Large-eddy simulation of ship tracks in the collapsed marine boundary layer: a case study from the Monterey Area Ship Track experiment

A. Berner, Christopher S. Bretherton, Robert Wood

TL;DR

This paper presents the first large-eddy simulation (LES) of a ship track using a coupled aerosol-cloud model, initialized with real-world aircraft data. The simulation successfully reproduces key observed features of ship tracks, including albedo enhancement and drizzle suppression, offering new insights into aerosol-cloud interactions in a specific marine boundary layer environment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how aerosols, particularly those from anthropogenic sources like ships, influence cloud properties and climate is a major challenge in atmospheric science. Ship tracks, visible lines of altered cloud properties caused by ship emissions, serve as natural experiments to study these aerosol-cloud interactions. However, accurately simulating their formation and evolution, especially in complex boundary layer conditions, is difficult. Previous modeling efforts often relied on simpler, one-dimensional models that couldn't capture the full three-dimensional dynamics and horizontal dispersion of ship tracks. This paper addresses this gap by using a sophisticated LES model to simulate a well-observed ship track case, aiming to better represent the interplay between aerosol, turbulence, and cloud processes.

Methods

The authors employ a Large-Eddy Simulation (LES) model (System for Atmospheric Modeling, SAM version 6.9) coupled with a bulk aerosol microphysics scheme. This approach allows for the explicit simulation of turbulent eddies and their impact on cloud formation and aerosol dispersion. A Lagrangian framework is used to track a segment of the ship track, allowing for a detailed study of its evolution over an extended downwind distance. The model is initialized using detailed aircraft observations from the Monterey Area Ship Track (MAST) experiment. Sensitivity studies are conducted by varying background aerosol concentrations, ship track injection strength, and the orientation of the ship track relative to the prevailing wind and boundary layer rolls. A simplified cloud albedo model is also used to partition the observed albedo changes into contributions from the first and second aerosol indirect effects.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for initialization and validation is from the Monterey Area Ship Track (MAST) field campaign, specifically data from the UK Meteorological Office (UKMO) Meteorological Research Flight (MRF) C-130 aircraft sampled on June 13, 1994. This dataset includes profiles of wind components, liquid water content, total water, cloud droplet concentration, and temperature. Satellite imagery from the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES) is also used for context. ERA-Interim reanalysis data is used for subsidence estimates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LES is crucial for capturing ship track dynamics: The 3D nature of LES is essential for simulating the turbulent mixing and horizontal dispersion that significantly influence ship track evolution and width, which 1D models cannot replicate.
  • Roll structures strongly influence track broadening: The alignment of the ship track with existing boundary layer rolls dramatically affects how quickly the track disperses, with tracks oriented perpendicular to the rolls broadening much faster.
  • Second indirect effect becomes dominant over time: While the initial albedo increase in ship tracks is largely driven by the Twomey effect (first indirect effect), the second indirect effect (changes in cloud macrophysics like liquid water path and cloud fraction) becomes increasingly important over longer timescales.
  • Drizzle suppression plays a key role: In certain conditions, particularly in shallow, collapsed boundary layers, ship tracks can suppress drizzle, leading to increased liquid water path and a stronger albedo enhancement.
  • Environment matters for indirect effects: The sign and magnitude of the second aerosol indirect effect can vary significantly depending on the background aerosol concentration and the presence of precipitation. In polluted environments, the second indirect effect can even be negative.

Key Results

  • The LES simulation successfully reproduces the observed albedo enhancement and drizzle suppression within the ship track.
  • The simulated track width is found to be sensitive to the orientation relative to boundary layer rolls, with perpendicular tracks broadening more rapidly.
  • In the baseline simulation, the albedo increase is initially dominated by the first indirect effect, but the second indirect effect becomes comparable or more significant by the end of the simulation.
  • In a high-aerosol sensitivity study with weak drizzle, the Twomey effect dominates, resulting in a smaller albedo enhancement compared to cases with stronger drizzle.
  • The model captures the organization of the ambient boundary layer into mesoscale rolls, consistent with observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Track elevation not simulated: The observed 100m elevation of the ship track above the surrounding layer was not reproduced, possibly due to the LES model quickly sharpening the weak inversion.
  • Aerosol source strength uncertainty: The exact aerosol source strength and alignment with background rolls introduce uncertainties, making a perfect match in aerosol concentration and track width unrealistic.
  • Model physics and forcings: Discrepancies between simulation and observations may be due to biases in the model forcings or limitations in the model's microphysics and aerosol physics.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that comprehensive ship track observations in a wider range of environments are needed to further test and improve aerosol-cloud interaction models. They also highlight the challenge of parameterizing cloud-aerosol interactions due to the wide range of possible effects observed.

Summary updated

Abstract

For the first time, a large-eddy simulation (LES) coupled to a bulk aerosol scheme is used to simulate an aircraft-sampled ship track. The track was formed by the M/V Sanko Peace on 13 June 1994 in a shallow drizzling boundary layer with high winds but very low background aerosol concentrations (10 cm−3). A Lagrangian framework is used to simulate the evolution of a short segment of track as it is advected away from the ship for eight hours (a downwind distance exceeding 570 km). Using aircraft observations for initialization, good agreement is obtained between the simulated and observed features of the ambient boundary layer outside the track, including the organization of cloud into mesoscale rolls. After eight hours, a line of aerosol is injected to start the ship track. The simulation successfully reproduces the significant albedo enhancement and suppression of drizzle observed within the track. The aerosol concentration within the track dilutes as it broadens due to turbulent mixing. A sensitivity study shows the broadening rate strongly depends on the alignment between the track and the wind-aligned boundary layer rolls, as satellite images of ship tracks suggest. Entrainment is enhanced within the simulated track, but the observed 100 m elevation of the ship track above the surrounding layer is not simulated, possibly because the LES quickly sharpens the rather weak observed inversion. Liquid water path within the simulated track increases with time even as the ambient liquid water path is decreasing. The albedo increase in the track from liquid water and cloud fraction enhancement (second indirect effect) eventually exceeds that from cloud droplet number increases (first indirect or Twomey effect). In a sensitivity study with a higher initial ambient aerosol concentration, stronger ship track aerosol source, and much weaker drizzle, there is less liquid water inside the track than outside for several hours downwind, consistent with satellite estimates for such situations. In this case, the Twomey effect dominates throughout, although, as seen in satellite images, the albedo enhancement of the track is much smaller.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{berner2015large,
  author = {A. Berner and Christopher S. Bretherton and Robert Wood},
  title = {{Large-eddy simulation of ship tracks in the collapsed marine boundary layer: a case study from the Monterey Area Ship Track experiment}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-15-5851-2015},
}

Loading related content...

Figure