Abstract
This paper extends the derivation of the Lagrangian averaged Euler (LAE-$\alpha$) equations to the case of barotropic compressible flows. The aim of Lagrangian averaging is to regularize the compressible Euler equations by adding dispersion instead of artificial viscosity. Along the way, the derivation of the isotropic and anisotropic LAE-$\alpha$ equations is simplified and clarified. The derivation in this paper involves averaging over a tube of trajectories $\eta^\epsilon$ centered around a given Lagrangian flow $\eta$. With this tube framework, the Lagrangian averaged Euler (LAE-$\alpha$) equations are derived by following a simple procedure: start with a given action, Taylor expand in terms of small-scale fluid fluctuations $\xi$, truncate, average, and then model those terms that are nonlinear functions of $\xi$. Closure of the equations is provided through the use of flow rules, which prescribe the evolution of the fluctuations along the mean flow.
Introduction
In fluid dynamics, the Euler equations describe the motion of inviscid fluids. While foundational, these equations present significant challenges when modeling "small-scale" phenomena such as turbulence and shock waves. In these regimes, the mathematical solutions can become singular or computationally unstable. Traditionally, researchers have addressed this by "regularizing" the equations—adding artificial viscosity to dissipate energy at small scales, effectively turning kinetic energy into heat.
However, adding viscosity is not always physically appropriate, particularly in systems where energy conservation is a priority or where the physical mechanism of dissipation is not purely viscous. This paper explores an alternative: Lagrangian averaging. Instead of damping energy through dissipation, the authors propose redistributing it through dispersion. By extending the Lagrangian Averaged Euler (LAE-$\alpha$) framework from incompressible liquids to barotropic compressible gases, the authors provide a method to smooth high-frequency fluctuations while preserving the underlying variational structure of the physics.
The Tube Framework and Variational Derivation
The authors utilize a variational approach, performing the averaging at the level of the system's energy functional (the Lagrangian) rather than on the final partial differential equations (PDEs). This ensures that the resulting equations respect fundamental symmetries and conservation laws.
1. The Tube of Trajectories
The core of the method is the "tube framework." The authors imagine a tube of possible fluid trajectories, $\eta^\epsilon$, centered around a mean flow, $\eta$. This represents the uncertainty or fluctuation inherent in the fluid's motion at scales smaller than a characteristic length $\alpha$.
2. Taylor Expansion and Truncation
The fluid's action is expanded in terms of small-scale fluctuations, $\xi$. By truncating this expansion at the second order ($O(\epsilon^2)$) and taking the average, the authors isolate the influence of small-scale dynamics on the large-scale mean flow.
3. Flow Rules and Closure
A critical challenge in averaging nonlinear equations is the "closure problem"—determining how the small-scale fluctuations evolve in relation to the mean flow. The authors introduce "flow rules" to bridge this gap:
- Advection Rule: Fluctuations are assumed to be "frozen" into the mean flow, moving with it as passive scalars.
- Rotation Rule: Fluctuations are rigidly transported and rotated by the local vorticity of the fluid.
These rules allow the mathematical derivation to be separated from the physical modeling, providing a flexible framework where different rules can be applied depending on the specific fluid behavior being studied.
Key Insights: Dispersion and Enthalpy
The parameter $\alpha$ represents a spatial scale. Below this scale, rapid fluctuations are smoothed out by dispersion—waves spreading out—rather than energy disappearing through viscosity. This maintains the Hamiltonian structure of the system.
In the compressible case, the derivation reveals a deep connection to thermodynamics. The averaged equations naturally incorporate enthalpy ($w$), showing that the averaging process is intrinsically linked to the fluid's internal energy and pressure-density relationships. The resulting system introduces a "modified momentum" ($\rho v$) and "modified pressure" ($\tilde{p}$) that account for the effects of the $\alpha$ scale, providing a more robust set of equations for numerical simulation.
Isotropic vs. Anisotropic Formulations
The paper provides two distinct versions of the LAE-$\alpha$ equations:
- Anisotropic: A more complex version that captures direction-dependent fluctuations, essential for flows with strong directional biases.
- Isotropic: A simplified version assuming fluctuations are uniform in all directions. This version is more computationally efficient but relies on the rotation flow rule.
Limitations and Future Research
While the mathematical framework is robust, the authors identify several areas for future development:
- The Initialization Problem: A significant hurdle remains in determining how to "filter" the initial state of a real fluid to provide the correct starting conditions for the averaged equations.
- The 1D Constraint: Because the isotropic model relies on vorticity for its flow rule, it currently fails in one spatial dimension where vorticity is zero.
- Entropy and Shocks: The current work assumes a barotropic fluid (where pressure depends only on density). To model very strong physical shocks where temperature changes are significant, the framework must be extended to include entropy.
- Numerical Validation: The theoretical derivation is complete, but the efficacy of these compressible equations must now be tested in numerical simulations to compare their performance against traditional Large Eddy Simulations (LES).
Conclusion
This paper provides a unified framework for the Lagrangian averaging of compressible fluids, simplifying previous incompressible derivations while extending the theory to gases. By prioritizing dispersion over dissipation, the LAE-$\alpha$ model offers a promising path for regularizing fluid equations without losing the essential variational characteristics of the underlying physics.
Summary updated