Linear ordinary differential equations constrained Gaussian Processes for solving optimal control problems

Andreas Besginow, Markus Lange‐Hegermann, Jörn Tebbe

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for solving optimal control problems for systems described by linear ordinary differential equations (ODEs). By combining computer algebra with Gaussian Processes (GPs), they constrain the GP to only generate solutions that adhere to the system's ODEs, effectively turning optimal control into a GP inference problem. This approach offers a principled way to incorporate system dynamics and constraints into machine learning-based control design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional optimal control methods often struggle with incorporating system dynamics directly, especially when dealing with noisy data or complex constraints. Algebraic system theory provides a rigorous framework for describing system behavior but often lacks the ability to handle data or uncertainty. On the other hand, machine learning techniques like Gaussian Processes are excellent at learning from data and quantifying uncertainty but typically don't inherently respect the underlying physical laws governing a system. This paper bridges this gap by proposing a method that leverages computer algebra to enforce the ODE constraints on a GP, allowing for data-driven optimal control that is grounded in the system's physics.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in the concept of Linear Ordinary Differential Equation Gaussian Processes (LODE-GPs). This approach starts by representing the linear ODE system using algebraic tools, specifically the Smith Normal Form (SNF) of the system's presentation matrix. This algebraic representation is then used to construct a prior GP that is inherently constrained to produce functions satisfying the system's ODEs.

The key steps are:

  1. Algebraic System Representation: The linear ODE system is characterized by its presentation matrix, which is then decomposed using the Smith Normal Form.
  2. LODE-GP Construction: Based on the SNF, a prior GP is constructed using specific basis functions and covariance kernels. This prior is designed such that any function sampled from it will satisfy the system's homogeneous ODEs.
  3. Control as Inference: Optimal control problems, which typically involve minimizing a cost function subject to system dynamics and point constraints, are reframed as a GP inference problem. The point constraints are incorporated by conditioning the LODE-GP on specific data points.
  4. Optimality via RKHS: The paper connects the optimality of the control solution to the properties of Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHSs). It's shown that the posterior mean of the LODE-GP, when conditioned on the problem's constraints, minimizes the RKHS norm, thereby solving the optimal control problem.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention or use pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it focuses on demonstrating the method's practicability through numerical examples of a "minimal system" (a single-state system) and a "three tank system." These examples are designed to showcase the LODE-GP's ability to handle optimal control tasks with specific initial and final conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Control as Inference": The paper elegantly reframes optimal control as a probabilistic inference problem. By conditioning a constrained GP on the desired control objectives (point constraints), the GP's posterior mean directly provides the optimal control trajectory.
  • Algebraic Constraints for GPs: The core innovation is using computer algebra (specifically Smith Normal Form) to imbue GPs with strong inductive biases that enforce the underlying differential equations of the system. This ensures that the learned control functions are physically plausible.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The work successfully connects abstract algebraic concepts (like Smith Normal Form) with modern machine learning techniques (Gaussian Processes) and classical control theory (optimal control, RKHS).
  • Principled Uncertainty Handling: While the focus is on the posterior mean for control, the framework inherently provides uncertainty quantification through the posterior covariance, which can be valuable for safety analysis.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the efficacy of the LODE-GP approach through two examples:

  • Minimal System: For a single-state system, the method successfully finds an optimal control trajectory that steers the system from an initial state to the origin, satisfying point constraints. The paper shows how hyperparameter tuning (lengthscale and signal variance) influences the control behavior.
  • Three Tank System: A more complex example involving a linearly dependent system (one uncontrollable part) is also solved. The LODE-GP is shown to handle this by modeling the uncontrollable part with a normal distribution, which is trained to have near-zero variance when the control problem is admissible.

The paper highlights that the LODE-GP posterior mean provides an optimal control solution in the RKHS sense, minimizing the norm while satisfying the ODEs and point constraints.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linear Systems: The current framework is explicitly designed for linear ODEs. Extending it to nonlinear systems would be a significant future direction.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: While the paper demonstrates hyperparameter optimization using Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE), it notes that it might be debatable to train all hyperparameters based solely on setpoints. Future work could explore more robust hyperparameter learning strategies, potentially incorporating domain knowledge or historical data more deeply.
  • Uncontrollable Parts: For systems with uncontrollable components, the paper models them with a Gaussian distribution. Further research could explore more sophisticated ways to handle these parts, perhaps by learning their dynamics from data rather than assuming a simple distribution.
  • Safety Guarantees: The paper mentions that the framework can support safety guarantees (Tebbe et al., 2024) and open-loop stability proofs (Tebbe et al., 2025), suggesting that exploring these aspects more deeply is a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents an intrinsic approach for addressing control problems with systems governed by linear ordinary differential equations (ODEs). We use computer algebra to constrain a Gaussian Process on solutions of ODEs. We obtain control functions via conditioning on datapoints. Our approach thereby connects Algebra, Functional Analysis, Machine Learning and Control theory. We discuss the optimality of the control functions generated by the posterior mean of the Gaussian Process. We present numerical examples which underline the practicability of our approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{besginow2025linear,
  author = {Andreas Besginow and Markus Lange‐Hegermann and Jörn Tebbe},
  title = {{Linear ordinary differential equations constrained Gaussian Processes for solving optimal control problems}},
  booktitle = {IFAC-PapersOnLine},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ifacol.2025.09.572},
}
Figure