Lorentzian contours for tree-level string amplitudes

Lorenz Eberhardt, Sebastian Mizera

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel mathematical framework using "generalized Pochhammer contours" to calculate string scattering amplitudes directly in physical, Lorentzian spacetime. By leveraging the combinatorics of the associahedron, they performed the first-ever numerical computations for high-point string interactions (up to 9 particles), providing an open-source tool for the community.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In string theory, calculating how strings scatter (amplitudes) is traditionally done using Euclidean Riemann surfaces—essentially treating the worldsheet of the string as a static, "flat" mathematical object. However, our universe is Lorentzian (time behaves differently than space).

When physicists try to translate these Euclidean calculations into the physical Lorentzian world, they hit a wall: the integrals used to calculate these amplitudes diverge (blow up to infinity). Standard mathematical fixes, like the Deligne–Mumford compactification, don't solve the underlying convergence issues. Consequently, researchers haven't been able to simply "plug and play" string formulas into a computer to get numerical results for complex interactions involving many strings.

Methods

The authors "engineer" a specific integration path called a Lorentzian contour ($\Gamma_n$) on the complexified moduli space of the strings. Key components of their method include:

  • Generalized Pochhammer Contours: Instead of integrating over a real interval that hits a singularity, they wrap the integration path around the singularity in a complex "loop." This resums the divergences into explicit prefactors (like sine functions) that make the physical resonance poles manifest.
  • Associahedron Combinatorics: The "moduli space" (the space of all possible string shapes) is partitioned using the geometry of the associahedron (or Stasheff polytope). Each face of this shape corresponds to a specific way particles can be exchanged (a Feynman diagram).
  • Triangulation and Schwinger Parameters: To make the math computable, they break the associahedron into simpler "simplices" (triangulation) and use Schwinger parameters to describe the "length" of the string's internal segments.
  • KLT Relations for Closed Strings: For closed strings (which relate to gravity), they use the Kawai–Lewellen–Tye (KLT) relations to build the closed-string contour out of two open-string (gauge-theory-like) contours.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, this work does not use traditional datasets. Instead, it evaluates the performance of the algorithm across the kinematic space of Mandelstam invariants ($s_{ij}$). They tested their numerical implementation on randomly chosen points in this space for $n = 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, \text{ and } 9$ external strings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Poles as Prefactors: By using these specific contours, the infinite "spikes" (resonances) in string scattering aren't hidden inside a broken integral; they are pulled out as explicit mathematical prefactors. This makes the result numerically stable.
  • The Geometry of Gluing: The paper provides a concrete "recipe" for how to glue different pieces of the integration contour together across the different faces of the associahedron.
  • Direct Physical Computation: This approach bypasses the need for "analytic continuation" (guessing the physical result from a safe mathematical region). You can now compute the amplitude directly at the energy level where the physics is happening.
  • Universality: The construction works for any number of external strings ($n$) and any type of string (open or closed).

Key Results

  • First High-Point Numerical Results: The authors successfully computed amplitudes for up to $n=9$ points. Previously, numerical results were largely limited to $n=4$ or $n=5$ due to the lack of known analytic formulas for higher points.
  • High-Energy Limits: They demonstrated that their numerical tool can explore the "fixed-angle high-energy limit," showing how string amplitudes decay exponentially—a hallmark of string theory that distinguishes it from point-particle theories.
  • Code Release: They provided a Mathematica notebook (LorentzianContours.nb) that implements these algorithms, allowing other researchers to perform these high-point calculations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tree-Level Only: This paper focuses on "genus-zero" surfaces, meaning strings that don't form loops (tree-level). Real-world precision requires "loop amplitudes" (higher genus).
  • Higher Loops: The authors acknowledge that extending this to one-loop or two-loop amplitudes is the "most interesting and pressing problem," but the geometry becomes significantly more complex (the integration space is no longer a simple polyhedron).
  • QFT Applications: A promising future direction is applying these compact contour techniques to standard Feynman integrals in Quantum Field Theory (QFT) to help with infrared and ultraviolet divergences.
  • Computational Cost: While $n=9$ is a breakthrough, the number of terms in the contour grows rapidly with $n$, suggesting a need for even more efficient "shift relations" or optimized algorithms for very high-point interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We engineer compact contours on the moduli spaces of genus-zero Riemann surfaces that achieve analytic continuation from Euclidean to Lorentzian worldsheets. These generalized Pochhammer contours are based on the combinatorics of associahedra and make the analytic properties of tree-level amplitudes entirely manifest for any number and type of external strings. We use them in practice to perform first numerical computations of open and closed string amplitudes directly in the physical kinematics for $n=4,5,6,7,8,9$. We provide a code that allows anyone to do such computations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{eberhardt2024lorentzian,
  author = {Lorenz Eberhardt and Sebastian Mizera},
  title = {{Lorentzian contours for tree-level string amplitudes}},
  booktitle = {SciPost},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21468/scipostphys.17.3.078},
}

Loading related content...

Figure