Lithium tantalate electro-optical photonic integrated circuits for high volume manufacturing

Chengli Wang, Zihan Li, Johann Riemensberger, Grigory Lihachev, Mikhail Churaev, Wil Kao, Xinru Ji, Terence Blésin, Alisa Davydova, Yang Chen, Xi Wang, Kai Huang, Xin Ou, Tobias J. Kippenberg

Abstract: Photonic integrated circuits based on Lithium Niobate have demonstrated the vast capabilities afforded by material with a high Pockels coefficient, allowing linear and high-speed modulators operating at CMOS voltage levels for applications ranging from data-center communications and photonic accelerators for AI. However, despite major progress, the industrial adoption of this technology is compounded by the high cost per wafer. Here we overcome this challenge and demonstrate a photonic platform that satisfies the dichotomy of allowing scalable manufacturing at low cost, while at the same time exhibiting equal, and superior properties to those of Lithium Niobate. We demonstrate that it is possible to manufacture low loss photonic integrated circuits using Lithium Tantalate, a material that is already commercially adopted for acoustic filters in 5G and 6G. We show that LiTaO3 possesses equally attractive optical properties and can be etched with high precision and negligible residues using DUV lithography, diamond like carbon (DLC) as a hard mask and alkaline wet etching. Using this approach we demonstrate microresonators with an intrinsic cavity linewidth of 26.8 MHz, corresponding to a linear loss of 5.6 dB/m and demonstrate a Mach Zehnder modulator with Vpi L = 4.2 V cm half-wave voltage length product. In comparison to Lithium Niobate, the photonic integrated circuits based on LiTaO3 exhibit a much lower birefringence, allowing high-density circuits and broadband operation over all telecommunication bands (O to L band), exhibit higher photorefractive damage threshold, and lower microwave loss tangent. Moreover, we show that the platform supports generation of soliton microcombs in X-Cut LiTaO3 racetrack microresonator with electronically detectable repetition rate, i.e. 30.1 GHz.

Introduction

Lithium Niobate (LiNbO3) has long been the "gold standard" for electro-optic modulators due to its strong Pockels effect, enabling high-speed data encoding at low voltages. However, despite the recent success of thin-film Lithium Niobate on Insulator (LNOI), the technology faces a major commercial hurdle: cost. Unlike silicon, Lithium Niobate lacks a high-volume consumer application to drive down wafer costs and increase manufacturing scale.

This paper proposes a "sister" material, Lithium Tantalate (LiTaO3), as the solution. LiTaO3 is already manufactured by the millions for surface acoustic wave (SAW) filters in 5G/6G technology. This work demonstrates that this commercially mature material can match or exceed the optical performance of Lithium Niobate while being fully compatible with high-volume foundry manufacturing.

Fabrication and Methods

The researchers developed a complete wafer-scale fabrication process for Lithium Tantalate on Insulator (LTOI):

  1. Wafer Production: The "Smart-cut" ion-slicing technique (hydrogen ion implantation and bonding) was used to create high-quality thin films of LiTaO3 on silicon carrier wafers.
  2. Etching Strategy: To overcome the difficulty of etching ferroelectric crystals, the team employed a Diamond-Like Carbon (DLC) hard mask. This was combined with Argon ion beam etching (IBE) and a novel alkaline wet etching step to remove redeposition residues on the waveguide sidewalls—a critical step for reducing optical loss.
  3. Scalable Lithography: Unlike many academic proofs-of-concept, this work utilized Deep UV (DUV) stepper lithography, the standard for industrial semiconductor manufacturing.
Comprehensive overview of the LiTaO3 platform, showing crystal structure (a), fabricated waveguides (b-d), the DLC-based etching process (e-f), and wafer-scale uniformity (g-j).

Key Insights and Advantages

  • The "Acoustic" Advantage: The study demonstrates that even "acoustic grade" LiTaO3—the cheaper version used for 5G filters—can be processed into high-performance PICs, though "optical grade" material yields the best results.
  • Birefringence Breakthrough: LiTaO3 has an order of magnitude lower birefringence than Lithium Niobate. This reduces unwanted "mode mixing" in tight waveguide bends, allowing for much denser circuit layouts and broadband operation across all telecommunication bands (O to L band).
  • Power Handling and Microwave Loss: LiTaO3 exhibits a higher photorefractive damage threshold, meaning it can handle higher optical power levels before material properties drift. Additionally, the material has a lower microwave loss tangent, promising for next-generation ultra-high-speed (100 GHz+) modulators.

Key Results

  • Ultra-Low Loss: The team achieved an intrinsic cavity linewidth of 26.8 MHz, corresponding to a propagation loss of only 5.6 dB/m, among the lowest reported for ferroelectric thin films.
  • Efficient Modulation: They demonstrated a Mach-Zehnder Modulator (MZM) with a half-wave voltage-length product ($V_\pi L$) of 4.2 V·cm, proving compatibility with CMOS voltage levels.
  • Soliton Microcombs: For the first time in an X-cut ferroelectric thin film, the researchers generated stable dissipative Kerr solitons (optical frequency combs) with repetition rates of 30.1 GHz and 81 GHz.

Conclusion

LiTaO3 represents a viable, scalable path for the next generation of photonic integrated circuits. By leveraging existing industrial infrastructure, this platform bridges the gap between high-performance ferroelectric materials and high-volume semiconductor manufacturing, offering a low-cost alternative to Lithium Niobate without sacrificing performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Photonic integrated circuits based on Lithium Niobate have demonstrated the vast capabilities afforded by material with a high Pockels coefficient, allowing linear and high-speed modulators operating at CMOS voltage levels for applications ranging from data-center communications and photonic accelerators for AI. However despite major progress, the industrial adoption of this technology is compounded by the high cost per wafer. Here we overcome this challenge and demonstrate a photonic platform that satisfies the dichotomy of allowing scalable manufacturing at low cost, while at the same time exhibiting equal, and superior properties to those of Lithium Niobate. We demonstrate that it is possible to manufacture low loss photonic integrated circuits using Lithium Tantalate, a material that is already commercially adopted for acoustic filters in 5G and 6G. We show that LiTaO3 posses equally attractive optical properties and can be etched with high precision and negligible residues using DUV lithography, diamond like carbon (DLC) as a hard mask and alkaline wet etching. Using this approach we demonstrate microresonators with an intrinsic cavity linewidth of 26.8 MHz, corresponding to a linear loss of 5.6 dB/m and demonstrate a Mach Zehnder modulator with Vpi L = 4.2 V cm half-wave voltage length product. In comparison to Lithium Niobate, the photonic integrated circuits based on LiTaO3 exhibit a much lower birefringence, allowing high-density circuits and broadband operation over all telecommunication bands (O to L band), exhibit higher photorefractive damage threshold, and lower microwave loss tangent. Moreover, we show that the platform supports generation of soliton microcombs in X-Cut LiTaO3 racetrack microresonator with electronically detectable repetition rate, i.e. 30.1 GHz.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024lithium,
  author = {Chengli Wang and Zihan Li and Johann Riemensberger and Grigory Lihachev and Mikhail Churaev and Wil Kao and Xinru Ji and Terence Blésin and Alisa Davydova and Yang Chen and Xi Wang and Kai Huang and Xin Ou and Tobias J. Kippenberg},
  title = {{Lithium tantalate electro-optical photonic integrated circuits for high volume manufacturing}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41586-024-07369-1},
}
Figure