Lexicographic Optimization: Algorithms and Stability

Jacob Abernethy, Robert E. Schapire, Syed Umar

TL;DR

This paper bridges the gap between two popular ways to solve lexicographic optimization problems: iterative "progressive filling" and exponential loss minimization. The authors introduce the concept of lexicographic stability to prove when these methods converge and reveal a surprising "dichotomy" in convergence rates—where the two smallest components of a solution optimize quickly, while all others can be arbitrarily slow.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lexicographic maximization is a powerful tool for fairness. Imagine you are allocating bandwidth or resources; a "lexicographic maximum" ensures the person getting the least gets as much as possible. If there's a tie, you maximize the second-least, and so on. It’s the ultimate "no one left behind" strategy.

Researchers typically find these solutions using one of two ways:

  1. Iterative Algorithms: Solving a sequence of $n$ optimization problems (one for each component).
  2. Exponential Loss Minimization: Minimizing a single function $L_c(\mathbf{x}) = \sum \exp(-cx_i)$ and letting $c$ go to infinity.

The problem? We didn't really know if these two methods were fundamentally connected, nor did we have a good grasp of when the loss minimization method actually works for general shapes. Furthermore, there were no established "speed limits" (convergence rates) for how fast these components reach their optimal values as $c$ increases.

Methods

The authors employ a mix of mathematical analysis and algorithmic theory:

  • Stability Analysis: They define "lexicographic stability"—a property where an iterative algorithm doesn't fail if you allow for tiny epsilon-errors in each step.
  • Geometric Proofs: They prove that all convex polytopes (shapes with flat sides, like cubes or pyramids) are stable, but they also construct a clever counterexample of a curved compact convex set that is not stable.
  • Convergence Rate Analysis: They provide the first formal bounds on how quickly the components of a near-minimizer of the exponential loss approach the true lexicographic maximum.
  • Algorithmic "Rehabilitation": They show that the famous Multiplicative Weights (MW) algorithm, which was previously thought to diverge in this context, can be "fixed" to find the lexicographic maximum by using a specific $1/t$ learning rate schedule.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical work in mathematical optimization, the authors rely on rigorous proofs and constructed mathematical examples (like specific sets in $\mathbb{R}^3$ or $\mathbb{R}^n$) rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Stability Link: The paper’s "aha moment" is showing that the success of exponential loss minimization is tied directly to the stability of the iterative method. If a set is stable, the loss minimizer is guaranteed to find the fair (lexicographic) solution.
  • The Two-Component Dichotomy: There is a bizarre split in performance. The smallest and second-smallest components of your vector are "fast learners"—they converge at a rate of roughly $\frac{\log n}{c}$. However, from the third component onwards, convergence can be "arbitrarily slow," even for a simple line segment.
  • Curvature Causes Trouble: While flat-sided shapes (polytopes) are always stable, sets with curved boundaries can be "unstable." In these cases, even an exact minimizer of the exponential loss might stay far away from the fair solution forever.
  • MW as Frank-Wolfe: The authors reframe the Multiplicative Weights algorithm as a version of the Frank-Wolfe optimization algorithm. This perspective allows them to prove that MW can indeed solve lexicographic problems if tuned correctly.

Key Results

  • General Convergence: Proved that for any stable set, the minimizer of the exponential loss converges to the lexicographic maximum as $c \to \infty$.
  • Polytopes are Safe: Established that convex polytopes are always lexicographically stable, subsuming many previous specific results.
  • Quantitative Rates: Showed that for the first two components, the error is at most $O(\frac{\log n}{c})$.
  • Negative Result: Constructed a specific convex set in $\mathbb{R}^3$ where the third component of the exponential loss minimizer is bounded away from the optimal value by at least $1/4$, no matter how large $c$ becomes.

Limitations and Future Work

The most significant limitation is the "slow convergence" of higher-order components. If you need to optimize the 3rd, 4th, or $n$th smallest components fairly, the exponential loss method might be practically useless because it takes an impractically large $c$ (and thus extreme numerical precision) to get close to the answer.

The authors suggest that future work should investigate whether there are other classes of sets (beyond polytopes) that are stable, or if there are alternative loss functions that don't suffer from this "slow component" dichotomy.

Summary updated

Abstract

A lexicographic maximum of a set $X \subseteq \mathbb{R}^n$ is a vector in $X$ whose smallest component is as large as possible, and subject to that requirement, whose second smallest component is as large as possible, and so on for the third smallest component, etc. Lexicographic maximization has numerous practical and theoretical applications, including fair resource allocation, analyzing the implicit regularization of learning algorithms, and characterizing refinements of game-theoretic equilibria. We prove that a minimizer in $X$ of the exponential loss function $L_c(\mathbf{x}) = \sum_i \exp(-c x_i)$ converges to a lexicographic maximum of $X$ as $c \rightarrow \infty$, provided that $X$ is stable in the sense that a well-known iterative method for finding a lexicographic maximum of $X$ cannot be made to fail simply by reducing the required quality of each iterate by an arbitrarily tiny degree. Our result holds for both near and exact minimizers of the exponential loss, while earlier convergence results made much stronger assumptions about the set $X$ and only held for the exact minimizer. We are aware of no previous results showing a connection between the iterative method for computing a lexicographic maximum and exponential loss minimization. We show that every convex polytope is stable, but that there exist compact, convex sets that are not stable. We also provide the first analysis of the convergence rate of an exponential loss minimizer (near or exact) and discover a curious dichotomy: While the two smallest components of the vector converge to the lexicographically maximum values very quickly (at roughly the rate $\frac{\log n}{c}$), all other components can converge arbitrarily slowly.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abernethy2024lexicographic,
  author = {Jacob Abernethy and Robert E. Schapire and Syed Umar},
  title = {{Lexicographic Optimization: Algorithms and Stability}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=mfyYIg2aFC},
}

Loading related content...

Figure