Abstract
We investigated turbulence in atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) using a minimally destructive, impurity injection technique analogous to particle image velocimetry in conventional fluids. Our approach transfers small regions of the BEC into a different hyperfine state and tracks their displacement, ultimately yielding the velocity field. This allows us to quantify turbulence in the same way as is conventional in fluid dynamics, using velocity-velocity correlation functions called velocity structure functions that obey a Kolmogorov scaling law. Furthermore, the velocity increments show a clear fat-tail non-Gaussian distribution that results from intermittency corrections to the initial "K41" Kolmogorov theory. Our observations are fully consistent with the later "KO62" description. These results are validated by a 2D dissipative Gross-Pitaevskii simulation.
Introduction
Turbulence is a universal phenomenon, yet its behavior in quantum fluids—where flow is irrotational and rotation is restricted to quantized vortices—has remained a subject of intense debate. While classical turbulence is well-described by Kolmogorov’s 1941 theory (K41), which predicts energy cascades across length scales, it was previously unclear if a collection of quantum vortices would statistically mirror classical fluid dynamics at macroscopic scales. Direct measurement of local velocity fields in ultracold atomic gases is notoriously difficult, often relying on indirect methods like Time-of-Flight expansion. This study bridges the gap by implementing a novel "tracer" technique to directly observe turbulence scaling laws in a 2D Bose-Einstein Condensate (BEC).
Experimental Methodology: Cold-Atom PIV
To overcome the challenges of measuring local velocities, the researchers developed a cold-atom version of Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV). This technique allows for the direct observation of the velocity field $\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{x})$ within the quantum gas.
The process involves several key steps:
- Tracer Injection: A spatially resolved Raman laser pulse "flips" small regions of atoms into a different hyperfine state. These atoms serve as tracers that move with the bulk fluid but can be imaged independently.
- Excitation: A 2D disk-shaped BEC of $^{87}$Rb atoms is stirred using "rods" of light controlled by a Digital Micromirror Device (DMD) to induce a turbulent state.
- Velocity Mapping: By tracking the displacement of these tracers over a short interval $\Delta t$, the local velocity field is mapped.
- Statistical Analysis: The team calculated Velocity Structure Functions (VSFs), $S_p(l)$, which measure the $p$-th order moments of velocity differences over a distance $l$. This is the standard metric for turbulence in classical fluid dynamics.
Key Results: Scaling and Intermittency
The experimental data, validated by 2D dissipative Gross-Pitaevskii equation (dGPE) simulations, provided a quantitative confirmation of classical turbulence theories in a quantum system.
The study yielded several landmark insights:
- Kolmogorov Scaling: The second-order structure function $S_2(l)$ followed the $l^{2/3}$ power law predicted by K41, demonstrating that at large scales, quantum turbulence statistically mimics classical fluids.
- Intermittency and KO62: The velocity distributions exhibited "fat tails" (high kurtosis), meaning extreme velocity fluctuations occur more frequently than predicted by simple Gaussian models. This confirms the KO62 theory (Kolmogorov’s 1962 refinement), which accounts for the intermittent nature of energy dissipation. The extracted intermittency coefficient was $\chi \approx 0.04$.
- Direct Energy Cascade: Unlike classical 2D fluids, which typically exhibit an inverse energy cascade (small to large scales), this quantum system showed a direct cascade (large to small). This is attributed to the annihilation of quantized vortices, which allows energy to leave the system at small scales.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
This work provides a robust experimental framework for studying quantum turbulence using PIV, successfully bridging the gap between quantum and classical fluid dynamics. While the current study focused on decaying turbulence, future research could utilize "continuously replenished" BECs to investigate steady-state turbulence. Such experiments would allow for even more precise tests of the energy cascade and the role of quantized vortices in the emergence of classical statistical laws.
Reference: Zhao, M., Tao, J., & Spielman, I. B. (2025). Kolmogorov scaling in turbulent 2D Bose-Einstein condensates. arXiv:2408.04715v2.
Summary updated