Learning the Synthesizability of Dynamic Texture Samples

Feng Yang, Gui-Song Xia, Dengxin Dai, Liangpei Zhang

TL;DR

This paper shifts the focus of dynamic texture synthesis from "how to build a better algorithm" to "how synthesizable is this specific video sample?" By introducing a hierarchical learning framework and a novel spatiotemporal descriptor (SCOP-DT), the authors can predict how well a video can be reproduced and automatically suggest the best synthesis method for the job.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dynamic textures (DTs)—videos of phenomena like flowing water, flickering fire, or swaying trees—are notoriously difficult to synthesize. While dozens of Example-based Dynamic Texture Synthesis (EDTS) methods exist, they all have "blind spots." Some handle temporal flow well but fail at spatial patterns; others produce repetitive, "verbatim" artifacts.

The authors identify a major gap: we lack a quantitative way to measure a video's "synthesizability" before we try to process it. Currently, researchers choose synthesis algorithms through trial and error. This paper aims to automate that choice by answering two questions:

  1. How likely is it that any current method will produce a high-quality result for this video?
  2. Which specific algorithm is the "case-optimal" choice for this particular sample?

Methods

The authors propose a hierarchical pipeline to analyze videos:

  1. DT Retrieval: First, the system distinguishes "dynamic textures" from other motions like "activities" (e.g., a person playing violin) or "events" (e.g., a single lightning bolt) using a C3D descriptor and Random Forest regression.
  2. Spatial Mode Partitioning: It then classifies the DT into two categories: SHDT (Spatially Homogeneous DTs, which are stationary in both space and time, like a field of grass) and TDT (Time-stationary DTs, which only show regularity over time, like a waterfall).
  3. Synthesizability Prediction: Using a combination of features, the system predicts a score $s \in [0, 1]$. A high score means the video is "easy" to synthesize.
  4. Method Suggestion: Finally, a classifier recommends the best off-the-shelf algorithm (e.g., LDS, Graphcut Textures, or STGConvNet) for that specific video.

The SCOP-DT Descriptor: A key technical contribution is the Shape-based Co-occurrence Patterns for Dynamic Textures (SCOP-DT). It extends 2D static texture analysis to 3D by using a "Tree of Shapes" for each frame and implicitly encoding temporal consistency across frame clips. This allows the model to capture both geometric structures and motion patterns simultaneously.

Datasets

The authors compiled and annotated a substantial new dataset to train their models:

  • Source Material: 1,729 DT samples aggregated from existing benchmarks like UCLA, DynTex, and YUPENN, plus "in-the-wild" videos from the Maryland dataset.
  • Annotation: Every sample was manually scored by experts on a 3-level scale (Good, Acceptable, Bad) based on the results of six representative synthesis algorithms.
  • Negative Samples: 13,520 non-DT videos (activities and events) were used to train the initial retrieval stage.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial vs. Temporal Difficulty: The study found that spatial synthesizability is significantly harder to predict and achieve than temporal synthesizability. Most DTs have strong self-correlation over time, making temporal extension easier, but their complex 2D spatial structures are harder for algorithms to "understand" and replicate.
  • The "Textureness" Metric: By treating DT retrieval as a regression problem, the authors created a "textureness" score that quantifies how much a video behaves like a texture versus a structured activity.
  • Wisdom of the Ensemble: No single feature (C3D, LBP-TOP, or SCOP-DT) was perfect. The best results came from aggregating these features at the "decision level," allowing the strengths of deep learning (C3D) to complement handcrafted geometric descriptors (SCOP-DT).

Key Results

  • High Retrieval Accuracy: The system achieved a 96.23% average precision in identifying dynamic textures within a sea of general video content.
  • Effective Classification: Distinguishing between SHDT and TDT reached 96.06% accuracy.
  • Synthesizability Prediction: The combined model achieved high precision in retrieving "good" samples (e.g., 96.25% precision for acceptable TDTs).
  • Algorithm Recommendation: The system successfully suggested the "best" synthesis method with an accuracy of 75.76% for SHDTs and 82.39% for TDTs.
  • Practical Application: The authors demonstrated that their tool can automatically "trim" a messy, unconstrained video to find the most synthesizable rectangular sub-region, significantly improving the final synthesis quality.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subjectivity of "Good": Synthesizability scores rely on human expert annotation, which is inherently subjective. Future work could explore more objective, automated quality metrics.
  • Fixed Algorithm Library: The "method suggestion" is currently limited to the six algorithms used during training. As new synthesis methods (like GAN-based approaches) emerge, the model would need to be re-trained.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest investigating the relationship between synthesizability and other video properties, such as aesthetic quality or specific motion patterns (e.g., turbulent vs. laminar flow).

Reference: Yang, F., Xia, G. S., Dai, D., & Zhang, L. (2018). Learning the Synthesizability of Dynamic Texture Samples. arXiv:1802.00941v1 [cs.CV].

Summary updated

Abstract

Exemplar-based dynamic texture synthesis (EDTS) is targeted to generate new samples of high quality that are perceptually similar to a given input dynamic texture exemplar. This paper addresses the issue of learning the synthesizability of dynamic texture samples. Given a dynamic texture sample, how is its possibility of being synthesized by EDTS methods estimated, and what is the most suitable EDTS algorithm to complete the task? To this end, we propose associating dynamic texture samples with synthesizability scores by learning regression models on a compiled dynamic texture dataset annotated in terms of synthesizability. More precisely, we first define the synthesizability of DT samples and characterize them by a set of spatiotemporal features. We then train regression models on the annotated dataset with feature representation to predict the synthesizability scores of the DT samples and learn classifiers to select the most suitable EDTS algorithm. We further complete the selection, partition, and synthesizability prediction of the DT samples in a hierarchical scheme. The learned synthesizability is finally applied to detecting synthesizable regions in videos. Both quantitative and qualitative experiments demonstrate that our method can efficiently learn and predict the synthesizability of DT samples.
BibTeX
@article{yang2019learning,
  author = {Feng Yang and Gui-Song Xia and Dengxin Dai and Liangpei Zhang},
  title = {{Learning the Synthesizability of Dynamic Texture Samples}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Image Process.},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=vcUga6KdIH2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure