TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel method for learning the structure of latent variable models, particularly when dealing with "unknown unknowns" – unmodeled latent factors that confound observed variables. By adapting composite likelihood methods and leveraging a structured canonical correlation analysis framework, the approach efficiently discovers hidden dependencies without explicitly modeling all potential latent variables.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In many scientific domains, we're interested in measuring unobservable quantities (like job satisfaction or analytical ability) using observable data (surveys, tests). Traditional latent variable models assume a known structure where observed variables are linked to specific, intended latent variables. However, real-world data often contains confounding effects from other, unmodeled latent variables. These "unknown unknowns" can distort our understanding of the intended latent variables. This paper tackles the challenge of identifying the structure of these confounding latent variables and their impact on observed data, even when we don't know their exact number or nature beforehand.
Methods
The core of the paper lies in a structured canonical correlation analysis (CCA) approach. Instead of traditional CCA which partitions variables into two sets, this method assumes a partition of observed variables where each subset is associated with a specific "known" latent variable. The key innovation is learning the bi-directed edges in a mixed graphical model, which represent the influence of these "unknown" latent variables.
The authors propose a composite likelihood approach, specifically a pairwise composite likelihood, to learn this structure. This method breaks down the complex joint likelihood into a product of simpler, pairwise likelihoods, making computation more tractable. They adapt an Expectation-Maximization (EM) framework, but with a novel twist: instead of directly optimizing the composite likelihood, they optimize a lower bound derived from the EM algorithm. This allows for more robust structure learning and avoids getting stuck in local optima, especially when dealing with discrete structure learning. They also introduce a "single-shot" algorithm that tests each potential bi-directed edge independently, offering a faster but potentially less accurate alternative.
A crucial component is the use of Cumulative Distribution Networks (CDNs), which provide a flexible framework for modeling conditional distributions of observed variables given latent variables. CDNs offer parameter modularity, meaning parameters in different parts of the model can be optimized independently, simplifying the learning process.
Datasets
The paper evaluates its methods on:
- Synthetic Data: Generated networks with varying numbers of latent variables and children, and bi-directed edges. This allows for controlled experiments to assess performance metrics like slope error, edge omission, and edge commission.
- Real-World Data: The 2009 National Health Service (NHS) Staff Survey, a large dataset with over 156,000 respondents. This dataset is used to demonstrate the practical utility of the method in modeling job satisfaction and work conditions, comparing the learned mixed graph model against a standard, fixed-structure model.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Unknown Unknowns" are Key: The paper highlights that ignoring unmodeled latent variables can lead to misspecified models and inaccurate conclusions. Their method explicitly aims to uncover the structure imposed by these hidden confounders.
- Structure Learning via Bi-directed Edges: The focus on learning bi-directed edges in a mixed graph is a novel way to represent the influence of unmodeled latent variables without explicitly defining them.
- Composite Likelihood for Scalability: Breaking down the complex problem into pairwise composite likelihoods is a smart strategy for handling high-dimensional data and complex dependencies, making the problem computationally feasible.
- EM Lower Bound for Robustness: Using a lower bound derived from the EM algorithm for structure learning helps to avoid local optima and leads to more reliable structure discovery compared to direct optimization of the bound.
- CDN Parameter Modularity: The use of CDNs simplifies the optimization process by allowing independent optimization of parameters, a significant advantage in complex models.
Key Results
- Synthetic Studies: The proposed LEARNSTRUCTUREDCCA-II algorithm (Algorithm 2) generally performed as well as or better than other methods (LSC-I, LSC-0) in terms of slope error and edge omission, while substantially reducing false positive "edge commission" errors. While performance at very small sample sizes (1000) was challenging for all methods, Algorithm 2 showed significant improvements at larger sample sizes (5000, 10000).
- NHS Staff Survey: The mixed graph CCA model (MCCA) demonstrated at least as good, and often better, predictive performance (measured by Area Under the Curve for logistic regression tasks) compared to a standard, fixed-structure model. This suggests that incorporating learned bi-directed structures improves the quality of latent representations for downstream tasks.
Limitations and Future Work
- Computational Cost: The parameter fitting step, even with the proposed methods, remains computationally expensive in high-dimensional settings.
- Scalability of Parameter Estimation: The authors suggest that more efficient algorithms could be achieved by relaxing the restriction that parameters must be the same across different likelihood components or by improving gradient optimization methods.
- Adaptive Partitioning: The current method assumes a fixed partition of observed variables. Future work could explore adaptive structures for this partition.
- Missing Data: The current framework assumes no missing data. Extending it to handle missing observations would be a valuable direction.
Summary updated