Locating Polyhedral Objects from Edge Point Data

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel method for accurately locating general polyhedral objects in 3D space using sparse edge point data from a light stripe sensor. By defining "edge intervals" and employing an edge interval tree search, the authors efficiently constrain possible object poses, leading to a fast and robust localization system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately identifying and determining the 3D position and orientation (six degrees of freedom) of objects is a fundamental challenge in robotics and computer vision. Traditional methods often rely on dense surface data or specific object features. This paper focuses on a more challenging scenario: locating polyhedral objects using only a few 3D data points that lie on the object's known edges. These edge points are assumed to be detected by a light stripe sensor, which provides noisy measurements. The core problem is to robustly infer the object's pose from these sparse, noisy edge points, especially when the object's edges might be parallel or nearly so, which can complicate geometric reasoning.

Methods

The paper introduces a two-pronged approach:

  1. Edge Intervals: For a given fixed distance between two points on intersecting edges, the authors define "edge intervals." These are pairs of intervals, one on each edge, that describe all possible locations of the two endpoints of a line segment of fixed length. Crucially, these intervals capture the monotonic relationship between the positions of the endpoints as the segment moves. This is achieved by solving a system of equations derived from orthogonality and distance constraints.
  2. Edge Interval Tree Search: The edge intervals are then used to build an "edge interval tree." This tree systematically propagates constraints. Starting with initial edge intervals for each detected edge point, the method iteratively refines these intervals by intersecting them with constraints derived from other edge points and the object's known geometry. This process prunes impossible configurations, significantly reducing the search space. The tree search is structured in levels, corresponding to the edge points.
  3. One-Dimensional Line Search: After the tree search narrows down the possibilities to a valid interval, a final one-dimensional line search is performed. This step is necessary because while the edge intervals ensure mutual distances are consistent, they don't guarantee that the starting and ending points of the line segments on the edges coincide precisely. This final search refines the object's pose to within a known error.

Datasets

The paper uses simulated data from a unit tetrahedron to illustrate and test the method. No real-world datasets are explicitly mentioned or used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Edge Intervals as Powerful Constraints: The concept of edge intervals elegantly captures the geometric constraints imposed by a fixed-length line segment intersecting two edges. This is a novel representation that is more informative than simple point correspondences.
  • Monotonicity is Key: The monotonic nature of edge intervals is fundamental to the efficiency of the tree search. It allows for predictable propagation of constraints.
  • Tree Search for Efficient Pruning: The edge interval tree effectively prunes the vast search space of possible object poses by systematically eliminating inconsistent configurations. This is a significant improvement over brute-force methods.
  • Robustness to Noise: The use of intervals, rather than precise points, inherently provides robustness to sensor noise. The final localization is achieved within a known error bound.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates that the edge interval calculation involves solving simple quadratic equations and takes negligible time. The edge interval tree search, even for a complex object like a tetrahedron, is highly efficient, examining only a fraction of the potential nodes due to effective pruning. The implementation on an IBM RT PC in C achieved a few seconds of execution time, including the line search for two valid intervals. This suggests the method is practical for real-time applications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sensor Error Impact: The paper notes that significant sensor errors can lead to missed localizations, requiring an increase in the initial intervals to maintain robustness.
  • Degenerate Cases: While the method handles degenerate cases (e.g., parallel edges, orthogonal edges) by solving simple quadratic equations, the paper acknowledges that if the distance d is shorter than the minimum distance between edges, edge interval calculation may fail.
  • Future Improvements: The authors suggest that substantial improvements in execution time are possible, implying further optimization of the implementation. The method's applicability to more complex objects or different sensor types could be explored.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1987locating,
  title = {{Locating Polyhedral Objects from Edge Point Data}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1987},
}
Figure