Lemmas of Differential Privacy

Yiyang Huang, Clément L. CanonnearXiv 2022 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper aims to consolidate and provide self-contained proofs for fundamental "buried" lemmas in differential privacy (DP). By organizing these lemmas by their application (central, local, shuffle DP), the authors create a valuable resource for researchers, streamlining the process of proving DP guarantees and fostering a deeper understanding of the field.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Differential privacy is a crucial concept for protecting sensitive data while enabling useful analysis. However, the field has grown rapidly, leading to a proliferation of specialized definitions and proofs. Many essential lemmas, while critical for establishing DP guarantees, are scattered across various papers, often with proofs that are either assumed or difficult to find. This makes it challenging for researchers to quickly access and verify these foundational results, slowing down new research and potentially leading to redundant proof efforts. This paper addresses this by acting as a curated compendium of these "buried" lemmas, providing clear, self-contained proofs and categorizing them for easy reference.

Methods

The paper's primary method is to collect, present, and prove a set of fundamental lemmas related to different facets of differential privacy. These include:

  • Central Differential Privacy (CDP): Lemmas relating pure DP to approximate DP, and mechanisms for finite output spaces.
  • Local Differential Privacy (LDP): Lemmas establishing equivalences and relationships between replacement and deletion LDP, and methods for converting asymmetric LDP protocols to symmetric ones.
  • Shuffle Differential Privacy (SDP): Lemmas that explore the relationship between SDP and LDP, and how shuffling can amplify privacy.
  • Privacy Amplification by Subsampling: Lemmas that demonstrate how subsampling can be used to achieve DP guarantees.

The authors provide self-contained proofs for each lemma, often referencing existing literature for context but ensuring the proofs themselves are accessible. They also aim to present these lemmas in a way that is useful for practical applications and further theoretical development.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Consolidation of "Buried" Lemmas: The paper's core contribution is its role as a centralized repository for essential but often hard-to-find DP lemmas. This significantly lowers the barrier to entry for researchers working with DP.
  • Self-Contained Proofs: Providing complete proofs for each lemma is crucial. This not only makes the results verifiable but also helps in understanding the underlying mechanisms and assumptions.
  • Categorization by DP Model: Organizing lemmas by Central DP, Local DP, and Shuffle DP makes the compendium highly practical. Researchers can quickly find relevant lemmas for their specific DP setting.
  • Bridging DP Models: The paper highlights connections between different DP models, such as showing how replacement LDP implies deletion LDP, and how LDP can be related to shuffle DP. This fosters a more unified understanding of privacy guarantees.
  • Practical Implications: By providing these foundational results, the paper aims to streamline the development of new differentially private algorithms and analyses, making DP more accessible and applicable.

Key Results

The paper presents several key lemmas and their proofs, including:

  • Lemma 3.1: Any (ε + δ, 0)-differentially private algorithm is also (ε, δ)-differentially private.
  • Lemma 3.2: Approximate DP implies pure DP for finite output spaces, providing a conversion mechanism.
  • Lemma 4.1: Replacement LDP implies deletion LDP.
  • Lemma 4.2: Deletion LDP implies replacement LDP with adjusted parameters (2ε, (e^ε + 1)δ).
  • Theorem 5.1: Establishes a relationship between one-message shuffle DP and LDP, showing that shuffle DP implies LDP with parameters εL = εS + ln n and δL = δS.
  • Theorem 6.1: Demonstrates privacy amplification by subsampling for approximate DP, showing that subsampling a dataset with probability p can reduce the privacy loss.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope: The paper focuses on collecting and proving existing lemmas. It does not introduce new DP models or fundamentally new theoretical results, but rather serves as a foundational resource.
  • Completeness: While the paper aims to be comprehensive, the field of differential privacy is vast, and it's possible that other "buried" lemmas exist that are not covered.
  • Future Work: The authors implicitly suggest that this compendium can serve as a basis for future research by providing readily available tools for DP proofs. Further work could involve expanding this collection to include more advanced lemmas or exploring new connections between different DP paradigms. The paper also mentions that some proofs are simplified versions of existing results, implying that more complex or generalized proofs might exist.

Summary updated

Abstract

We aim to collect buried lemmas that are useful for proofs. In particular, we try to provide self-contained proofs for those lemmas and categorise them according to their usage.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2022lemmas,
  author = {Yiyang Huang and Clément L. Canonne},
  title = {{Lemmas of Differential Privacy}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2211.11189},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.11189},
}
Figure