for improved accuracy in both X and Y directions.
  • The simulations showed that acoustic range sensors provide significant correction capabilities radially from the transmitter, but errors can still accumulate tangentially.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • Tangential Error Correction: The current system's ability to correct errors along the tangential direction to the buoy is limited.
  • Constant Offset: A consistent offset was observed in hardware range measurements, requiring further investigation and compensation.
  • Limited Range: The paper doesn't explicitly state the maximum effective range of the system, but the experiments were conducted at relatively short distances (up to 2.5m in hardware tests and simulated surveys with buoys at moderate distances).
  • Future Work:
    • Extending System Range: Future work will focus on increasing the effective range of the acoustic system.
  • Onboard Processing: Integrating all data processing onto the embedded microcontroller of the AUV is a key goal.
  • Delay Compensation: Further characterization of delays introduced during processing will enable compensation for the detected constant offset.
  • Multi-Buoy Systems: Exploring the benefits of using multiple buoys for improved performance and redundancy in survey missions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over the course of the last decade, the cost of marine robotic platforms has significantly decreased. In part this has lowered the barriers to entry of exploring and monitoring larger areas of the earth’s oceans. However, these advances have been mostly focused on autonomous surface vehicles (ASVs) or shallow water autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs). One of the main drivers for high cost in the deep water domain is the challenge of localizing such vehicles using acoustics. A low cost one-way travel time underwater ranging system is proposed to assist in localizing deep water submersibles. The system consists of location aware anchor buoys at the surface and underwater nodes. This paper presents a comparison of methods together with details on the physical implementation to allow its integration into a deep sea micro AUV currently in development. Additional simulation results show error reductions by a factor of three.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruland2017low,
  author = {Eduardo Alexander Iscar Ruland and Atulya Shree and Nicholas Goumas and Matthew Johnson‐Roberson},
  title = {{Low cost underwater acoustic localization}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure