Abstract
Persuasion is a complex interaction between the speaker's style, the audience's background, and the topic at hand. While traditional NLP models focus on linguistic features, this research highlights the importance of "topic relatedness"—the latent connections between controversial issues based on user stance alignment. By mapping these relationships, the proposed model significantly improves persuasion prediction, particularly for niche topics where data is limited.
Introduction
Predicting the persuasiveness of an argument typically involves analyzing the source, the audience, and the linguistic style. However, the topic itself is often treated as an isolated variable. This paper addresses the "topic relatedness" gap, arguing that views on one issue (e.g., "Minimum Wage") are often highly correlated with views on others (e.g., "Labor Unions"). Existing models fail to generalize across these related domains, requiring them to learn persuasive strategies from scratch for every new topic.
Methodology
The researchers developed a multi-pronged framework to capture the context of debate topics and their relationships:
- Topic Embeddings: Using an Item2Vec-inspired approach, the model creates embeddings for major issues. Topics are mapped closely in a vector space if users frequently hold similar stances on them.
- Topic-Centric Attribute Embeddings (ATT-EMB): Rather than using static demographic labels, user attributes (like "Conservative") are embedded based on their statistical relationship with specific stances, capturing how identities manifest differently across issues.
- Topic Semantics: A fine-tuned BERT model encodes the literal text of the debate topic.
- Architecture: A Siamese network structure processes the relationship between arguments and topics, feeding into a multi-layer feed-forward neural network (FFNN) to predict voter outcomes.
Datasets
The study utilized the DDO (Debate.org) dataset, which includes 67,315 debates across 23 categories. This corpus provides rich metadata on over 36,000 users, including their ideologies, religions, and stances on "Big Issues." The ground truth is derived from nearly 200,000 user votes indicating which debater was more convincing.
Results
The proposed model was evaluated against several baselines, including SBERT and Bi-LSTM models.
As shown in the results, the full model achieved a Macro F1 score of 65.62%, significantly outperforming the SBERT baseline (50.05%). Ablation studies revealed that removing topic-centric user embeddings (ATT-EMB) led to the most substantial performance drop (to 51.33%), underscoring the importance of the audience-topic interaction. Furthermore, the model demonstrated strong few-shot generalization; for "rare" topics appearing fewer than 20 times, topic-related features helped maintain accuracy and halved the performance gap compared to frequent topics.
Discussion and Conclusion
The core insight of this work is that user stances serve as a powerful proxy for topic relatedness. For instance, "Environment Protection" and "Abortion" may not be linguistically similar, but they share a high similarity score (0.85) due to underlying ideological links. By leveraging these bridges, models can transfer knowledge from data-rich topics to data-poor ones.
While the model effectively identifies related topics, future research should explore why specific linguistic strategies succeed across these clusters. Investigating granular rhetorical moves and testing the model on diverse social platforms could further refine our understanding of universal vs. topic-specific persuasion templates.
Summary updated