Learning Conceptual Space Representations of Interrelated Concepts

Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Bayesian model for learning conceptual space representations by modeling concepts as Gaussian distributions. It addresses the challenge of learning reliable concept representations when only a few instances are available, by leveraging background knowledge from description logic axioms and vector space embeddings of concept names. The proposed method significantly improves knowledge base completion tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a fundamental challenge in artificial intelligence: how to represent concepts in a way that aligns with human cognition and enables tasks like categorization and knowledge base completion. While recent methods can learn vector representations for individual objects (e.g., words or entities) in a high-dimensional space, they often fail to explicitly model the concepts themselves. Conceptual spaces, a theoretical framework, represent objects as points and concepts as regions (often modeled as Gaussians) in a metric space. However, automatically learning these concept representations from data is difficult, especially when dealing with limited instances for each concept. Traditional methods like fitting Gaussians to instance data become unreliable with few data points, and existing knowledge base completion methods often treat concepts in isolation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by learning concept representations that are informed by both instance data and the relationships between concepts.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is a Bayesian model that represents each concept as a Gaussian distribution in a learned vector space. The model uses Gibbs sampling to iteratively estimate the parameters (mean and covariance) of these Gaussians. What makes this approach novel is the construction of informative priors for these parameters, which are derived from two key sources of background knowledge:

  1. Description Logic (DL) Axioms: The paper leverages DL axioms from an ontology (like SUMO) to capture logical relationships between concepts (e.g., "all train stations are terminal buildings"). These axioms are used to inform the priors, ensuring that the learned Gaussian for a concept is consistent with its known relationships to other concepts.
  2. Vector Space Embeddings: The paper utilizes existing vector space representations of concept names (obtained from models like MEmbER). The intuition here is that similar concepts should have similar vector representations, and the relationships between concept names in this embedding space can inform the priors on the concept Gaussians. For instance, analogical relationships observed in word embeddings are exploited.

The model jointly learns representations for all concepts, allowing information to propagate between them. It also introduces scaling factors ($\lambda_C$) for each concept to control the probability of an individual belonging to that concept, which are estimated by maximizing the likelihood of the training data.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted using the SUMO (Suggested Upper Merged Ontology). SUMO is a large, open-domain ontology containing concepts, roles, and individuals, with existing mappings to WordNet and Wikidata. The dataset was split into training and testing sets, and negative examples were generated to create a knowledge base completion task. No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on evaluating the proposed method on an existing ontology.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Interdependencies is Crucial: The most significant insight is that explicitly modeling the relationships between concepts (via DL axioms and embeddings) is far more effective than treating each concept in isolation, especially when instance data is scarce.
  • Bayesian Priors as Knowledge Integration: The Bayesian framework provides a natural way to incorporate background knowledge (DL axioms, embeddings) as informative priors, guiding the learning process towards more robust and meaningful concept representations.
  • Concepts as Gaussians: Representing concepts as Gaussians is a principled way to capture their "vagueness" and dispersion in a conceptual space, aligning with prototype theory. The use of ellipsoidal contours (via diagonal covariance matrices) allows for different dimensional importances.
  • Gibbs Sampling for Cyclic Dependencies: The use of Gibbs sampling is essential for handling potential cyclic dependencies that arise when concept parameters depend on each other.
  • Embeddings and Ontologies are Complementary: The paper demonstrates that combining information from both vector space embeddings of concept names and structured ontological knowledge (DL axioms) yields superior results compared to using either source alone.

Key Results

The proposed model consistently outperformed baseline methods (linear and quadratic SVMs) in knowledge base completion tasks, as measured by F1 and Average Precision (AP) scores.

  • Significant Gains for Few-Shot Learning: The method showed substantial improvements for concepts with very few known instances (e.g., 1-5 training examples).
  • Outperforms Baselines Across the Board: Even for concepts with a larger number of training examples, the proposed model achieved better performance.
  • Combined Approach is Best: The full model, which integrates both DL axioms and embeddings, performed better than variants that used only DL axioms (Gibbs-DL) or only embeddings (Gibbs-emb), and also better than a flat prior approach (Gibbs-flat). This highlights the synergistic benefit of combining these knowledge sources.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The model assumes concepts can be faithfully modeled as scaled Gaussians.
  • The estimation of covariance matrices relies on the assumption of diagonal matrices, which simplifies the problem but might lose some information.
  • The current approach focuses on modeling concepts and does not extensively model role restrictions, although it acknowledges their potential.
  • The estimation of scaling factors ($\lambda_C$) relies on a closed-world assumption, which might lead to overly cautious predictions.
  • Future Work:
    • Extending the model to handle more complex concept expressions and role restrictions.
  • Investigating alternative methods for learning concept representations beyond Gaussians.
  • Exploring more sophisticated ways to integrate information from vector space embeddings and ontologies.
  • Applying the method to a wider range of domains and tasks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Several recently proposed methods aim to learn conceptual space representations from large text collections. These learned representations associate each object from a given domain of interest with a point in a high-dimensional Euclidean space, but they do not model the concepts from this domain, and can thus not directly be used for categorization and related cognitive tasks. A natural solution is to represent concepts as Gaussians, learned from the representations of their instances, but this can only be reliably done if sufficiently many instances are given, which is often not the case. In this paper, we introduce a Bayesian model which addresses this problem by constructing informative priors from background knowledge about how the concepts of interest are interrelated with each other. We show that this leads to substantially better predictions in a knowledge base completion task.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bouraoui2018learning,
  author = {Zied Bouraoui and Steven Schockaert},
  title = {{Learning Conceptual Space Representations of Interrelated Concepts}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=SyW1NEzdZH},
}
Figure