Licensed-Assisted Access to Unlicensed Spectrum in LTE Release 13

Hwanjoon Kwon, Jeongho Jeon, Abhijeet Bhorkar, Qiaoyang Ye, Hiroki Harada, Yu Jiang, Liu Liu, Satoshi Nagata, Boon Loong Ng, Thomas Novlan, Jinyoung Oh, Yi Wang

TL;DR

This paper introduces Licensed-Assisted Access (LAA), a 3GPP Release 13 enhancement allowing LTE to utilize unlicensed 5 GHz spectrum. LAA aims to boost network capacity by sharing this spectrum with Wi-Fi, employing a Listen-Before-Talk (LBT) mechanism to ensure fair coexistence and minimize interference.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ever-increasing demand for mobile data traffic is straining available licensed spectrum. While Wi-Fi has successfully utilized the unlicensed 5 GHz band, mobile operators have historically been limited to their allocated licensed bands. This paper addresses the challenge of how to effectively and harmoniously integrate LTE into the crowded 5 GHz unlicensed spectrum, which is already heavily used by Wi-Fi and other systems, without causing undue interference. The core problem is achieving increased capacity for LTE while ensuring fair sharing and coexistence with existing Wi-Fi networks.

Methods

The paper details the technical enhancements introduced in 3GPP Release 13 for LAA. The central mechanism is Licensed-Assisted Access (LAA), which uses a licensed LTE carrier as a primary cell (PCell) to anchor the connection and an unlicensed carrier as a secondary cell (SCell) for additional bandwidth.

Key technical aspects include:

  • Listen-Before-Talk (LBT): This is the cornerstone of LAA's coexistence strategy. Similar to Wi-Fi's CSMA/CA, LAA devices must sense the channel before transmitting. If the channel is idle, they can transmit. This involves:
  • Clear Channel Assessment (CCA): Using energy detection (ED) to determine if the channel is busy.
  • Contention Window (CW) Adaptation: A random backoff mechanism is employed, with the window size adapting based on HARQ-ACK feedback (ACK, NACK, DTX) to manage contention and improve fairness.
  • Priority Classes: LAA defines priority classes for LBT, allowing for differentiated access.
  • Frame Structure and Partial Subframe: LAA introduces flexibility by allowing transmissions to start and end at any time, not necessarily at subframe boundaries. This includes the use of partial subframes to maximize resource utilization.
  • Discovery Reference Signal (DRS): Used for efficient cell discovery and measurement, also subject to LBT.
  • RRM Measurement Enhancements: LAA UEs report average RSSI and channel occupancy to better reflect the dynamic unlicensed spectrum conditions.
  • CSI Measurement and Reporting: Adaptations are made for CSI feedback in the unlicensed band.
  • Scheduling and HARQ: Asynchronous HARQ is adopted due to the unpredictable nature of unlicensed spectrum access.
  • Multicarrier LBT: Solutions are proposed for performing LBT across multiple unlicensed carriers.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation results are based on simulations and contributions from 3GPP participants, referencing specific 3GPP contribution numbers (e.g., R1-150694).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LBT is Crucial for Fair Coexistence: The paper strongly emphasizes that LBT, a mechanism borrowed and adapted from Wi-Fi, is the key enabler for LAA to coexist fairly with incumbent Wi-Fi networks. Without it, LAA could significantly degrade Wi-Fi performance.
  • LTE's Spectral Efficiency Advantage: LTE's ability to leverage explicit CSI feedback and better link adaptation allows it to achieve higher spectral efficiency than Wi-Fi, potentially improving overall network performance even when sharing spectrum.
  • Licensed Carrier as an Enabler: Using a licensed carrier as an anchor (PCell) for LAA (SCell) provides a more robust and manageable framework, allowing LTE to alleviate some traffic load from the unlicensed band and thus create a more friendly coexistence environment.
  • Indoor Coexistence is More Challenging: The paper notes that achieving fair coexistence in indoor scenarios is more difficult than in outdoor scenarios due to the closer proximity of LAA eNBs and Wi-Fi APs.
  • LAA Can Improve Wi-Fi Performance: Counterintuitively, in some scenarios, Wi-Fi performance (UPT) can actually improve when coexisting with LAA compared to coexisting with another Wi-Fi network. This is attributed to LTE's efficiency and reduced interference from the LAA operator.

Key Results

  • Improved Wi-Fi UPT: Figure 4 shows that in DL-only Wi-Fi networks, User Perceived Throughput (UPT) for Wi-Fi can improve by up to 120% when coexisting with LAA compared to coexisting with another Wi-Fi network, across various load conditions.
  • Reduced VoIP Outage: Figure 5 demonstrates that VoIP outage percentage for Wi-Fi networks serving both DL and UL traffic can be significantly reduced (up to 80%) when coexisting with LAA, compared to coexisting with another Wi-Fi network.
  • Fair Coexistence Achieved: The evaluation results from 3GPP simulations indicate that LAA, with its LBT mechanism, can indeed ensure fair coexistence with incumbent Wi-Fi networks for both non-real-time and real-time traffic.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Indoor Scenario Complexity: The paper acknowledges that indoor coexistence is more challenging and requires careful design to ensure fairness.
  • LTE-U Details: While comparing LAA to LTE-U, the paper notes that technical details on LTE-U are less available due to its proprietary nature.
  • Future Work: The paper focuses on Release 13 LAA. Future work would likely involve further refinements of the LBT algorithm, enhancements for UL operation in unlicensed spectrum, and broader deployment scenarios. The paper concludes that LAA can fairly coexist with Wi-Fi, implying that the current design is robust, but ongoing monitoring and potential adjustments might be necessary as deployments evolve.

Summary updated

Abstract

Exploiting the unlicensed spectrum is considered by 3GPP as one promising solution to meet ever-increasing traffic growth. As a result, one major enhancement for LTE in Release 13 has been to enable its operation in the unlicensed spectrum via licensed-assisted access (LAA). In this article, we provide an overview of the Release 13 LAA technology including motivation, use cases, LTE enhancements for enabling the unlicensed band operation, and the coexistence evaluation results contributed by 3GPP participants.
BibTeX
@article{kwon2016licensed,
  author = {Hwanjoon Kwon and Jeongho Jeon and Abhijeet Bhorkar and Qiaoyang Ye and Hiroki Harada and Yu Jiang and Liu Liu and Satoshi Nagata and Boon Loong Ng and Thomas Novlan and Jinyoung Oh and Yi Wang},
  title = {{Licensed-Assisted Access to Unlicensed Spectrum in LTE Release 13}},
  journal = {IEEE Communications Magazine},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1109/mcom.2016.1500698cm},
}

Loading related content...

Figure