Abstract
User interaction with legal contracts has been limited to document reading, which is often complicated by complex, ambiguous legal language. We explore possible futures where contract interfaces go beyond single document interfaces to (1) educate users with legal rights not stated in the contract, (2) transform legal language into alternative representations to aid information tasks before, during, and after signing, and (3) proactively supply contractual information at relevant moments. We refer to these future interfaces collectively as Living Contracts. Using residential leases as a case study, we created three design probes representing different possible Living Contracts. A three-part qualitative study (N=18) revealed participants' barriers to interacting with contracts, including interpreting complex language, uncertainty about legal rights, and the pressure to sign quickly. Participants' feedback on the probes highlighted how Living Contracts have the potential to address these challenges and open new design opportunities for human-contract interactions beyond document reading.
Introduction
Most consumer legal contracts, such as residential leases or Terms of Service, are treated as static "fine print" documents—dense walls of legalese that users often scroll past to click "I Agree." This document-centric approach creates significant information asymmetry and situational barriers. Users frequently lack the legal expertise to parse complex jargon and feel immense pressure to sign quickly without fully understanding their obligations or rights. This research introduces Living Contracts, a paradigm shift that moves legal agreements from static documents to interactive, proactive interfaces designed to empower consumers throughout the entire agreement lifecycle.
Design Framework: The Living Contract Probes
To explore the potential of Living Contracts, we developed three design probes centered on residential leasing. These probes map to three core design concepts: Contextualization (DC1), Representation (DC2), and Proactivity & Awareness (DC3).
- LeaseCompare (Pre-signing): A tool allowing users to rank and filter apartment listings based on specific contract clauses (e.g., pet policies, dispute resolution) rather than just price, foregrounding contractual terms early in the decision-making process.
- LeaseRead (While signing): An augmented interface that contextualizes clauses with legal information cards, transforms text into comic scenarios to visualize consequences, and provides interactive calculators for financial terms.
- LeaseTrack (After signing): A post-signing tool featuring an "Obligation Tracker" timeline and "Contract-Aware Devices"—fictional IoT devices that proactively remind users of lease terms, such as quiet hours.
User Evaluation and Key Insights
A qualitative study with 18 participants (tenants, landlords, and legal professionals) revealed how these interactive representations address traditional barriers to contract comprehension.
Contracts as Relationship Signals
Participants did not view clauses merely as legal rules; they saw them as markers of a landlord's "personality." A "tenant-friendly" clause signaled a trustworthy future relationship. Notably, 16 out of 18 participants expressed a preference for higher-rent apartments if the contract felt more balanced and transparent.
Malleable Representations and Empowerment
Transforming static text into "what-if" simulations (Explorable Scenarios) provided significant clarity. Participants found interactive calculators far more effective than reading paragraphs about interest rates or late fees. Furthermore, contextualizing clauses with "Information Cards" for illegal terms (based on local ordinances) provided the confidence necessary to negotiate—a task participants previously felt too intimidated to perform.
Proactivity vs. Privacy
While proactive reminders were generally welcomed, "Contract-Aware" IoT devices were polarizing. Some saw them as helpful assistants, while others perceived them as an intrusive "enforcer" for the landlord within their private living space, highlighting a critical tension between utility and privacy.
Conclusion and Future Work
Living Contracts demonstrate the potential to reduce cognitive load and empower users through transparency. However, several challenges remain. The reliability of Large Language Models (LLMs) for high-stakes legal interpretation must be addressed to avoid "hallucinations." Additionally, market realities—such as housing shortages—may limit the impact of better interfaces if tenants have no choice but to sign predatory agreements. Future research should explore the extensibility of these concepts to other domains like medical insurance and student loans while ensuring robust privacy protections for proactive systems.
Summary updated