Abstract
Smart teaching is the main direction of education and teaching mode change in the new era. This paper takes the research literature on wisdom teaching mode in the context of engineering education in the past ten years as a sample, adopts bibliometric method and visual analysis to examine the research lineage of wisdom teaching mode, reveals the hot research topics and research status in this field and further elaborates the future research trend of wisdom teaching, which provides reference for the research on wisdom teaching mode in the context of engineering education.
Introduction
As engineering education becomes increasingly globalized—highlighted by China joining the Washington Agreement in 2013—traditional "chalk and talk" methods are failing to keep pace with the digital age. While "smart teaching" (or wisdom teaching) is touted as the solution, the sheer volume of new research makes it difficult for educators and policy-makers to identify core trends and effective strategies. This study performs a meta-analysis of the field to identify core researchers, "hot" topics, and the evolution of research from 2012 to 2022, providing a roadmap for future education informatization reforms.
Methodology
The researchers employed bibliometric analysis and visual mapping using data sourced from the China Knowledge Network (CNKI), a primary database for Chinese academic work. The dataset consisted of academic literature related to "smart teaching" in an engineering context indexed between 2010 and 2021. VOSviewer software was utilized to construct and visualize bibliometric networks, allowing for the clustering of keywords, authors, and institutions. Impact and centrality were determined through publication counts and citation frequencies.
Analysis of Research Trends
Growth in Publication Volume
The research landscape remained relatively stagnant until 2016, after which publication volume exploded. This inflection point is attributed to national policy shifts in China prioritizing education informatization.
As shown in the figure above, publications grew from 40 articles in 2012 to a peak of 913 articles in 2020. The slight decrease to 757 articles in 2022 suggests the field has reached a "bottleneck" period, transitioning from rapid quantitative growth to deeper, more specialized qualitative research.
Keyword Co-occurrence and Research Hotspots
Keyword analysis reveals that the field is organized into four distinct clusters: teaching modes, teaching environments, teaching platforms, and teaching concepts.
A significant portion of high-impact research revolves around specific platforms like "Rain Classroom," which emerged as a dominant tool for hybrid teaching. This indicates that practical, platform-specific implementation currently outweighs abstract theory in the literature. Furthermore, the COVID-19 pandemic acted as a catalyst, normalizing the transition to intelligent education scenes.
Key Results and Influencers
The study identified Xiaoling Zhou and Yonghe Wang as the most prolific authors in the field. Despite the high volume of work, the research community remains decentralized. In terms of impact, Zhen Yang’s 2020 paper on hybrid teaching models via smart platforms stands as the most influential recent work, garnering 20 citations within the sample period.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While this study provides a comprehensive quantitative map of the Chinese-language research landscape, it is limited by its exclusion of international databases. Future research should explore the qualitative efficacy of these models—specifically their impact on engineering student outcomes. The authors predict the next frontier will be the "deep integration" of AI and Big Data, moving toward personalized, student-centric learning where AI can address individual learning differences in real-time.
Summary updated