Learning Heuristic Search via Imitation

Mohak Bhardwaj, Sanjiban Choudhury, Sebastian A. Scherer

Abstract

Robotic motion planning often involves searching through vast trees of maneuvers, a process constrained by limited onboard computation. Heuristics are essential for guiding this search, yet traditional methods do not explicitly optimize for minimizing search effort. This paper introduces SaIL (Search as Imitation Learning), a framework that trains a heuristic policy to map partial search information to optimal node expansion decisions. By imitating "clairvoyant oracles"—experts with full environmental knowledge—SaIL learns to predict efficient paths. Experimental results across diverse environments demonstrate that SaIL significantly reduces search effort compared to state-of-the-art heuristics, finding feasible solutions with fewer computations.

Introduction: The Computational Bottleneck in Planning

In robotics, the primary challenge in motion planning is often not finding the shortest path, but finding any valid path within strict computational limits. For systems like agile drones or high-degree-of-freedom robotic arms, checking the validity of every potential movement against obstacles is expensive.

Standard search algorithms rely on static heuristics, such as Euclidean distance, to prioritize exploration. However, these "blind" heuristics often lead to inefficiencies. For instance, a greedy heuristic might drive a robot directly into a U-shaped "bug trap," forcing the algorithm to expand thousands of unnecessary nodes before backtracking. The goal of this research is to develop a heuristic that learns from the environment's structure to minimize this search effort.

Methodology: Search as Imitation Learning (SaIL)

The authors frame the search process as a sequential decision-making problem, specifically a Markov Decision Process (MDP). At each step, the state is defined by the currently explored map, and the action is the selection of the next node to expand from the "Open List."

To train this policy efficiently, the paper introduces SaIL, which leverages Imitation Learning with Clairvoyant Oracles:

  1. The Clairvoyant Oracle: During training, the algorithm has access to the complete map. It uses dynamic programming (e.g., Dijkstra’s algorithm) to compute the perfect cost-to-go for every point. This oracle represents the "ideal" search behavior.
  2. The Learner: The learning agent only perceives the partially explored environment. It uses a neural network to approximate the Oracle's values based on features like distance to the goal, tree depth, and local obstacle density.
  3. Training via Imitation: SaIL employs an iterative training loop where the agent follows a mixture of its own policy and the Oracle's. The agent’s network is updated to minimize the discrepancy between its predictions and the Oracle's perfect values, leading to rapid convergence compared to standard reinforcement learning.

Experimental Evaluation

The SaIL framework was tested on several 2D grid environments designed to challenge search algorithms:

  • Forests: Randomly placed obstacles testing general navigation.
  • Bug Traps: U-shaped obstacles that typically lure greedy heuristics into dead ends.
  • Gaps: Walls with specific distributions of openings, requiring the agent to learn environmental "priors" (e.g., gaps are more likely at the bottom).
  • Mazes: Complex rectilinear corridors.

Key Results

SaIL consistently outperformed traditional heuristics like Euclidean and Manhattan distance, as well as established planners like A and Multi-Heuristic A (MHA*).

Comparison of standard inflated Euclidean heuristics versus the SaIL learnt heuristic policy in 'bug trap' and 'centre line' environments.

As shown in the figure above, standard heuristics often get trapped due to their inherent greediness. In contrast, the learnt policy in SaIL adapts its behavior based on the environment type. In "bug trap" worlds, it learns to search along the periphery to avoid the trap, while in worlds with paths around a center line, it adopts a more aggressive, greedy search strategy to find the goal quickly. This adaptability results in a massive reduction in search effort—often by an order of magnitude in complex scenarios.

Conclusion and Future Directions

SaIL demonstrates that heuristics can be viewed as active decision-making policies rather than static metrics. By imitating a clairvoyant oracle, the system learns to exploit environmental patterns to find paths with minimal computation.

While currently focused on feasibility, future work aims to extend SaIL to "anytime" planning, where an initial fast solution is iteratively refined toward optimality. Additionally, replacing hand-crafted features with deep representation learning (e.g., CNNs) could allow the system to learn directly from raw sensor data, further increasing its robustness in unstructured real-world environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Robotic motion planning problems are typically solved by constructing a search tree of valid maneuvers from a start to a goal configuration. Limited onboard computation and real-time planning constraints impose a limit on how large this search tree can grow. Heuristics play a crucial role in such situations by guiding the search towards potentially good directions and consequently minimizing search effort. Moreover, it must infer such directions in an efficient manner using only the information uncovered by the search up until that time. However, state of the art methods do not address the problem of computing a heuristic that explicitly minimizes search effort. In this paper, we do so by training a heuristic policy that maps the partial information from the search to decide which node of the search tree to expand. Unfortunately, naively training such policies leads to slow convergence and poor local minima. We present SaIL, an efficient algorithm that trains heuristic policies by imitating "clairvoyant oracles" - oracles that have full information about the world and demonstrate decisions that minimize search effort. We leverage the fact that such oracles can be efficiently computed using dynamic programming and derive performance guarantees for the learnt heuristic. We validate the approach on a spectrum of environments which show that SaIL consistently outperforms state of the art algorithms. Our approach paves the way forward for learning heuristics that demonstrate an anytime nature - finding feasible solutions quickly and incrementally refining it over time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bhardwaj2017learning,
  author = {Mohak Bhardwaj and Sanjiban Choudhury and Sebastian A. Scherer},
  title = {{Learning Heuristic Search via Imitation}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Robot Learning},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=FemzP2S-Yc8},
}
Figure