Localization for MCMC: sampling high-dimensional posterior distributions with local structure

Matthias Morzfeld, Xin T. Tong, Youssef M. Marzouk

TL;DR

This paper introduces "localization" as a technique to make Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling more efficient for high-dimensional Bayesian inverse problems. By exploiting the "local structure" of these problems, they develop MCMC samplers that exhibit dimension-independent convergence rates, a significant improvement over traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solving Bayesian inverse problems often involves inferring unknown parameters (represented by a high-dimensional vector $x$) from noisy observations ($y$). This inference is typically framed as finding the posterior distribution $p(x|y) \propto p(y|x)p(x)$, where $p(y|x)$ is the likelihood and $p(x)$ is the prior. When the dimension of $x$ is very large, sampling from this posterior distribution using MCMC becomes computationally prohibitive due to slow convergence. Traditional MCMC methods often struggle as the dimension increases, leading to longer computation times and less efficient exploration of the parameter space. This paper addresses this challenge by proposing a method to adapt MCMC for problems where statistical interactions (correlations and dependencies) are localized, meaning they primarily affect nearby components of $x$ or are influenced by nearby observations.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in the concept of localization. This involves two main strategies:

  1. Localizing Prior Covariance/Precision Matrices: For Gaussian priors $p(x) = N(m, C)$ or $p(x) = N(m, \Omega^{-1})$, localization means setting small off-diagonal elements of the covariance matrix $C$ or precision matrix $\Omega$ to zero. This results in a banded matrix, effectively restricting statistical interactions to a neighborhood.
  2. Localizing Observation Matrix: Similarly, the observation matrix $H$ (relating $x$ to $y$) is localized by assuming that each observation $y_j$ primarily depends on a few components of $x$. This means setting small off-diagonal elements of $H$ to zero, creating a banded observation matrix.

These localized matrices then define a "localized problem." The paper then shows how to efficiently sample from the posterior of this localized problem using MCMC. Key algorithms discussed include:

  • Gibbs Sampler: A natural choice for localized Gaussian problems, where sampling is done block-wise. The paper proves dimension-independent convergence rates for Gibbs samplers when the precision or covariance matrices are banded.
  • Metropolis-within-Gibbs (MwG) Sampler: A more general sampler that can handle nonlinear problems. The authors propose a "localized MwG" (l-MwG) sampler that leverages localization for both the prior and the likelihood.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses synthetic examples to illustrate its methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Localization as a Bridge: Localization acts as a bridge between the complexity of high-dimensional inverse problems and the efficiency of MCMC algorithms. It transforms problems that might be intractable into more manageable ones.
  • Dimension Independence is Achievable: The paper demonstrates that for problems with local structure, MCMC samplers (like Gibbs) can achieve convergence rates that are independent of the problem's dimension. This is a crucial insight, as traditional MCMC often suffers from dimension-dependent slowdowns.
  • A Different Kind of High-Dimensionality: The paper distinguishes its notion of "high dimensionality" from the typical function-space MCMC context. Here, high dimensionality arises from a large domain and a large number of observations, rather than necessarily a small effective dimension or low-rank updates.
  • Local Structure is Key: The effectiveness of localization hinges on the assumption that statistical interactions and observation dependencies are indeed local. When this holds, even complex problems can be tackled efficiently.
  • Trade-off Between Accuracy and Efficiency: Localization introduces small errors by approximating the original problem. However, these errors are controllable and can be made arbitrarily small by adjusting localization thresholds, offering a tunable trade-off between computational efficiency and accuracy.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantees for Linear Problems: For linear-Gaussian inverse problems, the authors prove that localization introduces small errors in the posterior mean and covariance, and that Gibbs samplers applied to localized problems have dimension-independent convergence rates.
  • Empirical Success in Nonlinear Problems: The paper presents numerical examples (image deblurring, Lorenz '96 model) demonstrating that the l-MwG sampler can efficiently sample from non-Gaussian posteriors and achieve dimension-independent integrated auto-correlation times (IACTs), outperforming other standard MCMC methods like RWM, pCN, MALA, and Hamiltonian MCMC.
  • Example 1 (Gaussian Prior): IACT for RWM, pCN, MALA, and Hamiltonian MCMC increased with domain length (dimension), while the l-MwG samplers showed constant IACT.
  • Example 3 (Banded Covariance, Full Precision): When the condition number of the covariance matrix was large, the precision matrix became full, and the l-MwG sampler's performance degraded, highlighting the importance of the "moderate condition number" assumption for dimension independence.
  • Example 4 (Image Deblurring): A Gibbs sampler on a localized problem showed constant IACT as image size (dimension) increased, demonstrating efficiency for large-scale problems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rigorous Definition for Non-Gaussian Problems: The paper acknowledges that a rigorous definition of localization for non-Gaussian problems is still needed, as simply enforcing bandedness of covariance matrices might not be sufficient due to the importance of higher moments.
  • Tuning Localization: Localization may require tuning of thresholds, which can be computationally expensive.
  • More Sophisticated Samplers: The l-MwG sampler is presented as a first example. Future work could involve combining localization with more advanced MCMC strategies like "likelihood-informed proposals," matrix splittings, or multigrid methods for even greater efficiency.
  • General Sparsity Patterns: The current work focuses on banded matrices. Future research could explore adapting these ideas to matrices with more general sparsity patterns.
  • Practical Challenges: The paper mentions that practical MCMC samplers will require more sophisticated proposal distributions and localization techniques than the basic l-MwG presented.

Summary updated

Abstract

Highlights•We explain how to use localization for the numerical solution of Bayesian inverse problems by Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC).•We prove dimension independence of MCMC samplers under simplifying assumptions.•The notion of high-dimension we discuss is different from what is usually assumed in function space MCMC.
BibTeX
@article{morzfeld2019localization,
  author = {Matthias Morzfeld and Xin T. Tong and Youssef M. Marzouk},
  title = {{Localization for MCMC: sampling high-dimensional posterior distributions with local structure}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jcp.2018.12.008},
}
Figure