Localized Recrystallization of a Lithium-Metal Anode during Fast Stripping in High-Activity Liquid Electrolytes

Shang Zhu, Zijian Hong, Zeeshan Ahmad, Venkatasubramanian ViswanathanACS 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a phase-field model to simulate lithium metal anode behavior during charging and discharging, crucially incorporating electrolyte non-idealities. They discovered that at high stripping rates, a surprising "localized recrystallization" occurs in valleys, which helps to smooth the anode surface and improve stability, offering a new strategy for safer lithium-metal batteries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lithium-metal anodes are highly desirable for next-generation batteries due to their superior energy density and low potential. However, their practical application is severely hampered by the instability of the electrode-electrolyte interface. During repeated charging (plating) and discharging (stripping) cycles, lithium metal can form uneven structures (dendrites) and voids, leading to capacity fade, reduced efficiency, and even safety hazards like short circuits. While much research has focused on plating-induced dendrite formation, the stripping process and its impact on interfacial stability, especially under non-ideal electrolyte conditions, have been less understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by computationally investigating the complex morphological evolution during both plating and stripping, with a particular focus on the role of electrolyte non-idealities.

Methods

The researchers developed a sophisticated phase-field model to simulate the dynamic evolution of the lithium metal-electrolyte interface. This model extends previous work by incorporating thermodynamic non-idealities of electrolyte solutions, specifically the lithium-ion activity coefficient, which becomes significant at high concentrations. The core of the model is a generalized Allen-Cahn equation that describes the phase evolution (lithium metal vs. electrolyte) and couples it with Butler-Volmer kinetics for the electrochemical reactions.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Phase-Field Approach: Using an order parameter ($\xi$) to distinguish between the lithium metal ($\xi=1$) and electrolyte ($\xi=0$) phases, allowing for continuous interfaces.
  • Butler-Volmer Kinetics with Activity: The reaction rate is modeled using the Butler-Volmer equation, but crucially, it includes the lithium-ion activity ($a_{Li^+}$), which is a product of the ion concentration and its activity coefficient ($\gamma_{Li^+}$).
  • Activity Coefficient Model: They employed an empirical model for the activity coefficient that accounts for deviations from ideal behavior at higher concentrations, based on experimental data.
  • Coupled Equations: The model solves for the evolution of the order parameter, chemical potential (governing mass transport), and electric potential, ensuring mass transport and electrical neutrality.
  • Computational Framework: The simulations were performed using the open-source MOOSE framework, allowing for detailed 2D simulations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on computational modeling and uses parameters derived from existing literature and experimental measurements for electrolyte properties.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stripping Matters: The study highlights that the stripping process, not just plating, plays a critical role in determining the morphological stability of the lithium anode. Fast stripping can lead to smoother surfaces.
  • Electrolyte Non-Idealities are Crucial: At high lithium-ion concentrations (which can occur during stripping or in concentrated electrolytes), the assumption of ideal solutions breaks down. The activity coefficient significantly influences the reaction kinetics.
  • Localized Recrystallization: The most striking finding is the observation of "localized recrystallization" in the valleys of the anode surface during fast stripping. This phenomenon involves the formation of a new phase in regions previously occupied by the electrolyte.
  • Mechanism of Recrystallization: This recrystallization is driven by a combination of high local lithium-ion concentration and a significantly elevated activity coefficient in the valleys. This effectively reverses the local reaction direction from stripping to plating, smoothing out the surface.
  • Potential for Stability: This localized recrystallization acts as a self-healing mechanism, mitigating reaction rate heterogeneity and promoting a more uniform anode morphology, which is key to preventing dendrite growth.
  • Activity Modulation: The paper demonstrates that by controlling electrolyte chemistry and compositions, one can modulate lithium-ion activity and thus tune electrodeposition patterns.

Key Results

  • Simulations show that fast stripping (higher overpotential) leads to a smoother anode surface (lower roughness factor) compared to slow stripping.
  • During fast stripping, localized recrystallization is observed in the valleys of the anode surface.
  • This recrystallization is linked to high local lithium-ion concentrations (up to 2.8 M) and significantly elevated activity coefficients (up to ~30) in these valley regions.
  • The localized recrystallization effectively mitigates the stripping rate in valleys, promoting a more uniform interface.
  • A simplified phase diagram for overpotential-dependent recrystallization is presented, indicating that recrystallization begins around 0.115 V stripping overpotential.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Empirical Activity Model: The activity coefficient model used is empirical. A deeper understanding of the microscopic origins of these high activity coefficients is needed.
  • Molecular Simulations: The authors suggest that future work should involve molecular simulations to better understand the microscopic origins of high activity coefficients.
  • Full Recrystallization: While localized recrystallization is beneficial, the paper notes that "full recrystallization" (occurring across the entire surface) might not be desirable as it could introduce additional kinetic barriers.
  • Experimental Validation: While the results are consistent with experimental observations, direct experimental validation of the localized recrystallization phenomenon would strengthen the findings.
  • Electrolyte Systems: The study focuses on a specific electrolyte system (LiPF6 in EC/DMC). Further investigation into other electrolyte compositions and their impact on activity and recrystallization is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The lithium-metal anode is one of the most promising candidates for "beyond-lithium-ion" batteries thanks to its high specific capacity and low negative electrochemical potential. However, the electrode-electrolyte interface instability hinders its commercialization in rechargeable batteries. During cycles of charging and discharging, the lithium-metal anode is electrochemically plated and stripped along with the morphological evolution, which determines the cycling performance. In this work, with a phase-field model, we computationally characterize the morphological evolution dynamics during the plating and stripping steps at the lithium-metal-electrolyte interface. Our model is valid in a wide range of lithium concentrations in liquid electrolytes by incorporating nonidealities of electrolyte solutions into the interfacial reaction kinetics. Intriguingly, at fast stripping, i.e., high discharging overpotential, we observe an unexpected localized recrystallization phenomenon in high-lithium-ion-concentration valley regions. This recrystallization phenomenon mitigates the overall reaction rate heterogeneity and provides a potential approach to improving the morphological stability. Furthermore, we systematically investigate the correlation between the recrystallization phenomenon and lithium-ion activity and draw a simplified phase diagram for the overpotential-dependent recrystallization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2023localized,
  author = {Shang Zhu and Zijian Hong and Zeeshan Ahmad and Venkatasubramanian Viswanathan},
  title = {{Localized Recrystallization of a Lithium-Metal Anode during Fast Stripping in High-Activity Liquid Electrolytes}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/acsami.2c17379},
}
Figure