Large-scale project system management based on Hall three-dimensional structure

Rui ZhangProceedings of the 2018 4th International Conference on Humanities and Social Science Research (ICHSSR 2018) 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Modern project management is deeply integrated into various societal sectors, yet large-scale projects present unique challenges due to their high costs, extensive research periods, and complex interdependencies. This paper explores the application of systems engineering methodologies to large-scale project management. By adapting the Hall three-dimensional structure, the author proposes a simplified "Project Management Activity Matrix" to provide a systematic and practical framework for managing complex project lifecycles.

Introduction: The Complexity of Large-Scale Projects

Large-scale projects, such as major infrastructure developments or aerospace programs, are not merely larger versions of standard projects; they are complex systems. They involve significant financial investment, long durations, and a multitude of stakeholders and subsystems. Traditional management techniques often struggle with these complexities because they lack a holistic, systematic perspective. The primary challenge lies in integrating diverse resources effectively while maintaining a balance between cost, quality, and progress.

The Hall Three-Dimensional Structure

To address these challenges, the paper utilizes the Hall three-dimensional structure, a cornerstone of systems engineering introduced by A.D. Hall in 1969. This framework provides a comprehensive way to visualize the different facets of a system across three primary axes:

  1. Time Dimension: Represents the chronological phases of a project, from initial planning to final retirement.
  2. Logical Dimension: Outlines the thinking procedures and problem-solving steps required at each phase (e.g., problem definition, optimization, decision-making).
  3. Knowledge Dimension: Encompasses the various professional fields and disciplines required to execute the project, such as law, engineering, and management.
Hall's three-dimensional structure

The Project Management Activity Matrix

While the 3D structure is theoretically robust, it can be difficult to apply as a day-to-day management tool. The author simplifies this model into a two-dimensional Project Management System Activity Matrix. This matrix focuses on the intersection of Time and Logic:

  • The Rows (Time): The project lifecycle is condensed into four key stages: Project Phase, Design Phase, Implementation Phase, and the Closing Stage.
  • The Columns (Logic): Management logic is refined into five essential steps: Prediction, Decision, Plan, Control, and Feedback.

This results in a 20-cell matrix ($A_{11}$ through $A_{45}$), where each cell defines a specific, mandatory management activity. For example, $A_{34}$ focuses on controlling emergencies during the implementation phase, while $A_{25}$ involves feeding back survey data to refine design plans.

Key Insights and Systemic Thinking

The core contribution of this framework is the treatment of project management as systems engineering. Key insights include:

  • Continuous Feedback: Unlike linear models, the matrix integrates "Feedback" as a logical requirement for every stage of the project, ensuring that information from later stages informs ongoing planning and control.
  • Dynamic Objectives: The framework acknowledges that goals in large projects are not static. They are part of a dynamic development process where changes in design or external factors must be systematically reflected in the project's behavior.
  • Management as a Safeguard: By defining specific tasks for every intersection of time and logic, the matrix acts as a comprehensive checklist, ensuring that critical functions are not overlooked due to the project's scale.

Conclusion

The Project Management System Activity Matrix provides a "unified way of thinking" for project managers. By mapping out the necessary activities across the project's lifecycle, the framework helps maintain order and coordination in complex environments. While the model currently focuses on the intersection of time and logic, future developments could further integrate the "Knowledge" dimension to tailor the matrix for specific industries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nowadays project management has been deeply rooted in various fields and places of society. It plays an important role in social life. The large project management with a large-scale and costly, involving broad, longer study period and other characteristics. The application of systematic methods to manage it is an inevitable trend in the development of project management. Hall three-dimensional structure is a typical methodology of system engineering. This paper applies its application for large project to a systematic description of large projects. On the base, the project management activity matrix is proposed to form a new management method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018large,
  author = {Rui Zhang},
  title = {{Large-scale project system management based on Hall three-dimensional structure}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2018 4th International Conference on Humanities and Social Science Research (ICHSSR 2018)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2991/ichssr-18.2018.56},
}
Figure