Abstract
In-game team communication in online multiplayer games has shown the potential to foster efficient collaboration and positive social interactions. Yet players often associate communication within ad hoc teams with frustration and wariness. Though previous works have quantitatively analyzed communication patterns at scale, few have identified the motivations of how a player makes in-the-moment communication decisions. In this paper, we conducted an observation study with 22 League of Legends players by interviewing them during Solo Ranked games on their use of four in-game communication media (chat, pings, emotes, votes). We performed thematic analysis to understand players' in-context assessment and perception of communication attempts. We demonstrate that players evaluate communication opportunities on proximate game states bound by player expectations and norms. Our findings illustrate players' tendency to view communication, regardless of its content, as a precursor to team breakdowns. We build upon these findings to motivate effective player-oriented communication design in online games.
Introduction
Effective collaboration in "virtual ad hoc teams"—groups of strangers formed briefly to achieve a competitive goal—is notoriously difficult. In environments like League of Legends (LoL), players lack traditional non-verbal cues such as facial expressions or tone of voice and must coordinate under extreme time pressure. While previous research has quantitatively mapped communication patterns (e.g., identifying that toxic players tend to chat more), there is a lack of granular understanding regarding the individual decision-making process. This study explores the "in-the-moment" motivations and perceptions that drive communication choices in one of the world’s most competitive gaming environments.
Methods and Participants
The researchers conducted an in-situ observational interview study with 22 LoL players on the South Korean server. Unlike retrospective surveys, researchers observed players during live "Solo Ranked" games and asked questions during lulls in action—such as while the player was dead or walking back to lane—to capture immediate reasoning.
As shown in the participant data (Figure 3), the study included a diverse range of skill levels, from Iron to Emerald, and various primary roles. The team performed thematic analysis on transcripts from 24 game sessions and post-game interviews to identify 55 unique codes and 13 categories of communication behavior, focusing on four distinct media: text chat, pings, emotes, and votes.
Communication as a Limited Economy
A primary finding is that players treat communication as a resource with a high "action cost." Typing a message requires taking hands off the controls, which can be fatal. Consequently, information is often considered "outdated" by the time it is sent.
Players navigate multiple channels (Figure 2) with varying degrees of efficiency. Pings (B) are the dominant channel because they are low-cost and high-speed, though they are frequently misinterpreted if sent in "barrages." In contrast, objective voting (D) is often ignored because the game state changes faster than the 60-second voting window.
Key Insights: Trust and Toxicity
- The "Talkative = Toxic" Heuristic: Surprisingly, players often view frequent chatting—even positive talk—with suspicion. They associate "staying on the keyboard" with a lack of focus and fear the talkative player will turn hostile if the game goes south.
- Trust through Action: Trust in ad hoc teams is "swift" and performance-based. Players gauge a teammate's commitment by their "mental fortitude" (resilience after a mistake) and their physical presence in fights, rather than verbal encouragement.
- Performance-Based Hierarchy: There is an unwritten rule that the player performing best has the "right" to lead. Conversely, players who are losing their lane often self-silence, feeling they have lost the social standing to suggest strategies.
- Gender Camouflage: Female players reported "camouflaging" their identity by choosing gender-neutral usernames or adopting "male-like" speech patterns to preemptively avoid harassment.
Conclusion
Communication frequency often spikes at the end of a game, serving as emotional bonding in wins or emotional venting in losses. Throughout the match, however, many players explicitly use silence as a strategy to "reduce friction," fearing that even an apology might trigger a teammate's frustration. The authors suggest that future game design should focus on "persistent status" indicators that provide context without requiring the player to stop playing and type, acknowledging that in high-stakes play, less talk often leads to more trust.
Summary updated