Abstract
Educational technology is a new subject that integrates the merits of multiple disciplines. Under the trend of interdisciplinary integration, it is very meaningful to explore the knowledge exchange between disciplines, clarify the structure of each discipline, and thus promote the development of educational technology. Extracting data from eight core journals on educational technology, this paper investigates the integration between educational technology and other disciplines from the perspectives of references and citations. The disciplines were divided by the standard of China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI). The results show that: educational technology has a stable disciplinary structure, featuring a high self-citation rate (i.e. the tendency to cite the literature within the discipline); educational technology has frequent knowledge exchanges with pedagogy-related disciplines, and exerts a major impact on the other secondary disciplines of pedagogy; educational technology actively absorbs the knowledge of other disciplines, and communicates frequently with external disciplines like psychology, computer science, library and information science.
Introduction
Educational Technology (ET) is inherently complex, situated at the intersection of pedagogy, psychology, and engineering. While its interdisciplinary nature is widely acknowledged, descriptions of its structure have historically been qualitative, relying on expert intuition. This research provides a quantitative "map" of the ET landscape in China by analyzing over 50,000 references and 35,000 citations from core journals. By clarifying the "knowledge exchange"—who ET cites and who cites ET—this paper establishes a data-driven boundary for the discipline and predicts its future evolution.
Methodology
The study employed Citation Analysis, a bibliometric technique used to reveal the internal laws of a discipline through statistical methods. The researchers utilized the Chinese Citation Database (CCD), focusing on 5,945 papers published between 2014 and 2018 across eight core ET journals in the Chinese Social Sciences Citation Index (CSSCI).
To ensure accuracy, the team used a dual-standard classification: domestic Chinese journals were categorized using China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) standards, while foreign journals followed Web of Science (WOS) standards. The analysis distinguished between "references" (knowledge input) and "citations" (knowledge output/impact).
Knowledge Input: Domestic vs. International Perspectives
The analysis reveals a stable core for ET, but also highlights significant differences in how domestic and international research communities influence the field.
Domestic Knowledge Sources
In the Chinese academic context, ET shows a high degree of self-reliance. As shown in Figure 1, Educational Technology itself accounts for 36.6% of references, followed by Distance Education at 21.2%. This indicates a mature, self-sustaining disciplinary structure within the pedagogical cluster.
International Knowledge Sources
When looking at foreign references, the disciplinary mix shifts significantly. While "Education & Educational Research" remains the primary source, there is a much higher integration of technical and behavioral sciences. Psychology accounts for 19% of foreign references, and Computer Science contributes 7%, suggesting that international ET research is more heavily focused on behavioral analysis and engineering methodologies than its domestic counterpart.
Knowledge Output: ET as an Innovation Hub
ET is not merely a consumer of ideas; it acts as a vital knowledge exporter. The study found that ET exerts a major impact on secondary education, vocational education, and adult education. These fields extensively borrow ET theories and methods—such as instructional design and digital resource management—to drive their own development. Furthermore, the diffusion of ET knowledge reaches as far as Medical Education and Sociology, demonstrating the broad utility of educational tools across diverse sectors.
Key Insights: The "Matthew Effect" and Interdisciplinary Bridges
A critical finding is the high self-citation rate (36.6% for ET specifically; 57.8% for the broader pedagogy cluster). While this stability is a sign of maturity, the authors warn of a potential "Matthew Effect," where a field becomes so self-referential that it restricts communication with outside disciplines.
However, a significant bridge exists with Library and Information Science. ET has borrowed heavily from this field for technical methodologies like data mining, learning analytics, and visualization analysis. Keyword clustering further identified research frontiers such as Smart Education, AI-integrated learning, and Maker Education as key areas where these disciplines converge.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The research confirms that Educational Technology has established a stable disciplinary core while serving as an interdisciplinary hub. To maintain its growth, the authors suggest that ET must overcome its current "weak information absorption capacity" by more aggressively integrating emerging fields like neuroscience and brain science. Moving forward, the discipline's ability to synthesize pedagogical innovation with cutting-edge technology will remain its defining characteristic.
Summary updated